Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:10:10 UTC

HCD.2 - Compose and Compare Human Capability-Development Programmes for Later Work

Type: Human Capability Development practitioner programme-composition pattern Status: Stable

HCD.2:0 - Use This When

Use this pattern when one named person has a recoverable later-Work demand and a practitioner, manager, or that person needs to construct or compare ways of developing the required contributions, including finding out whether a candidate is feasible. Begin with the person’s current mastered and supported configuration, the complete later-Work tasks, and the conditions of participation.

The first useful result is a programme-comparison account. It describes the candidates considered, the tasks each could complete, the division of contributions and access, their burden, uncertainty, evidence needs and applicability. Identify the smallest change that would warrant reconsideration. If only one candidate remains feasible, describe it and the limits on comparison. If none satisfies a binding condition, identify that condition. An authorized decision holder can use the comparison when a choice is requested.

The comparison shows what each programme would change relative to what the person can already do with available support. The practitioner can see whether a proposed component completes a usable contribution, preserves a prerequisite, adds a future option, or merely displaces practice that another required result still needs. When another start competes with unfinished learning, §4.2a compares continuing, pausing and starting together.

The personal comparison uses a qualified account of demand. Diagnosis, programme selection, observed learning and provider competence each require their own grounds. When the current recipient is a learning-product author who does not yet know the learners, return the outputs, audience assumptions, existing alternatives, resource boundary, and individualization questions to HCD.28. It constructs and compares the whole learning product; its conditional variants and requirements can then supply this personal comparison. A named person’s compatible Work, entry performance, support, and participation conditions are the retry inputs for personal comparison.

HCD.2:0.1 - Working Terms

Name in this patternWhat it denotes
human holderThe identified person whose development is being considered. Evidence about an audience or cohort needs a basis for transfer to this individual.
current mastered and supported configurationThe contributions the person can currently make under stated conditions, together with references, AI, tools, specialists, and other supports available under those conditions. Identify any capability or access that is still assumed.
capability-development programmeA bounded arrangement of preparation, representative attempts, feedback, correction, retries, access, and later checks intended to help the person make specified contributions in later Work. A learning product may support parts of the programme. Evidence about the person is needed to establish that development occurred.
complete work taskA representative later-Work task whose required result, critical errors, human contributions, supporting contributions, and stopping conditions are sufficiently present to guide programme composition.
contribution allocationA statement of what the person must recognize or perform, what may be retrieved from a reference, what controlled AI help may supply, and what a specialist or other provider must contribute. Several allocations may coexist in one task.
access allocationThe tools, sources, people, environments, permissions, timing, and support conditions that a programme assumes or must obtain. Intended help, permitted help, actual availability, and help received in an attempt remain different facts.
comparable programme descriptionOne candidate described against the same holder, later-Work outputs, protected errors, horizon, evidence posture, and resource coordinates as the other candidates.
learning-product design returnA product-design question for HCD.28 for an author who has audience hypotheses but no personal holder evidence. It preserves the product question; HCD.28 returns candidate variants and requirements, while HCD.2 still needs the relevant personal evidence.

The programme, its description, a later decision to adopt it, the Work that enacts it, and observed human development require different work and evidence. HCD.2 constructs and compares programme descriptions.

HCD.2:1 - Problem Frame

A person may need to recognize when a professional Method applies, retrieve a precise rule, perform a calculation, challenge an AI proposal, and obtain a specialist result in one piece of later Work. A syllabus can mention every topic and still fail to make that combination attainable. Conversely, requiring the person to memorize every detail can waste scarce time and remove useful support already present in the Work.

Different people can have different starting capabilities and support. Compare candidates for one person against that person’s baseline. One person may already perform the routine operation but miss a hazardous mismatch. Another may need a prerequisite before a whole task is useful. A third may be capable with a reference and specialist return but not under unsupported conditions. Time, participation, project access, teacher capacity, and the cost of later checking can change which programme is feasible.

The practitioner therefore needs to compose bounded alternatives around complete work tasks and compare what the person and outside contributors would supply under that person’s support and resource conditions. Judge a longer, newer, better-documented or differently named programme by the contribution it would make to the required work.

HCD.2:2 - Problem

The common shortcut is to translate a demand into topics, allocate hours, and call the result a programme. This hides whether the pieces combine in representative Work, whether practice and correction fit inside the budget, and whether the assumed teacher, data, AI, specialist, or project access exists.

