E.24:4.2 - Check 2: Stable Identity Test
A candidate qualifies as a durable ontic only when it has stable identity beyond one local wording issue, source expression, or bounded local episteme used for first explanation.
Ask:
- What exact candidate entity, proposal episteme, or source-construct entity is independently identifiable before judgment, and what direct rule identifies it as the fixed EntityOfConcern of the decision episteme?
- Which exact result payload follows from each available disposition without replacing that fixed EntityOfConcern: closing assertions, a bounded episteme, a selected ontology-unit individual, or an unresolved reason?
- What changes the identity of that ontic?
- What does not change ontic identity, even if an ontic-description episteme, publication form, notation, view, or presentation carrier changes?
- Which direct world-side relations and grounding conditions are required for identity?
- Which dependent patterns may rely on that identity?
If durable identity is not established, use an existing assertion or a bounded local episteme under C.2.1 when it meets its threshold in §4.3. Otherwise return the unresolved question about the identified decision subject. If no decision subject can be identified, retain the inquiry material.
Test the invariant against the subject before filling a relation field:
| Governed subject | Identity, constitution, or recognition rule | Relation-set consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Holon or System | A.1’s exact candidate, constituents, constructive part relations and assembly, reidentification, whole-level characteristic, larger-assembly compatibility, and any kind-specific condition | keep those facts under their subject patterns; A.1 explicitly forbids compressing them into one universal relation signature |
| Method | A.3.1’s semantic way-of-doing identity and any independently governed method-holarchy facts | name only the direct relations needed by dependent method use; no head relation is presumed |
| Work | A.15.1’s dated occurrence identity and continuity rule | performer, enacted method, affected referent, resources, and results stay under their exact direct relations or A.6.1 bindings |
| Transformation | A.3.4’s independently identified actual bounded change at the selected resolution | work, flow, production, representation, and receiving-use relations remain separate; no core relation is invented |
| Episteme | C.2.1’s constitution rule | EpistemeConstitutionRelation is identity-bearing because C.2.1 explicitly selects it; empirical grounding, edition, conformance, and publication remain neighboring relations |
| Relation | A.6.REL plus each direct relation pattern’s obtaining and occurrence-identity rule | the ontology unit coordinates common occurrence discipline with those direct rules; no relation-to-relation head occurrence is required |