HCD.5:4 - Solution
Establish the target action and the person’s observed entry conditions, or the entry conditions assumed for a future audience. Use an existing selection when its grounds fit. Where a selection is still needed, compare plausible mechanisms and choose the Method or combination justified by the task, learner, support, burden, risk and evidence. If an external condition explains the limitation, state its effect and preserve any separate human target. Give a question that still requires another contributor to that contributor where known.
Use observations of the target to decide whether to continue or change practice. Report the conditions and what changed; a before/after difference alone does not identify the intervention’s effect. Seek additional causal evidence when the receiving question needs that stronger claim and the inquiry is feasible and worth its cost. If the target observation is unavailable, leave change unknown rather than treating it as a demonstrated lack of improvement.
HCD.5:4.1 - Bind the Selection Use
Distinguish a choice for a known person from a design for a future audience. Establish the following information.
- the person and participation basis, or the future audience and its assumptions; identify the intended recipient and, where a decision is required, the decision holder;
- the later-Work contribution, configuration, horizon, protected result and critical-error conditions;
- the qualified target for that person and any still-plausible rival explanation, or the target contribution and proposed entry conditions for each design branch;
- the person’s starting attempt, including task, permitted and received help, work product, result, errors, uncertainty and evidence window. For future design, state instead the entry task or existing evidence that would distinguish the branches, the allowed help and the response that would select or reopen each choice;
- current strengths, prior relevant practice, available time, access, tools, AI posture, provider contribution, environment, privacy, safety, and other protected conditions; and
- the observation the intended use would need if the Method is applied, including an applicable observation already available.
For future design, record unknown learner, support or resource conditions as assumptions and say when to revisit the design. Select a personal branch when the person’s entry evidence supports it. Use HCD.3 if rival explanations change the target or next action. For missing data, permission, safe participation, a tool, or a domain way or judgement, use an applicable result already available. Where another practice must supply the contribution, send the question and relevant evidence when the source is known. Otherwise state the remaining limit. A qualified demonstration, family of exemplars or practitioner judgement can supply a usable domain basis before it is fully verbalized, as §4.2.1 explains. Identify the human target independently of any external constraint.
HCD.5:4.2 - Generate a Small Candidate Set by Mechanism
Use the observed action difference, or the stated difference between possible entry conditions, to generate serious candidates. Use questions such as the following to identify a candidate that fits.
| Observed difference | Candidate Method question | Boundary to preserve |
|---|---|---|
| the person lacks a usable representation or cannot follow expert reasoning | Would an explanation, demonstration, integrated worked example, or prompted self-explanation expose the decision-bearing relation? | Match guidance to prior knowledge and the target. Retain the guidance while it fits. Change it when a different task or the learner’s progress makes different guidance appropriate. Independent performance requires its own observation. |
| the person cannot yet notice the difference named by an instruction | Would HCD.6.1 make that difference discernible through an accessible contrast and a response that uses it? | The encounter must be feasible from the learner’s existing capabilities; noticing the difference and performing the target action remain separate. |
| the person performs an operation when named but does not recognize when it applies | Would discrimination practice across contrasting situations improve recognition and Method selection? | Repeating execution with the Method name supplied cannot test this target. |
| a recurrent component is slow or error-prone and constrains the whole task | Would focused part practice with immediate correction stabilize that component? | The component must contribute to the later task; part success does not establish whole-task coordination. |
| separate contributions are adequate but their coordination fails | Would sufficiently whole-task practice with bounded support expose the interfaces and stopping conditions? | A true prerequisite may still need preparation; task realism does not excuse unsafe or uninterpretable complexity. |
| the next attempt repeats a known, actionable difference | What information-specific feedback, corrective activity, and retest would let the person change that action? | Praise, a score, or another attempt is not enough when it does not identify the difference to change. |
| the person has an endorsed goal and feasible action but misses a stable cue | Would a bounded if–then plan or environmental cue support enactment? | Goal attainment is not capability, and a plan cannot repair an unavailable or unsafe action. |
| competent participation in complex Work is needed | Would demonstration, coaching, guided participation, or supervised workplace practice provide the missing contribution? | Check that a suitable provider, task, access and supervision are available. Establish which consequences are permitted in this use. |
| the observed limit disappears when data, permission, workload, tool, or support is restored | Is the supported next move an access or arrangement change rather than a development Method? | Use an available support result or give HCD.7, HCD.8 or the responsible contributor the specific missing condition and preserve any remaining human target separately. |
Spacing, retrieval, interleaving, cue focus, support fading, and other practice features may refine a candidate when their mechanism matches the target. HCD.10 chooses the condition-sensitive practice change after the governing Method and observations are present.
If a local proficiency model is being used, connect the candidate mechanism to its proposed transition rather than selecting a Method for a level name. Recover the starting response, the intended difference and the condition that distinguishes them from HCD.4:4.2.1–HCD.4:4.2.2. For N24 (HCD.6:5.6), correct calculation with a supplied unit rules against arithmetic repetition as the present target. Contrast and supported whole performance are serious alternatives for making unit selection available. If later evidence separates cue-dependent selection from cue-resistant selection, reconsider that mechanism and its task; the model’s new wording alone is no reason to repeat an unchanged Method. Pass the selected connection and its uncertainty to HCD.6.