A second shortcut starts with one polished programme and compares every rival with its documentation rather than with the same required result. The detailed candidate then appears to dominate because its assumptions and costs are visible while the others remain sketches.

A third shortcut assigns an audience profile to every future learner. It converts a course-design hypothesis into a personal diagnosis and can recommend development without same-holder evidence. Return a personal comparison when the inputs support it. For a future audience, return a learning-product design question. For a named person whose inputs are insufficient, identify what the comparison still needs.

HCD.2:3 - Forces

  • Complete tasks expose coordination and critical errors, while some prerequisites need preparation before meaningful whole-task practice.
  • Internalized performance can reduce access delay, while reliable references, tools, AI, and specialists can be legitimate parts of later Work.
  • A detailed programme is easier to inspect, while unequal detail is not evidence that it contributes more.
  • Personalization can remove redundant work, while role labels and audience averages do not establish one person’s starting capability.
  • A finite time budget forces displacement, while hidden reading, preparation, provider Work, and retries are easy to leave outside the count.
  • Early supported performance can enable practice, while it does not establish later independent, changed-condition, or delayed performance.
  • One candidate may be the only feasible option now, while feasibility alone does not establish dominance, effectiveness, or a final choice.
  • Programme design can reveal missing access or provider capability, while the description does not make that support available.
  • Future options can be valuable, while speculative option value must not replace the required near-term work result.

HCD.2:4 - Solution

Use or construct comparable descriptions of each candidate as a finite change from the person’s current mastered and supported configuration. Keep complete later-Work tasks, human and external contributions, practice and correction, resources, evidence limits, and future options visible on one comparison basis. Return what the comparison establishes to its intended recipient. A choice uses the relevant decision rule and authority.

HCD.2:4.1 - Bind the Personal Comparison

Name:

  1. the person whose programme is being compared and the basis for their participation;
  2. the question or decision the comparison will serve, its recipient and any decision holder, later-Work family, configuration, horizon, and protected result or critical-error conditions;
  3. a compatible HCD.1 demand account or equivalent qualified later-Work input;
  4. the current performance evidence, supported contributions, unresolved gaps, and any HCD.3 target or HCD.4 profile that the comparison actually uses;
  5. the professional Methods, target-domain criteria, source access, tools, AI posture, specialists, provider contributions, environment, authority, and time that matter to the candidates, distinguishing what is available from what remains assumed; and
  6. the development result required of the candidates. Keep a proposal to change that result separate.

HCD.1, HCD.3, and HCD.4 can supply these inputs. Compatible direct evidence is enough for the positions the current comparison consumes. Use diagnosis only when rival causes would change the programme.

If personal evidence, participation, later Work, or support conditions are missing, stop the personal comparison at the affected claim. For an unknown audience, issue the learning-product design return to HCD.28. When a product variant comes back for a named person, test its entry assumptions, intended contribution, assistance and burden against that person’s compatible evidence before using it as a programme candidate. Use an applicable domain result for the Method or correctness criterion. If a domain judgement is still needed, return that question and its available evidence to the practice able to answer it, or identify the missing contribution if its source is unknown. If no candidate can make the supplied development stake feasible, return that constraint and the surviving alternatives to the separate navigation or target decision rather than weakening the stake inside HCD.2.

HCD.2:4.2 - Compose Task-Closing Candidates

  1. Select representative complete tasks. State the required result, important variants, critical errors, Work products, conditions, and stopping rules. Use the topic or Method name to locate the actual task.
  2. Decompose only far enough to allocate contributions. For every material contribution, state what the person must recognize and perform, what the person may retrieve from an applicable reference, what controlled AI help or other support may supply, and what requires a specialist or other provider. Identify the human check when the intended task requires one.
  3. Separate prerequisites from simultaneous complements. A prerequisite must be available before the relevant practice can proceed. A reference, tool, or specialist contribution may instead remain part of the same later Work. Do not teach every complement as if it had to become unaided personal performance.
  4. Construct finite changes from the baseline. Add, substitute, remove, or retain programme elements relative to the person’s current configuration. Explain which task combination each change is intended to close, any future option it opens, and which existing contribution it might displace or weaken.
  5. Include the complete development loop. Account for preparation, demonstrations or explanations where useful, the representative attempts, feedback, correction, retries and changed-condition or later checks that the intended contribution requires. Include the access and provider work needed to carry them out.
  6. Identify any planning or provision still needed. Use existing suitable results where they suffice. HCD.5 can select a development Method, HCD.6 can design practice tasks, and HCD.7 can establish what support is available. For a missing contribution, HCD.8 can compare obtaining or building it, establish what preparation has been completed and identify the operating evidence still needed. A representative test can supply that evidence when needed and feasible. HCD.9–HCD.10 address practice and progression. Give enough detail for the comparison and distinguish proposals from results already obtained.

