G.4:11 - SoTA-Echoing
These sources contribute to the CAL clauses or extensions identified below under the stated conditions. Reconsider the affected use when its source assumptions or adopted contract change.
| Source and adopted contribution | Use in CAL | Applicability limit | Return when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Angelopoulos, Bates, Fisch, Lei, and Schuster, Conformal Risk Control, ICLR 2024 — adapt bounded monotone-loss risk control only for a CAL clause whose statistical assumptions are explicit. | C3 and CC-G4-04 require loss, risk/coverage target, calibration population/window, exchangeability or declared shift treatment, and failure/abstain behavior before such a clause is published. Only an actual application under §4.4a supplies the required binding and verdict. | “Conformal”, a calibration set, or a coverage target does not make a universal acceptance guarantee, authorize deployment, or establish that evaluation occurred. | Reopen only C3, CC-G4-04, and the one worked clause/test that claims this guarantee when its assumptions or guarantee change. |
Fontaine, Togelius, Nikolaidis, and Hoover, Covariance Matrix Adaptation for the Rapid Illumination of Behavior Space, GECCO 2020 — adapt only the need to pin descriptor, distance, insertion, archive, and reporting policy when G.4:Ext.NQD is used. | C6, G.4:Ext.NQD, and CC-G4-13 keep QD method semantics in C.18 while making the CAL wiring reproducible. | Archive occupancy, coverage, QD-score, or the presence of CMA-ME wiring is not dominance, acceptance, selection, or a runtime result. | Reopen only C6, G.4:Ext.NQD, CC-G4-13, and its one NQD example/test if the adopted descriptor/archive contract changes. |
| Wang et al., Enhanced POET: Open-ended Reinforcement Learning through Unbounded Invention of Learning Challenges and their Solutions, ICML/PMLR 119 (2020) — reject as a source of G.4 core or acceptance semantics; retain it only as an exact lineage reference for optional exploration wiring under the applicable pattern. | C6 and CC-G4-11 require an exact current pattern and present-task entry and stop condition before any exploration extension is admitted; no POET-specific rule enters the CAL core. | Open-ended generation, transfer, or progress telemetry does not become a CAL acceptance rule, task authority, or selected governor by citation. | Reopen only C6, CC-G4-11, and the exact C.19/C.23 extension block if the applicable pattern explicitly adopts a changed POET-family rule set. |
Use A.18/A.19 for comparison, partial-order and selected-set rules. Distributionally robust and broader multi-objective methods are further candidates to investigate when the receiving question needs them. Revisit only the clauses, extensions and applications that depend on a changed source claim.
G.4:11.1 - CAL architecture and publication inventory
The charter fixes the pack’s scope and assumptions. Typed operators and clauses define admissible applications; flows compose them; evidence profiles and the ProofLedger expose their required grounds. The TaskMap connects these declarations to selection. Later applications bind actual inputs and produce results under §4.4a. Extensions add only the method-specific declarations needed by that use.