E.3:4 - Solution
E.3:4.1 - Principle Taxonomy
For this precedence classification, assign each principle exactly one class from { Gov, Arch, Epist, Prag, Did }.
| Class | Scope & Purpose | Example Pillars |
|---|---|---|
| Gov (Governance) | Change process, community decision‑making | P‑10 Open‑Ended Evolution - P‑11 SoTA |
| Arch (Architectural) | Macro‑structure & invariants | P‑1 Cognitive Elegance - P‑4 Kernel |
| Epist (Epistemological and Ontological) | Semantics, evidence, trust | P‑3 Scalable Formality - P‑8 Consistency |
| Prag (Pragmatic) | Real‑world value & cost/benefit | P‑7 Pragmatic Utility |
| Did (Didactic) | Cognition & learnability | P‑2 Didactic Primacy - P‑6 Lexical Stratification |
Epistemological sub‑concerns (reasoning, falsifiability) reside inside Epist, keeping semantics and trust in one class.
E.3:4.2 - Precedence Stack
Each precedence node is an applicable pillar, derived principle, guard or assurance requirement, or local policy. The table identifies its source level; it does not rank every sentence in one file above every sentence in another. In particular, level 1 is the Eleven Pillars, not the entire E.2 file.
| Level | Governing Artefact | Overrides |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | Vision & Mission (E.1) | everything |
| 1 | Eleven Pillars (E.2) | all below |
| 2 | Principles (this pattern) | patterns & DRRs |
| 3 | Architectural / Definitional patterns | local rules |
| 4 | Tooling & Pedagogy | informative only |
Default class order. Identify the applicable rules and their source levels. Within the higher-rule boundaries, apply any explicit priority governing this pair. Only an otherwise unresolved conflict uses the default class order:
Gov ≫ Arch ≫ Epist ≫ Prag ≫ Did
Unresolved conflict. These relations form a partial order. Two incompatible applicable rules may remain tied or incomparable after the source-level, explicit-priority and class comparisons. Return that pair, the shared action and applicability conditions, and hold the dependent action. Unrelated actions remain governed by their applicable rules. Acyclicity does not guarantee a winner.
To resolve the hold, refer the pair to the authority empowered to amend the affected rules or their priority under their governing change process. That authority may adopt a priority or amend a rule’s scope. Record the rationale, affected scope, Pillar Impact Analysis and edge effects under E.9; an exception also retains its required expiry. The DRR records the decision and does not itself authorize