Recover the required constituent performances and their coordination within each complete task, using FPF B.1.5.EW when those connections are unclear. Identify which contributions must be present together during the encompassing work and how the person and other participants provide them. Adequate performance of isolated constituents can leave their coordination unavailable. Keep already attained contributions and include development only for the missing or insufficiently transferable ones. Include the variety of constituent Methods that the intended task variants require; a single rehearsed path may leave the person unable to choose a different continuation. Check shared time, attention, equipment and assistance as a combined demand rather than counting the same available resource separately for every part.

For example, in a stipulated dance case, strength and recall of the figure are adequate but balance during rotation is not. A programme adds suitable rotational-coordination practice and return to the figure under varied relevant conditions; it need not repeat the already mastered strength and recall work. HCD.3 distinguishes that gap from other causes, HCD.6 designs the practice and HCD.10 distributes its variation. Use a suitable domain exercise and performance criterion, obtaining qualified help if they still need to be established.

When the comparison depends on how a contribution develops, use an applicable HCD.4 local model or describe the relevant progression on the available evidence. Name which entry evidence makes each route usable, which qualitative change it proposes and what evidence supports the relations it relies on. HCD.6:4.2.1 supplies task and help alternatives; compare their whole learner/provider burden and the observation that could redirect them. Do not count crossed model nodes as equal units of gain or require every candidate to follow one presumed ladder. In the N24 case (HCD.6:5.6), contrast-first and supported-performance-first routes have the same target but different entry reliance, preparation and learning opportunities. The selected plan remains revisable; it is not the person’s recorded trajectory.

HCD.2:4.2a - Compare a New Start with Unfinished Learning

When another component would start alongside unfinished learning, recover what is still needed for the contributions already being developed before treating the addition as feasible. A learning line here is the remaining development towards one declared task contribution or a bounded future option. Several exercises can belong to one line; completing an exercise need not close that line.

Start from the person’s current programmes and recent attempts, including paused work that still needs maintenance or would incur a restart cost. For each relevant line, recover the intended later use and its threshold under allowed support, what the person has already demonstrated, and what remains unsupported. Describe any practice, feedback, learner correction or further check still needed for that use. Include the provider and access windows that make them possible. Include a delayed or unassisted check only when the intended use requires it.

Compare the proposed new start with continuations that finish an existing contribution, preserve necessary practice, or deliberately pause or retire a line. Compare the benefits and costs still at stake. A future option can justify a new start, but name what the bounded exploration will make possible or settle and when it returns for a decision. Calling every new topic an option leaves no stopping condition.

Construct a feasible boundary on concurrent learning for each candidate. Place the remaining attempts, feedback and correction in the available learner and provider windows. Check attention blocks, shared tools and any assistance needed at the same time. Count a shared activity once when it serves several lines, while retaining different observations needed for different claims. Include maintenance, transition and restart costs of a pause. A sum of course hours can fit even when feedback arrives too late for correction or two lines need the same scarce practice window.

State which lines can remain active together and under what condition another can start: for example, an existing contribution is closed to its declared criterion, one line is paused with its consequences accepted, or additional usable capacity becomes available. The result can be a conditional set of compatible lines rather than a fixed count. Splitting one line into more modules does not change its remaining demand. Carry this boundary and its protected work into the programme comparison; the authorized decision owner still chooses whether to start, continue or pause.

Use observations of attempts and the help received, from HCD.9 or another suitable source. A successful episode removes only the remaining work its evidence settles; the wider contribution can still need a changed-case attempt or another required check. HCD.11–HCD.13 supply stronger observations only where the intended claim needs them. Failed correction, a changed later task or a lost provider window changes the remaining work or feasible boundary through HCD.14 or, for continuing development, HCD.15. When the required result is established, remove the completed work from the open set while retaining any needed maintenance. These changes can tighten or widen the boundary.

HCD.2:4.3 - Make the Descriptions Comparable

Describe every candidate on the same conditions and consequences that matter to the question.