HCD.5:4.2.1 - Compose learning from the contribution, not an explicit–implicit ratio
Use this branch when a rule lesson, repeated imitation or unstructured participation leaves a person unable to use what they encounter. Use the activity or combination that could supply the missing contribution under the available conditions. The combination can begin with an explanation, a demonstration, an existing successful performance or participation in work; the entry evidence decides.
Recover the practice and the kind of judgement. Identify the receiving activity and an adequate performance, together with a nearby case that calls for a different response. Correctness can be specified by a rule, but it can also be made accessible through recordings, competent demonstrations, accepted work products, partner responses or qualified practitioner judgement. Establish the conditions in which those comparisons have standing. Where competent practitioners differ, identify their different conventions or purposes. Teach a choice between them if the learner needs to make that choice. If the required distinction remains unsupported, narrow that target or obtain subject help. Incomplete verbalization alone does not make a demonstrated practice unavailable.
Distinguish a learner’s ability to explain a regularity from their ability to notice, anticipate or enact it. Likewise distinguish a teaching activity from a claim about the learner’s psychological mechanism. Learning from examples can include deliberate comparison; a fluent response can have a history of explicit instruction. Failure to verbalize an acquired distinction does not establish that its acquisition was unconscious. Neural-network learning can suggest questions about exposure, variation or prediction, but that analogy supplies no evidence of the human mechanism.
Find the missing contribution in an attainable whole use. Use an existing work sample or a small supported encounter that the person can enter. Ask what the person can already supply and what the current help supplies. Then choose the contribution that will change the next attempt:
| Present need | Construct the learning opportunity | Use its result |
|---|---|---|
| Understand why a choice or boundary matters | Give a short explanation connected to contrasting cases; let the learner predict or choose in another case. | Use the relation to guide selection, diagnose an exception or ask a better question. A repeated definition is insufficient when action is the target. |
| Notice or anticipate a pattern before a full account is available | Supply accessible, meaningful examples and contrasts across the relevant family; let the learner discriminate, predict, complete or respond. | Use the response to locate any remaining confusion and, where needed, refine examples or help through HCD.6.1. |
| Make an available operation more fluent or stable | Arrange manageable repetitions with information about the result that the learner can use to correct or retain the action. | Reduce the demands of the encompassing activity while the learner practises the operation where its ordinary pace or concurrent demands would obscure that practice. Return the operation to the encompassing activity and establish whether the person can perform it there with the required fluency or stability. |
| Coordinate contributions that work separately | Keep the consequential coupling in a reduced-demand whole task; support other contributions and practise the missing relation. | Restore tempo, complexity, partners or conditions as the intended use requires. Part success alone cannot decide that return. |
| Adapt a familiar response | Contrast conditions in which it works with conditions requiring a change; vary the deciding relation while preserving usable references. | Let the person select, modify, pause or seek help in a new relevant case. Include a valid familiar case so that blanket refusal is not rewarded. |
| Participate competently in changing work or culture | Give a useful, attainable contribution with access to competent participants, feedback and another occasion to contribute. | Increase or change participation from what the person can supply and what the practice needs. Attendance alone supplies neither the opportunity nor the learning. |
Choose what to explain and when to bring it into attention. Explain a relation when it can make the next action intelligible, expose a misconception, protect a consequential boundary or help transfer. Demonstrate or contrast what a description leaves imperceptible. During a difficult whole performance, one usable cue may serve better than simultaneous monitoring of every component. Where a detail needs attention, examine it between attempts, practise under manageable conditions and return attention to the purpose, partner or result of the whole. If conscious monitoring already helps, keep it. If it disrupts an otherwise available coordination, compare a different cue or a separate preparation episode. The appropriate focus is a subject- and learner-dependent design choice.
Choose encounters that prepare the learner for later work. Frequent forms can deserve repeated use; rare but consequential exceptions can deserve deliberate contrasts or an available reference. Include meaningful variation in speakers, situations, materials or partners where later work will require it. A teaching set may intentionally overrepresent a difficult exception. Tell the learner enough about that choice to avoid mistaking exercise frequency for prevalence in the practice. A 70/30 split between rule instruction and learning from examples would need grounds in this case. Allocate time by the missing contribution, encounter opportunities, consequence and response.
Distinguish learning a convention, switching conventions and changing one. For reproduction, provide examples and feedback from the practice the learner wants to join. For switching, contrast situations with different purposes or expectations and practise recognizing which convention is in use. For deliberate innovation, let the learner vary a consequential relation while retaining a chosen contribution, then examine the variant with competent participants in its receiving use. A successful experiment can support keeping that variant locally; wider adoption and a changed cultural norm are further results. Music and dance practice development returns those questions to MDPE.21, MDPE.17 and MDPE.Application:5. Learning to take part in that work remains an HCD question.
Join activities through actual use. An explanation can supply a distinction for comparing examples. A contrast can make an instruction perceptible. Repetition can make a response available quickly enough to coordinate with another action. Participation can expose the context or exception that changes the next explanation. State which of these joins is needed here and give the learner the corresponding action. Use the activities whose results the learner or task actually needs.
