HCD.20 - Compose and Compare Arrangements for Individual and Group Learning
Type: Human Capability Development practitioner learning-arrangement comparison pattern Status: Stable
HCD.20:0 - Use This When
Use this pattern to design or assess how individual and shared participation could support a learning target. Identify the target, what the learners bring or are expected to bring, and whether interaction supplies a contribution the task needs. Determine whether the needed actions, help and resources fit.
Return the supported comparison or feasibility finding. Specify the actions required of each learner, contributions from others, task-group size, assistance, access and full burden. Identify which conclusions the proposed or available observations can support. An individual arrangement can suffice, several options can remain viable, or a particular condition can rule one out. If a choice is requested, identify its grounds.
Distinguish the enrolled cohort, the groups that perform a particular task, any continuing peer circles and the providers available to help. Twenty-four people can enroll together and work in six groups of four, with a separate allocation of mentors.
For routine booking or assignment of settled groups, use the existing arrangement. Use HCD.28 for the whole learning product and HCD.22 for designing a shared task. When the request is solely for a competent joint result, organize the work for that result. If the assignment also requires learning, keep the necessary personal opportunities in the comparison. To judge team or organization capability, use evidence about that holder and its work.
HCD.20:0.1 - Working Terms
| Term | Meaning in this pattern |
|---|---|
| learning arrangement | A proposed, existing or selected combination of individual and shared activity, people, materials, timing, help and observation for a bounded learning purpose. |
| cohort | The people admitted to one offer or period. Size a task group for the activity its members perform. |
| task group | The participants who must interact for one bounded activity and result. Its size follows those actions and constraints. |
| peer circle | Relationships retained across episodes where continuity supplies a useful contribution. Membership can remain stable while task groups change. |
| individual contribution | The judgement, explanation, bodily action, coordination or other operation a particular learner must perform. |
| shared result | A work product or performance produced through several contributions. It may support learning. To assess a learner’s capability, establish the contribution they made and the conditions in which they made it. |
| peak demand | The contributions needed in the same relevant time window, qualified by provider competence and access. |
HCD.20:1 - Problem Frame
A provider chooses four-person groups because the platform makes them convenient. One member can already solve the task, two wait for the answer and one keeps time. The report is correct, but the intended model selection occurred only once. At a shared instrument, an observer predicts a reading and challenges a choice during someone else’s turn, then operates the instrument on their own turn. The two roles offer different opportunities to learn.
Both situations resist a universal preferred size. The limiting resource may be sequential explanation, access to an instrument, feedback, confidentiality or the effort of coordinating different schedules. Prior subject knowledge and experience of working together also change what help the arrangement needs.
A comparison must preserve the target contribution and include the costs carried by learners and providers. Reducing paid mentor minutes by requiring lengthy peer work shifts effort to the learners. Compare that added effort and the effect on the task with the provider time saved.
HCD.20:2 - Problem
Which individual or shared arrangements can supply the intended learning opportunities and make each learner’s contribution interpretable under the preparation, interaction, access and resource constraints? What limits the feasibility of a proposed arrangement?
HCD.20:3 - Forces
| Force | Tension |
|---|---|
| Shared resources and personal action | Participants can share information, equipment and help, while each may still need to perform the target operation. |
| Diversity and coordination | Different knowledge and grounds can enlarge the available reasoning, while language, timing and background differences can make their use harder. |
| Continuity and variation | Stable relationships can reduce repeated coordination, while a new partner or example can expose an untested assumption. |
| Immediate group performance and learning | A strong member can improve the common answer while removing another member’s useful attempt. |
| Total and peak capacity | The overall staffing allowance can suffice while the actual feedback window remains impossible. |
| Flexible participation and dependence | Individual routes can remain viable while some shared tasks need a particular contribution by a particular time. |
| Visible action and warranted inference | Participation can expose opportunities and failures; learning and transfer still need appropriate observations. |
HCD.20:4 - Solution
HCD.20:4.1 - Fix what must survive the comparison
Identify the learning target, the relevant later work, the contribution the learner needs to make, permissible help and critical errors. Identify any separately required shared product or team performance. If the purpose is responding to another person’s reasons, an isolated calculation exercise is not an equivalent comparator. If the purpose is performing a routine calculation reliably, extensive debate may add no required contribution.