Comparison positionRequired content
holder and useHuman holder, recipient, participation basis, later-Work family, configuration, horizon and receiving question or decision. Name the decision holder if there is a choice.
current configurationSupported current contributions, protected strengths, unavailable values, uncertainty, and evidence window.
intended task closureComplete tasks and outputs the programme is intended to make attainable, including protected errors and variants. Keep intended attainability separate from observed learning.
contribution allocationHuman recognition and performance, reference use, controlled AI help and human checking, specialist returns, and other provider contributions.
preparation and sequenceTrue prerequisites, simultaneous complements, dependency reasons, and any replaceable or optional ordering. Printed topic order is not a capability hierarchy.
practice and evidence planThe representative attempts, permitted help, feedback, correction and retries needed for the stated claims. Include changed-condition or delayed checks when the claim requires them, and say what each observation can establish.
access and provider basisAvailable and assumed sources, tools, AI, people, environments, permissions, capacity, peak load, and missing enablement.
resources and displacementLearner time, provider time, preparation, assessment, transition, tool or material burden, and the useful activity displaced by the change. For concurrent unfinished learning, include the remaining commitments and pause/restart consequences from §4.2a.
uncertainty and source limitsEvidence for each expected contribution, unsupported effect claims, transfer and retention limits, and the observation that could change the estimate.
continuationFuture options opened, preserved or closed; applicability conditions; the feasible boundary on concurrent learning where relevant; exact constraint or evidence gap; and smallest change that reopens the comparison.

Unequal detail is a comparison gap when it hides a difference that matters to the receiving use. Develop only the smallest missing fragment needed to compare the same task, output, conditions, support, and resource coordinates. Do not require complete competing courses when one closed task family can discriminate the alternatives.

HCD.2:4.4 - Compare the Finite Programme Changes

Use C.11.CRC to compare each realizable candidate configuration with the person’s current configuration. Name the baseline, finite change, including an addition, substitution, removal or retention, candidate configuration, horizon, scenarios, result and resource coordinates, interactions, uncertainty, transition, reversibility, and option effects.

For HCD.2, the decision-bearing coordinates normally include:

  • closure of the required later-Work outputs and protected critical-error conditions;
  • learner, teacher, assessor, specialist, tool, and transition burden;
  • dependence on references, AI, cues, project access, authority, and provider availability;
  • preservation of current strengths and practice needed by other contributions;
  • the expected performance under the stated conditions and the evidence needed for any claims about supported or independent performance, changed conditions, transfer or retention after a delay; and
  • future development options and the cost of reopening a closed route.

Use dominated, non-dominated, beneficial, harmful, or indeterminate only for the candidates, coordinates, horizon, conditions, and evidence actually compared. A programme is not non-dominated merely because it was generated, and one feasible candidate is not dominant merely because no rival is ready. HCD.2 supplies the comparison claim; C.11 supplies any later bounded choice from the complete choice inputs.

HCD.2:4.5 - Return the Programme-Comparison Account

Return one account containing:

Result positionRequired content
comparison boundaryHolder, later Work, supplied development stake, recipient, any decision holder, candidates, horizon, conditions, participation, evidence window, and direct outside owners.
candidate descriptionsThe comparable positions in §4.3 for every actual candidate, including any one candidate that remains feasible.
comparison claimsSupported relative contribution, burden, dependence, uncertainty, displacement, and option claims; any dominance relation is explicitly bounded.
access allocationsIntended human, reference, AI, specialist, provider, environment, permission, and timing contributions, with actual availability distinguished from assumption.
evidence and gapsSources and observations supporting each claim, missing values, unsupported stronger claims, and the conclusion each gap blocks.
dispositioncomparable candidates, one feasible candidate with comparison gap, current candidate set infeasible, personal comparison blocked with the exact missing input and its receiving owner, or learning-product design return for an unknown audience. A programme choice is a separate result.
continuationThe smallest comparable fragment, provider result, personal observation, budget change, target decision, or other condition that permits the next comparison or choice.

If a final choice is requested, the authorized decision holder can use the comparison under the applicable decision Method. Preserve the options, preferences, belief state, outcome model, protected conditions and any authority still needed. For an inquiry that could improve the choice, include its expected contribution and full cost. Authorization, commitment, launch and actual learning effects each require grounds of their own.