Choose the next observation from the pending decision. If a learner recognizes the pattern but cannot enact it, examine what prevents enactment and select suitable practice or support. If they perform only with a model, decide whether that support belongs to later work or whether another occasion should expose selection without it. If their response fits one register or partner convention, extend the experience only when another use is needed. Stop the added development when the supported arrangement serves the present purpose.
This construction is a reasoned teaching hypothesis. Use established subject knowledge, available observations and current learning research to choose a worthwhile action; an unattainable controlled experiment is not a prerequisite for trying a proportionate arrangement. Retain what is uncertain when it changes use. Commission a further comparison when its attainable answer can change the teaching choice or justify a stronger claim enough to warrant its cost. C.11.DUA develops that comparison; a claim of an intervention effect needs an appropriate causal basis.
HCD.5:4.3 - Compare Method Fit and Evidence
For each serious candidate, record:
| Selection position | Required content |
|---|---|
| target contribution | The human action or judgement intended to change and its role in later Work. |
| proposed mechanism | How the Method is expected to change that target, what source or prior observation supports the expectation, and any plausible alternative explanation that matters. |
| task and learner fit | Starting performance, prior knowledge, task complexity, similarity, support dependence, and the differences from serious alternatives that matter to this selection. |
| proposed form of practice | The minimally sufficient explanation, demonstration, practice, feedback, correction, plan, coaching, or support change; identify a qualified professional description when local design would be unsafe or under-specified. |
| provider and access need | Competence, time, data, tools, AI, environment, supervision, permission, privacy, and peak-load conditions required for the Method. |
| burden and risk | Learner and provider effort, displaced Work, error exposure, overload, autonomy, fatigue, clinical or safety risk, and the cost of another attempt or probe. |
| evidence plan | Use existing observations when sufficient. Select further observation only for a question that can change the choice or qualify a needed claim; retain the relevant help, conditions and inference limits. A design hypothesis can guide an attainable next action without a separate causal study. |
| alternatives and stop | Any surviving alternatives or rejected candidates with reasons, conditions for stopping or returning, and the smallest change that would justify reconsidering the selection. |
Compare the intended contribution and full enactment effort on the same basis for each candidate. A richly specified Method does not defeat an unnamed alternative; make only the smallest alternative description needed to expose a decision-bearing difference. Preserve source limits instead of transporting one average effect, hours threshold, cue, sequence, or professional arrangement to a different task and population.
HCD.5:4.4 - Select a Coherent Method Set
Select one Method or the smallest combination that covers the required contributions at a justified total burden. For a combination, address the following questions.
- which target or task difference each member addresses;
- whether it prepares a prerequisite, enables the first attempt, supplies feedback, supports correction, or tests changed performance;
- which order is required by dependence and which order is merely convenient;
- which help is allowed during each observation and what the person must do without an answer-bearing cue; and
- when the set can finish because the supported contribution meets its intended use, and when insufficient target change, another limitation or loss of provider support calls for a change or return.
If one candidate proposes the same contribution as another at higher burden, retain the lower-burden adequate candidate unless a material evidence, safety, participation, or future-use value justifies the difference. If methods address different supported targets, keep those targets and evidence plans distinct even when one programme coordinates their enactment.
HCD.5:4.5 - Record the Method-Selection Account
| Result position | Required content |
|---|---|
| selection boundary | Person and participation basis, or future audience assumptions; later-Work contribution, configuration, horizon, evidence window, receiving question or decision, its recipient and any decision holder or outside responsibilities the use requires. Mark which conditions are observed and which are proposed. |
| target and start | For personal selection: qualified target and starting attempt with its conditions, strengths, errors, help, uncertainty and still-plausible rivals. For future design: target contribution, assumed starting conditions and the entry evidence that would select or reopen each branch. |
| selected Method set | Each Method’s action, proposed mechanism, intended target contribution, proposed form of practice, required support, and stop condition. |
| comparison | Task and learner fit, evidence, burden, risk, and reasons for selection or rejection; any serious alternatives assessed on the same basis, including differences in effort. |
| evidence plan | Existing basis and any worthwhile next observation; help and changed conditions that affect interpretation; stronger later-Work evidence only for a needed stronger claim; limits that change use. |
| disposition | selected Method set, conditional design hypothesis for stated entry evidence, non-training return, or Method description or provider result blocked. |
| continuation | The practice-task design, provider/access result, first enacted attempt, missing professional description, outside-owner question, or smallest condition that reopens selection. |
For a future audience, return only a conditional design hypothesis tied to the stated entry evidence and planned diagnostic branches. When a competent professional Method or provider result is required and unavailable, name that result rather than writing a generic local substitute.
HCD.5:4.6 - Recognition and Assurance
Recognition. Use HCD.5 when the question is “What kind of development activity could change this person’s specific action?” and a worked example, whole task, focused component practice, feedback loop, coaching arrangement, self-regulation aid, or support change would lead to different next Work. For a future audience, ask the same question conditionally