For known learners, use available evidence of preparation and identify remaining uncertainty. For a future audience, state the entry assumptions. Distinguish insufficient subject preparation from unfamiliarity with the interaction. A learner may understand a model but not know how to request clarification or express an evidence-based objection; adding more subject explanation will not directly repair that interaction gap.
Retain a qualified individual or existing supported option as a baseline when it can serve the target. Identify what interaction could add, such as evidence unavailable individually, a recipient for an explanation, an alternative interpretation to challenge, shared access or coordinated action. Where group work offers no consequential gain, return the sufficient simpler option. If interaction is part of the target, compare arrangements that can supply it or identify the missing contribution.
HCD.20:4.2 - Derive different scales from the actual activity
Separate admission, immediate task groups, continuing relationships and provider assignment. Work from the action that needs capacity.
For sequential contributions, use an explicit time construction. If each of k participants needs r contributions of t minutes, and joint coordination needs c(k) minutes, the proposed activity requires at least k × r × t + c(k) within its window T. Include preparation or transitions elsewhere when they lie outside that window; include them here when they consume it. The necessary condition is k × r × t + c(k) ≤ T for this sequence. Check the availability of the people, inputs and equipment when each operation is due. A help visit also requires the learner and provider to be free together and the relevant inputs to be ready.
For a shared instrument, identify which actions require exclusive control and which can occur while someone else operates. For a proposed schedule, allocate the necessary personal turns and observer actions that support the target. For a past-use question, establish which participants performed them. For parallel annotation or drafting, inspect the later reading, comparison and integration burden: simultaneous writing does not make integration instantaneous.
Start with the smallest configuration that supplies the required contributions under the relevant constraints. Compare another configuration when an additional participant could improve the result or a different arrangement could reduce the burden. Use the task and feasible conditions to decide which options to retain.
Specify the contribution expected from an observer, such as predicting a reading, measuring, checking a condition, asking for a discriminating test or explaining a change. Merely watching or recording attendance does not establish that action. If personal instrument manipulation is part of the target, observation does not eliminate the necessary later hands-on attempt.
HCD.20:4.3 - Make the proposed composition usable
Select membership differences for a task-related contribution, using obtainable information. Relevant prior knowledge can provide contrasting interpretations; compatible time windows make the interaction possible; permission to share material determines which case can be used. Diversity by a convenient score does not prove that participants will exchange or use useful grounds.
Estimate the help required to bridge the intended differences. A novice paired with an expert may receive modelling, but can also become a spectator. Where the target includes the novice’s own judgement, give them an opportunity to make it and plan feedback they can use. A group of novices may require a qualified external check before its shared misconception becomes the lesson.
When an arrangement is to be put into use, establish the agreed time, channel, contributions and response expected at first contact. Use an existing adequate agreement. If a needed participant does not take part, restore the contribution, regroup on compatible terms or use a viable individual route. A roster records assignment; for a claim that contact occurred, establish what happened.
Retain a peer circle when familiarity supplies trust, context or useful continuing feedback. Change partners or admit a newcomer when a new contribution is needed and the transition can be supported. Introduce the current problem, relevant work, permissions and any decision still open. Give the group an opportunity to assess and use, adapt or decline the contribution on its grounds. To claim that it changed the work, establish what was used.
Use confidential material only under the permissions and protections that cover this group and use. Where disclosure would exceed them, use a permitted substitute that preserves the relevant relation, qualified private help or another viable route. An anonymized surface that removes the very condition to compare is not a usable substitute. Do not make disclosure of a real project a condition of access to a generally offered learning opportunity.
Use HCD.21 when membership, first contact or use of a newcomer’s contribution needs to be established. Return the resulting availability and coordination burden to the comparison. Use HCD.27 for personal entry and recovery windows when one common rhythm is unsuitable.
HCD.20:4.4 - Allocate the actions and assistance before counting savings
For each candidate, show which actions remain personal, which benefit from exchange, which produce a common result, and which require qualified provider judgement. Use HCD.22 where the shared task needs design. Other participants may identify an ambiguity or challenge an inference; they do not acquire the authority or competence of a subject assessor by receiving the role title.
Decide when the learner sees others’ solutions and whether their earlier personal work remains available. A private first attempt can preserve an initial judgement when that matters. Demonstration or other accessible instruction can supply a method the novice needs. Assign independent search only when it serves the learning purpose under the available support.