HCD.2:4.6 - Recognition and Assurance

Recognition. Use HCD.2 when the live question sounds like “Which way could this person become able to do the whole job?” and the alternatives differ in preparation, practice, support, time, or future options. The smallest useful result may be one comparable task fragment rather than a complete curriculum.

Assurance. Stronger reliance needs same-holder and condition-compatible inputs, qualified target-domain tasks and error criteria, credible provider and access claims, complete resource coordinates, and explicit evidence limits. A programme can be compared before it is chosen or run. Effectiveness, transfer, retention, provider operation, and personal development require their own observations.

HCD.2:4.7 - What Changes in Practice

Ask which proposed change could make the person’s complete later-Work tasks attainable, which contributions each participant would supply, what the work would cost and what evidence is still missing. For a future audience with no named learner, return the product-design question. An existing course can supply one candidate.

HCD.2:5 - Archetypal Grounding

HCD.2:5.1 - Constructed Personal Case: Learner-FP6

Learner-FP6 is the learner in this constructed case. The stipulated entry attempt shows that this person can build a device model but confuses a flow unit, the recipient of the result, and the organizational permission needed for the proposed action. The intended later-Work outputs, mandatory tasks, 340 learner-hour limit, available teacher and worked examples, and protected critical errors are held fixed for this comparison. No observation of actual learning is claimed.

Two six-hour candidates replace harder optional cases rather than add time:

CandidateFinite change and intended contributionBurden, dependence, and evidence gap
focused preparationAllocate two hours to selecting the result recipient, two to checking the required organizational permission and tracing consequences for other systems, and two to checking flow units and constraints before the next whole task. The mandatory tasks, later variation, and final result remain unchanged.Uses an explicit prerequisite route and keeps teacher feedback inside the existing arrangement. It may isolate the three weaknesses clearly, but the comparison still needs a changed-condition whole-task attempt to show whether the contributions combine.
supported whole-task preparationUse the same six learner hours for a complete decision task in which the person must calculate with the flow unit, address the right recipient, and obtain or respect the required permission. A worked example and bounded teacher questions support the first attempt; a changed case then removes answer-revealing help.Tests integration earlier but may conceal which prerequisite failed. Selecting, demonstrating, and reviewing the extra case consumes teacher preparation and feedback Work that must fit an established capacity or be priced separately.

HCD.2 returns two comparable descriptions, the common output and evidence plan, and the unresolved provider-load and changed-condition evidence. An independent attempt showing three separable errors would strengthen focused preparation; success on the components but failure to combine them would strengthen the whole-task candidate. Either observation reopens only the affected comparison claims.

HCD.2:5.2 - Unknown Audience: FoundationsProgramme A, B, and C

A learning-product author has two intended outcomes: checked performance of complete selected work tasks, and lower effort to learn a previously untaught Method while preserving correctness. These are design aims, not observed gains. The author has an audience hypothesis, three 340-hour compositions, and no named learners. A allocates 202/96/42 hours to general/domain/joint application, B allocates 88/204/48, and C allocates 136/136/68. C is described in more detail; that detail does not establish dominance.

The HCD.2 boundary returns a learning-product design question to HCD.28: preserve the two outputs, audience assumptions, three alternatives, learner and teacher resource coordinates, support assumptions, and individualization questions. Use C’s existing material and develop the missing A or B material only far enough to compare one complete task family with the same output, entry assumptions, representative attempt, feedback, retry, access, and resource account. Do not fabricate one future learner or require three complete courses before comparison becomes useful.

If the learner budget falls from 340 to 204 hours while both outputs remain fixed, none of the three original candidates is launchable as described. Multiplying every activity by 0.6 or hiding reading and practice outside the budget does not close the task. If a 204-hour option is requested, construct a candidate that accounts for the 136 hours removed or replaced and preserves a credible way to attain the outputs. If none is feasible, report that limit. The separate 240-hour teacher calculation does not replace learner time or establish a competent available service. A 170-hour ThinkingFoundations-only offer answers a narrower output question and therefore is not an improved version of the same candidate set.

HCD.2:5.3 - One Feasible Candidate Is Not a Winner

A named person has a qualified near-term engineering task and strong entry evidence. Only one candidate currently fits the deadline and available project access; a second candidate depends on an unavailable specialist. HCD.2 may return the feasible candidate, its finite comparison with the current configuration, and the exact specialist result that blocks the other candidate. Its feasibility under these conditions does not establish effectiveness or dominance over the unavailable alternative. A later provider result, deadline change, or changed task reopens the bounded comparison.

