F.3:9 - Self-checks
- Same-conclusion test. Do the source uses establish the same relevant meaning and preserve the conclusions needed here? If so, merge. If the available passages cannot settle the comparison, retain the unresolved difference and identify the missing basis.
- Argument probe. Substitute the participants from one use into the other. Split when this exposes incompatible source-required participant kinds or semantic roles. A false instance alone does not establish another sense: “Alice is licensed” and “Bob is licensed” can differ in truth while using
licensedwith the same meaning. - Entailment probe. Does one use imply an occurrence while the other implies a description, kind, or status? Split.
- Label inversion. When a Plain label is used, read it alone. If it invites a broader claim, ti