Identify the support each option requires, such as subject help, facilitation, material preparation, technical assistance and assessment. Use HCD.7 for the assistance arrangement where needed and HCD.8 for a missing contribution. A qualified available provider can undertake several kinds of work, provided their timing and combined effort permit it.
AI may supply a contrast, draft feedback or suggest a tutor move when its result can be qualified and used. Count preparation, choice, checking, correction and fallback. For a design intended to develop a learner’s judgement, preserve an opportunity for the learner to make it. For a claim about their performed judgement, establish what the learner did and what help they used. If AI supports an experienced mentor, retain the mentor’s subject competence and ability to reject an unsuitable suggestion.
HCD.20:4.5 - Compare full effort and the time of use
Compare proposed arrangements for the same intended result under comparable observation conditions. Check each option’s demands against obtainable capacity, or assess a single proposed route when that is the question. Include the burdens that affect feasibility or the comparison.
- learner preparation, personal attempts, exchange, reading others’ work, correction and recovery;
- author and provider preparation, qualification, facilitation, subject help and individual checking;
- coordination, channel and equipment access, permitted-material preparation and re-entry;
- waiting and peak demand, reserve capacity and work displaced elsewhere.
Count a shared expense once and recurring expenses where they occur. Keep learner time, specialist time, elapsed time and financial expenditure visible rather than collapsing them into an unqualified score. State which values are estimates and which come from operation.
Inspect the most demanding plausible window on a shared timeline for participants and providers. Place dependent actions after their inputs become available and identify when the learner can use a response. Combine simultaneous actions only where the people and equipment can support them. For planned visits, show which available provider could make each one, including preparation, movement and time for the learner to act. For an operational claim, establish the visits that occurred. Queuing a question works only while the dependent action can still take place. Count reserve capacity only when it supplies the needed competence, permission and availability.
When scaling the cohort, recompute the number of task groups and the relevant recurrent work. A mentor-to-learner ratio summarizes a particular arrangement. Check peak and sequence constraints for the scaled cohort. Unexpected absence or retries may change the result before another enrolment does.
HCD.20:4.6 - Preserve interpretable observations and revise the right object
For a design, specify what would show whether the planned actions occurred and what each learner performed with the permitted help. For a report on past use, check the available observations. A common report, observation note or explanation can be useful evidence for a bounded question. It does not automatically establish the same contribution for silent members.
Use HCD.11–HCD.13 for the relevant personal performance, changed-condition or delayed-use question. For team capability, use appropriate evidence of integrated team work. For missing evidence, use a qualified source or identify what remains unknown. If a decision is needed, act within your authority or put the question to the decision holder. For a material or provider finding, use the appropriate material or operating evidence. Distinguish dissatisfaction, absence, inaccessible help and unsuccessful learning before attributing the result to motivation.
A useful pilot can expose an infeasible window, an unused contribution or a task that one person completes for the rest. That observation can locate a needed change in the arrangement. Revise it when the task and authority include revision. A causal comparison of arrangements needs a qualified research design that handles shared exposure, between-person influence, provider differences, attrition and the intended observation horizon.
Return the comparison or the proposed arrangement’s qualified feasibility, the constraints and assumptions on which it depends, and any unresolved evidence. If a choice is requested, give the grounds for it or the condition that prevents it. Reopen affected dimensions when the target, participants, contact, resources or evidence change.
HCD.20:5 - Archetypal Grounding
HCD.20:5.1 - Twenty-four future diagnosticians
Use the constructed product in HCD.28. Participants can calculate an indicator but need to choose between rival explanations. The proposed shared contribution is comparison of reasons that one explanation supports and another cannot yet explain. The common diagnosis is useful during practice; each participant’s later model selection remains a separate target.
The initial proposal gives each participant two three-minute contributions and reserves six minutes for reconciliation. Thus 6k + 6 ≤ 30 permits at most four participants before any separate subject help. Four is a necessary capacity bound, not a completed feasible arrangement or an optimum. If six minutes of qualified help must follow the initial explanations and precede the later reasoning, four people need 36 active minutes. The construction below preserves both rounds and reconciliation instead of hiding that assistance inside an already occupied interval.
