HCD.3:4 - Solution
Compare plausible explanations in the detail needed to distinguish the findings or next actions they would support. Use existing evidence where it suffices. If further observation is needed, seek a safe, attainable observation that can distinguish the explanations. State the smallest supported human limitation, explain an established external constraint or identify the evidence still missing. Give a question that requires another practice to the practice that can answer it, when known.
HCD.3:4.1 - Bind the Diagnostic Use
Name:
- the person whose contribution is in question and the basis for their participation;
- the HCD.1 demand account or equivalent qualified later-Work input, including configuration, conditions, horizon, and evidence window;
- the observed gap and the finding or development decision it could affect;
- the evidence collector, declared use, access conditions, privacy or worker-governance boundary, and the responsible parties where these conditions require their action;
- the protected conditions and safe probe limit; and
- the point at which a clinical, safety, legal, employment, target-domain, or other specialist owner must take over.
If the demand is absent or incompatible, stop the diagnosis and return the missing scope or evidence needed to consider this person’s difficulty. A role label, population profile or imagined task does not establish the demand.
HCD.3:4.2 - Compare Decision-Changing Rivals
Consider explanations that are plausible for this gap and could affect the diagnosis or the next Work. The table gives examples.
| Rival branch | Question that keeps it live |
|---|---|
| demand or envelope | Is the demand specified correctly and inside the capability envelope being relied upon? |
| applicability, access, expression, adaptation, or enactment | Is the response unavailable, or does a cue, context, interference, configuration, or performer arrangement prevent selection or use? |
| Method or description | Is the target Method missing, stale, disputed, or inapplicable? |
| tools and supports | Are AI, information, cues, access, environment, workload, recovery, or another support condition limiting? |
| assignment and organization | Is assignment, permission, authority, coordination, organization, provider access, or a required specialist result missing? |
| specialist condition | Does health, disorder, safety, ethics, law, or another specialist condition require its direct owner? |
| human change target | Does the evidence support a particular capability, knowledge, skill, discrimination, misconception, behaviour, self-regulation, or commitment as limiting and changeable? |
| measurement artefact | Could a scoring, recording, or interpretation error explain the poor indicator without the corresponding failure in Work? |
Use evidence about an actual condition or a consequential gap to decide which explanations warrant comparison.
Too few or poorly linked observations, coupled conditions, contamination, or unsafe collection can prevent this comparison from distinguishing the live branches. Narrow the conclusion or give a non-training return that names the evidence limit, what observation could distinguish the remaining explanations and any conditions for obtaining it safely.
Look for a missing intermediate performance, not just an absent basic skill or an unknown whole procedure. FPF B.1.5.EW can help identify how the necessary parts work together. In a stipulated dance case, the person has sufficient strength, holds the axis when stationary and recalls the figure, but loses balance during its rotation. Those observations locate a coordination question between the muscular actions and the figure; they do not establish a general lack of strength or memory. If existing observations already distinguish the decision-changing rivals, use them. Otherwise choose a suitable comparison of the rotation in isolation and in the figure, under domain-qualified conditions. Return the supported limitation or the unresolved alternative rather than prescribing more of whichever exercise is easiest to name.
HCD.3:4.3 - Probe Before Declaring Capability Loss
When a prior qualified capability or result exists and the differential can change the next Work, use an applicable E.23.CAE disposition before declaring loss or prescribing more practice. Use an applicable reference observation when it establishes the contrast. If a further probe is needed and can be made safely, return to the reference conditions without intervening development, vary the smallest consequential condition, and distinguish applicability, access, adaptation, enactment and result.
A recovered response under the reference conditions weakens the claim of loss across all conditions. Transfer requires evidence in the target conditions. Failure across reference and target conditions may warrant capability-claim revision only after demand, configuration, support, and measurement rivals have been addressed. If the probe teaches, primes, fatigues, changes exposure, or cannot be run safely, narrow the conclusion or return an unresolved differential that states the observation limit and its effect on the conclusion.
For a new observation, identify who will collect and interpret it, how the person will participate, its declared use, protected conditions and applicable access and privacy limits. Treat an assisting System’s inference as decision input. Acting on it requires separately established authority for the particular action.
HCD.3:4.4 - Record the Result
A qualified intervention target contains:
| Result position | Required content |
|---|---|
| use boundary | Human holder, later-Work demand, configuration, horizon, evidence window, receiving question or decision, participation basis, and governance limits. |
| observed gap | Claim-sized Work observation, intended result or critical-error boundary, and why the gap matters. |
| target | The person’s difficulty with the required contribution and the smallest supported human change to target under the named conditions. A later decision selects any practice or other intervention. |
| evidence | The observations, work products or contrasts used, how they support the target, and any uncertainty, contamination or measurement limits. |
| rival disposition | The explanations considered, any still-plausible alternatives, and their effects on the target and next observation. When none remain, keep the evidence limits and reopen condition explicit. |
| protected conditions | Method, task, tools, prompts, information, time, environment, assignment, authority, supports, and specialist routes held or bounded. |
| intended observation | The target change to observe, its conditions, and the claim that would depend on it. Explaining a result as an effect of the intervention through that target requires evidence for each link. |
| boundaries and continuation | Direct specialist or owner boundary, unsupported uses, and the condition that reopens the target. |
Observed performance may be reported with its conditions before a causal explanation is established. A better score alone establishes neither a change in the proposed target nor the intervention’s effect through that target.
A non-training return contains:
| Result position | Required content |
|---|---|
| actual owner or missing result | The established external constraint or the specific input still needed, with the party responsible for any further action where known. |
| conclusion and limits | What the external condition establishes and which human-target conclusion or development decision, if any, remains unsupported. |
| evidence and rival disposition | What is known, what remains unresolved, and why a human target is not supported. |
| safe interim boundary, when needed | While a conclusion is unresolved, state which assignments, inferences, prescriptions or other uses the available evidence does not warrant. |
| reconsideration | If a conclusion remains blocked, name the result, observation, decision or evidence that would permit a retry. For a settled finding, identify a change that would matter if it were revisited. |
HCD.3:4.5 - What Changes in Practice
Ask which explanation affects the warranted conclusion or the next Work, which evidence distinguishes it and whether the evidence supports a human change. If an external condition explains the difficulty, state its effect. For a missing input or specialist decision, say what is needed and return the question to the practice able to address it when known.