HCD.2:5.4 - Two Unfinished Lines and an Attractive New Start

In this constructed case, Lena has six learner-hours and two 45-minute sessions with a suitably qualified teacher in the coming week. The sessions can each return feedback early enough for a learner correction and subsequent check. The programme must preserve preparation for Friday’s report. A second line concerns work next month; a simulation method might open a further project option.

Recover the remaining contribution of each line:

LineExisting evidence and remaining useful resultRemaining burden in this window
A — justify a dashboard anomalyLena computes the indicator correctly. She still needs to distinguish two plausible explanations, select a discriminating observation and correct her reasoning on a changed case under the allowed reference. This is needed for Friday’s report.Two learner-hours for attempt, feedback use, correction and check; one 45-minute teacher session, including preparation and review.
B — adapt a data queryA query works on the practised structure. The remaining task is to adapt it to a changed structure and check the result with the permitted reference. No further topic reading is needed on the stipulated evidence.Two learner-hours and one 45-minute teacher session for the remaining attempt, correction and check.
C — explore simulationThis is a proposed start, not an acquired contribution. One supported model and a contrast with the current analysis would inform whether a further simulation programme is worth constructing. That decision ends this exploration.Two learner-hours and one 45-minute teacher session for the bounded exploration and its review.

All three fit the six learner-hours but need 135 teacher-minutes; only 90 are available. Counting A’s completed calculation and B’s completed query as closed learning would conceal this competition. There are at least two comparable continuations that preserve Friday’s requirement:

  • Continue A and B; defer C. Four learner-hours and 90 teacher-minutes are allocated to the two remaining task contributions. The allocations leave actual completion to be established by the subsequent work.
  • Continue A and open C; pause B. The same four learner-hours and 90 teacher-minutes supply A and the exploration. On the stipulated pause arrangement, preserving B’s partial work takes another half-hour now and returning to it requires a further half-hour next month. Its remaining practice is still owed, and its later use must tolerate that delay.

The two continuations have different closure, option and transition consequences. HCD.2 returns those differences and the conditions under which each of these two combinations fits the learner’s and teacher’s windows. Lena’s choice is separate. If the next project now requires simulation while B’s later use is cancelled, opening C and retiring B can become preferable; unfinished status is not a reason to retain obsolete work.

Under the original work estimates, a confirmed third timely teacher session would make the three-line candidate feasible at six learner-hours and 135 teacher-minutes. This widens the available comparison without establishing that taking all three is preferable.

Suppose instead that A’s next attempt reveals another correction requiring one learner-hour and a further 45-minute teacher session before Friday. A now consumes three learner-hours and both sessions. The previous two-line continuations no longer fit. With the same help, a candidate can keep only A active and pay B’s half-hour pause cost: 3.5 learner-hours and 90 teacher-minutes. Retaining B or starting C as described requires additional suitable help or a changed arrangement. HCD.9’s result changes the remaining work; use HCD.14, or HCD.15 for continuing development, to reopen the affected comparison.

HCD.2:6 - Bias-Annotation

Recurring biasLikely driftRepair
course-solution biasThe requested course or familiar programme is treated as the answer before later Work and baseline are recovered.Begin from the holder, complete work tasks, current configuration, and supplied development stake.
detailed-candidate biasThe most documented candidate appears superior to sketches.Where the unequal detail affects the comparison, complete the smallest comparable fragment for the required task.
topic-count biasCoverage or PatternID count substitutes for contribution to later Work.Trace every included element to task closure, a prerequisite, a support contribution, an evidence need, or a future option.
role-average biasAudience or role assumptions become one person’s current profile.Use compatible evidence about the named person. If it is missing, identify the affected claim and what it needs. For an unknown future audience, return the product-design question.
support invisibilityTeacher, assessor, specialist, AI, access, and preparation are assumed free and available.Record access allocations, actual availability, peak load, and missing enablement separately.
assistance attributionHelped output is treated as independent human capability or learning.Distinguish permitted and available help from the help actually received. Qualify claims about independent, changed-condition or delayed performance by their observations.
sunk-curriculum biasExisting content is retained because it was expensive to create.Compare the finite contribution and displacement of retaining it under the current task and budget.
technique-brand biasA pedagogy label is assumed to work across holders and tasks.State its proposed mechanism, source limit, required observation, and serious alternative.