The constructed comparison considers three options.
| Option | What it can supply | Condition that remains to be shown |
|---|---|---|
| Supported individual work with contrasting reasons | Personal model choice and comparison, with booked subject help | The material and response opportunity must expose the intended reasoning; help and checking must be obtainable. |
| Pairs comparing different evidence | More room for explanation and challenge per participant | Both participants must encounter the required rival explanations; extra pairs may increase mentor demand. |
| Groups of four with a separate help interval | Four distinguishable evidence contributions, a second personal round and common reconciliation | Both mentors and group members must be free at each visit, after its inputs exist and before the dependent action. |
For 24 participants, six groups of four each need a six-minute subject-help visit. One mentor cannot supply 36 direct minutes in a 30-minute booking. Two mentors have enough total time, but simultaneous starts would give all six groups the same visit window. The proposed starts are G1/G2 at 10:50, G3/G4 at 11:00 and G5/G6 at 11:10. Before relying on this schedule for delivery, establish that the participants can make their starts. Each person’s entry work and first judgement finish before their group starts. Nobody needs to wait through the whole cohort window.
Each first round gives all four people three minutes to expose their evidence and what it supports or leaves open. The shared notes and qualified case reference then supply the mentor’s inputs. The six-minute visit includes inspecting the group’s bounded question and responding to it; it does not replace the learner’s model choice. In the second round, each person challenges or answers a consequential question about another contribution. The final six minutes reconcile the supported common conclusion.
| Groups | First contributions, 4 × 3 min | Subject help | Second contributions, 4 × 3 min | Reconciliation | Mentors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| G1, G2 | 10:50–11:02 | 11:02–11:08 | 11:08–11:20 | 11:20–11:26 | M1 → G1; M2 → G2 |
| G3, G4 | 11:00–11:12 | 11:12–11:18 | 11:18–11:30 | 11:30–11:36 | M1 → G3; M2 → G4 |
| G5, G6 | 11:10–11:22 | 11:22–11:28 | 11:28–11:40 | 11:40–11:46 | M1 → G5; M2 → G6 |
Both mentors are booked from 11:00 to 11:30. Each gives three visits, with four minutes between visits and two minutes before the first and after the last. The rooms and case materials are prepared in advance; the gaps cover movement or connection and a brief reset. A site needing longer travel or help requires different bookings before the offer. The last group finishes at 11:46 and completes its ten-minute personal changed case by 11:56. A missing visit or unanswered question remains a supply gap; nominal spare time does not show that it was answered.
Retain first-response checking in all variants. Eight minutes per participant remains 192 minutes even when the group result is excellent. In HCD.28’s worked example, inspecting each correction adds four minutes per person, or 96 further minutes; that work also remains personal. Use actual first attempts, correction needs and help requests to refine these planning assumptions. A faster mentor or an apparently quiet group is not evidence of unchanged learning quality.
Complete the pair option on the same task and twenty-four-person cohort. Each partner initially explains two of the four evidence contributions in three minutes. Six further minutes let both question the grounds. The mentor can now use the visible evidence and question. After the six-minute visit, each partner has another three minutes to explain the connection between the other’s evidence and the rival accounts. Six minutes of reconciliation complete the thirty-minute pair activity. Thus the pair retains two personal contributions each, questioning, qualified help and a common result; dividing four calculations is insufficient.
Three prepared mentors are booked from 11:00 to 11:30. M1 serves P1/P4/P7/P10, M2 serves P2/P5/P8/P11, and M3 serves P3/P6/P9/P12. The plan requires the four pair starts shown below. Confirm availability before relying on the schedule for delivery. Each mentor has two minutes to move or reconnect between visits; the first room and material must already be ready at 11:00.
| Pairs | First contributions and questions, 6 + 6 min | Subject help | Second contributions, 2 × 3 min | Reconciliation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1, P2, P3 | 10:48–11:00 | 11:00–11:06 | 11:06–11:12 | 11:12–11:18 |
| P4, P5, P6 | 10:56–11:08 | 11:08–11:14 | 11:14–11:20 | 11:20–11:26 |
| P7, P8, P9 | 11:04–11:16 | 11:16–11:22 | 11:22–11:28 | 11:28–11:34 |
| P10, P11, P12 | 11:12–11:24 | 11:24–11:30 | 11:30–11:36 | 11:36–11:42 |
The twelve visits take 72 direct minutes within 90 booked mentor-minutes. The staggered starts change the cohort’s elapsed window; each pair has 30 active minutes. With two mentors, an alternative schedules each for 10:30–11:30, serving three pairs per half-hour at minutes 0, 8 and 16. Each pair starts twelve minutes before its visit and finishes eighteen minutes after the visit begins. The last pair finishes at 11:34 and its ten-minute personal response by 11:44. This plan needs 120 booked mentor-minutes, an earlier first start and lower simultaneous staffing. Establish the longer booking and participant availability before relying on it for delivery.
