E.19:2 - Problem
Without a stated, common review method, reviewers and authors face four problems.
- Different reviewers focus on formal or template compliance and miss deeper ontological, semantic, and naming issues, producing bureaucratic output that does not improve the enforceable Conformance Checklist.
- Authors “optimize for the visible checklist” and miss hidden requirements (lexical discipline, Bridge hygiene, SoTA‑Echoing quality, scope claims, delta‑class impact).
- Older patterns accumulate conceptual staleness and diverge from current practice, current terminology, or current internal invariants.
- Compliance comes to depend on reviewer taste. That makes the specification’s normative content harder to trust and prevents a repeatable review decision.