HCD.2:7 - Conformance Checklist

  • The person whose programme is in question is identified for a personal comparison; an unknown audience receives a learning-product design return rather than an invented profile.
  • The later-Work family, supplied development stake, protected outputs and errors, configuration, horizon, participation, evidence window, recipient and any required decision holders or outside contributors are explicit.
  • The baseline contains only supported current human and external contributions under stated conditions.
  • Each candidate explains how the person’s and others’ contributions would combine to complete a recognizable later-Work task, or how that combination could be tested.
  • Human recognition and performance, reference retrieval, controlled AI help and checking, specialist returns, and other provider contributions are allocated explicitly.
  • True prerequisites are distinguished from supports and complements used during the same later Work.
  • Preparation, representative attempts, feedback, correction, retries, changed-condition or delayed checks, and provider/access work appear where needed for the intended results.
  • Candidates use the same decision-bearing output, error, burden, support, horizon, uncertainty, and future-option positions; unequal detail that affects the comparison is identified as a gap.
  • Learner, teacher, assessor, specialist, transition, tool, material, and displaced-work burdens are visible where they change the comparison.
  • When another start competes with unfinished learning, the comparison recovers remaining work, compares closure with opening an option, and states which lines can remain active together, when another may start and what would change that boundary.
  • Supported, independent, changed-condition, transfer, and retention claims remain distinct, and unobserved gains remain hypotheses.
  • Any dominance wording is bounded to the candidates, coordinates, horizon, conditions, and evidence actually compared.
  • The recipient can identify what the comparison establishes, its limits and the smallest change that would reopen the affected comparison. A choice, authorization, launch, actual provider operation or effect draws on the evidence or authority for that separate claim.

HCD.2:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them

Anti-patternWhy it failsRepair
“Give everyone programme C”Detail and a broad audience description do not establish personal fit.Keep C as one design candidate; obtain same-holder inputs before personal comparison.
“This programme covers more topics”Topic count says nothing about task closure, displacement, support, or evidence.Compare contributions to complete later-Work results and protected errors.
“Scale 340 hours to 204”Uniform scaling can remove preparation, attempts, feedback, or correction that makes the output plausible.Name every removed or replaced hour and show how the required mechanisms and outputs remain available.
“Teacher hours make it feasible”A time calculation does not establish competence, access, scheduling, or operation at peak load.Use a suitable HCD.7 or direct result. If support is missing, HCD.8 can compare obtaining or building it and identify the preparation and operating evidence the selected route needs.
“AI support means the person knows it”Assisted performance can differ from later unassisted performance.Allocate the human checking contribution and preserve actual help in every observation.
“Every component is a prerequisite”A printed sequence turns legitimate same-task references and specialists into unnecessary memorization or gates.Separate before-practice prerequisites from simultaneous complements and supports.
“One feasible candidate dominates”Missing rivals or evidence do not create a supported dominance relation.Return the feasible description and the exact comparison gap.
“HCD.2 chooses and launches”Comparison is collapsed with preference, authority, commitment, and execution.If a choice is requested, give the authorized decision holder the comparison needed to make it.
“The course author is the learner”Recipient and holder are silently merged.Keep the author and learner distinct. Return a product-design question for a future audience. For a named learner, use compatible individual evidence or identify the input still needed.

HCD.2:9 - Consequences

The practitioner gains a comparison that connects development activities to complete later Work, exposes external support before commitment, and states which conclusions are supported and which remain uncertain. A small comparable fragment can be enough to improve a decision, so the method does not require building several complete courses first.

Constructing and comparing the candidates takes work. The programme itself can be infeasible because of learner or provider time, access, transitions, retries, displaced practice or the cost of obtaining later evidence. Some requests return to learning-product design, provider enablement, target-domain owners, or a separate target decision rather than yielding a personal recommendation.

HCD.2:10 - Rationale

What one programme adds depends on what this person can already contribute, what support is actually available, which complete tasks matter, and which protected errors cannot be traded away. Starting from an empty curriculum exaggerates every addition; starting from a role average fabricates the holder.

Whole tasks reveal coordination and applicability, while identifying each contribution shows what the person must do, which references, AI or specialists can help and what must already be in place. Comparing finite changes keeps resources and displaced work visible. Separating comparison from choice protects preference, authority, commitment, launch, and evidence of effect as their own questions.

HCD.2:11 - SoTA-Echoing

How should a practitioner compose and compare a development programme for one person’s consequential later Work without reducing it to topics or promising an unobserved effect?