For the three-mentor option, retain HCD.28’s first-response and correction checks and its preparation branch. Make the planning allowances explicit:
| Provider contribution | Pairs, three mentors | Four-person groups, two mentors |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed preparation, including the pair-specific material and briefing | 9 h | 8 h |
| Help with six preparation branches | 24 min | 24 min |
| Booked subject-help window | 90 min | 60 min |
| First-response and correction checks | 288 min | 288 min |
| Cohort contact, collection and return | 96 min | 72 min |
| Qualified recovery reserve | 96 min | 72 min |
| Recurring allocation | 594 min = 9.9 h | 516 min = 8.6 h |
| Fixed plus recurring allocation for one cohort | 18.9 h | 16.6 h |
The extra fixed hour estimates pair-specific evidence distribution and mentor preparation. The coordination and recovery allowances include confirming the different starts; they are planning estimates. A claim about the measured cost of pairing needs operating evidence. The two-mentor pair alternative adds thirty booked minutes, bringing its first-cohort provider allocation to 19.4 hours.
The pairs’ 90-minute core takes 36 learner-hours for 24 people. Six preparation branches add 2 hours. Twelve possible recoveries at 15 learner-minutes add up to 3 hours, for 41 active learner-hours at full reserve use. For groups of four, 24 × 96 minutes is 38.4 learner-hours. Add 2 preparation hours and nine possible 15-minute recoveries (2.25 hours) to obtain 42.65. Both plans preserve HCD.28’s two-day feedback sequence and noon submission of personal responses.
On these allowances the three-mentor pair option costs 2.3 more provider-hours but 99 fewer active learner-minutes than four-person groups. The differing reasons, personal contributions and simultaneous staffing still matter; no option has established equal educational outcomes merely by fitting its clock. For a choice, use the learning contributions, capacity and separate burdens. A later observation may justify revisiting the recovery allowance or reveal a judgement that learners had no opportunity to practise. Recompare if the evidence affects the question.
HCD.20:5.2 - Shared equipment and an internal team
An internal team uses one safe training instrument. During another person’s turn, participants can predict a reading, request a pause, compare the observed result with a model and explain a discrepancy. The operator then changes. Here some useful actions occur together, while manipulating the instrument requires exclusive access. Model these constraints separately from sequential speaking time.
Begin with the actions needed later. If the target requires each learner to manipulate the instrument, provide each with a turn. For a claim about their performance, identify an observation of their own work. If only some roles manipulate it and others must recognize when to challenge a reading, preserve those different targets. Do not add equal hands-on time merely for symmetry or remove it merely to increase headcount.
The employer’s schedule can provide access and a common window without a purchased course. It does not guarantee willingness to expose an error in front of a supervisor, permission to use production data or availability of qualified instruction. A permitted training case and a different feedback arrangement may be needed. Compare that burden with individual supported practice.
The Noerholk et al. study provides a concrete example of active observer possibilities: during simulated ultrasound training, non-operators could assist with images and measurements, suggest, question and discuss, with turns at the probe. Its novice population, two-hour training and separate individual simulator assessments bound the source use; it does not establish an ideal size or clinical competence for this internal team.
HCD.20:6 - Bias-Annotation
| Likely drift | Repair |
|---|---|
| Favourite-size bias | Derive the size of each action from its contribution and constraint; compare a plausible alternative where one could improve the answer. |
| Visible-output bias | For a design, identify whose contribution the proposed observation could show and with what help. For a claim about performed work, establish who acted and under what assistance, or state what the observation leaves open. |
| Diversity-as-score bias | Identify the task-relevant difference and where its contribution could be used. For a claim about use, identify what happened. |
| Hidden-labour bias | Count reading, explaining, correction and coordination carried by participants. |
| Stable-group inertia | Compare the benefit and burden of continuing the relationship with those of changing it, including transition costs and any contribution an existing membership excludes. |
| Silent-group optimism | Distinguish sufficient understanding from inability to ask, absence or unavailable help. |
HCD.20:7 - Conformance Checklist
A recognizable comparison preserves:
- the intended personal contribution and any distinct shared or team result;
- meaningful entrant preparation and interaction conditions;
- separate cohort, task-group, relationship and provider scales;
- the contribution interaction could supply and a feasible individual or existing baseline where it can serve the target;
- the actions, help, material permissions and contact needed for each option, and the evidence for any claim that they occurred;
- complete and peak burdens without hiding recurring individual checks;
- the observation that can distinguish the claimed result and conditions that could change the finding or any choice based on it.