The programme comparison combines sufficiently whole complex-task practice with expertise-sensitive support, explicit correction and retesting where those mechanisms fit, and configuration-relative finite comparison. The maintained 4C/ID model and its fourth-edition presentation supply the serious complex-task design candidate: whole learning tasks, support for non-routine reasoning, timely procedural information, and additional practice for recurrent parts. Paas and van Merriënboer’s 2020 review (COG-05) supports changing guidance with prior knowledge and task complexity. Winget and Persky’s 2022 review (COG-06) supplies the bounded formative-assessment, corrective-activity, retest, and threshold arrangement. HCD.2 adapts these contributions into §§4.2–4.3; none establishes later professional performance or the effect of a local programme.

The serious ordinary alternative is a syllabus-first or branded-programme comparison: list content and hours, match them to a role profile, then prefer the most complete or familiar package. A syllabus is quick to describe; when it leaves complete-task closure, same-holder starting evidence, contribution allocations, provider dependence, displaced work, or unequal detail unclear for the decision, add the comparison needed to resolve them. A syllabus can describe a candidate when it shows how its content contributes to the required work.

C.11.CRC supplies the internal finite-comparison grammar used in §4.4. HCD.2 uses the expectations, applicable observations and further evidence needed to compare programmes. Use the relevant HCD methods to assess instruction, supported attempts, independent performance, transfer or retention under their own conditions. Bastani and colleagues’ 2025 school-mathematics trial (AI-04) is counterexample evidence that improved AI-assisted practice can fail to improve later unassisted performance; its population and task do not supply an adult workplace effect size or a universal AI prohibition. These limits produce the separate evidence states in §§4.3–4.6 rather than a promised causal programme effect.

The additional design and evidence work is useful when the programme decision depends on complete-task performance, personal fit, support, burden or uncertainty left unresolved by the available syllabus. Reopen the selected line if a stronger source changes the complex-task, support, correction, AI-dependence, or transfer boundary, or if representative use shows that the same decision values can be preserved with materially less effort.

HCD.2:12 - Relations

  • HCD.1: can supply the compatible human capability-demand account and later-Work boundary; programme composition does not alter that demand.
  • HCD.3: can supply a qualified human target or non-training return when the distinction between plausible causes matters to the programme comparison.
  • HCD.4: can supply the current/target claim comparison, protected strengths, priorities, and trade-offs; a profile does not generate programme alternatives.
  • HCD.5: selects human-development Methods for the target contribution and evidence limits exposed by a candidate.
  • HCD.6: designs representative practice tasks, permitted help, variations, and result criteria needed by the selected Method.
  • HCD.7: establishes which provider, source, tool, AI, access, and human-check contributions are actually available.
  • HCD.8: compares obtaining or building a specified missing contribution. Identify the preparation achieved and the evidence that the selected route works for its intended use. Use existing adequate evidence or a representative test where needed and feasible. HCD.7 can arrange support already established.
  • HCD.9 and HCD.10: carry out focused practice and change its variation, spacing, interleaving, challenge, or help while preserving attempt history.
  • HCD.11–HCD.13: provide compatible observed performance, transfer, retention, and support-dependence evidence.
  • HCD.14 and HCD.15: revise affected programme assumptions and parts, or reopen development when later Work or support changes; changes in remaining work or available help can revise the boundary on concurrent learning.
  • C.11.CRC: supplies the finite configuration-relative comparison claim. C.11 separately supplies a bounded choice when its required inputs and conditions hold.
  • Decision Design and other advice Methods: may recommend a programme to a named recipient from qualified inputs; advice does not compose the missing programme or make the choice for its owner.
  • HCD.28: constructs and compares a whole learning product for a future audience, using HCD.5–HCD.8 and other applicable contributions. HCD.2 returns the unknown-audience question there and uses a suitable product variant when compatible evidence establishes its applicability to the person.
  • Learning-product and target-domain practices: supply applicable instructional/carrier construction and professional task correctness. HCD.28 coordinates the needed product contributions; HCD.2 can use an applicable domain result or return the unresolved domain question to the practice able to answer it.
  • Provider, clinical, safety, legal, employment, specialist, organization, and release owners: retain their direct competence, participation, authority, and consequence decisions.

HCD.2:End

Referenced in the corpus

88 literal mentions in other sections. Read their context to establish the relation.