These design values permit a bounded comparison. Reliance on actual contact, operational support or personal performance requires evidence that those events or contributions occurred. A composition algorithm or feasible timetable supplies only its narrower result.
HCD.20:8 - Common Anti-Patterns and How to Avoid Them
| Anti-pattern | Failure | Repair |
|---|---|---|
| Cohort equals group | An enrolment number dictates every interaction. | Separate scales and derive each action’s capacity. |
| Division of labour equals learning | One member supplies the operation the others were meant to learn. | Allocate the personal contribution and a suitable later attempt. |
| Mandatory private attempt | A novice must invent an unavailable method before useful modelling. | Choose visibility and help for the learning purpose. |
| Observer equals spectator | A useful observer action may be overlooked or assumed from attendance. | Identify the observer’s intended contribution and use evidence of it for claims about performed work. Provide a personal turn where the target requires manipulating the instrument. |
| Weekly-hours illusion | Adequate totals hide simultaneous demand. | Compare the live window with qualified available capacity. |
| Group discount | Reduced paid help conceals participant work and quality loss. | Compare whole burdens and each learning contribution. Establish what was supplied when comparing actual operations. |
| Automatic regrouping | Every difficulty triggers social disruption. | Repair the task, support or material first when that is the supported cause. |
HCD.20:9 - Consequences
The comparison can support individual practice, a group arrangement or a change to either. It can also identify a resource or learning constraint that prevents a proposed use. Different activities can require different group sizes and help windows.
The method requires enough task detail to estimate interaction and qualified help. Some useful differences in people are difficult to observe cheaply, and anticipated participation may fail. Identify those uncertainties, their implications and any viable recovery options. Reopen the comparison when the action, entrants, contact, material access, available window or observed contribution materially changes.
HCD.20:10 - Architectural Rationale
Several people can work together and produce one shared result. A claim about one person’s capability needs evidence of that person’s contribution. A claim about team capability needs evidence of integrated team work.
Group size follows from the learning work. Individual instruction may supply all the required contributions. Where response to a peer or shared equipment is essential, examine which arrangements can provide it, at what cost and with which personal opportunities.
HCD.20:11 - SoTA-Echoing
Collaborative Cognitive Load Theory relates collaborative learning to subject demands, prior knowledge and the demands of coordinating work. Here it motivates inspecting whether useful shared resources justify interaction for the chosen task. It is a theoretical contribution, not a group-size formula or demonstrated effect for this offer.
Noerholk et al., “Does group size matter during collaborative skills learning?” supplies the bounded construction described in §5.2. The present instrument case is an adaptation, not a replication or a transfer of the study’s outcome to technical diagnostics.
The time inequality, peak-demand comparison and separation of scales are transparent design constructions. Their input estimates and learning adequacy remain open to observation. HCD.7 and HCD.8 supply the existing provider and AI-support methods; changing the price or interface of a tool does not by itself change their competence and checking requirements.
HCD.20:12 - Relations
- Consumes: HCD.28 product requirements, HCD.2 personal programme values or equivalent qualified target, entry, access and burden information.
- Uses: HCD.5 and HCD.6 for the learning mechanism and representative task, HCD.21 for membership and contact, HCD.22 for shared-task construction, and HCD.27 for compatible routes. HCD.7 and HCD.8 can help identify required support, arrange a missing contribution or assess what support was delivered.
- Supplies: a comparison or feasibility finding about the learning arrangements, which may answer the receiving task. For a requested product or programme choice, give the grounds it can use. Identify any task, membership, timing or support condition still needed for delivery.
- Receives: evidence about participation, task performance and help; HCD.11–HCD.13 personal evidence; material diagnosis through HCD.19.
- Keeps separate: team and organization capability, service launch, market demand and causal effectiveness. Their owners and evidence govern those conclusions.