Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:20:20 UTC

HCD.6.1:5.4 - Reading what changed in a claim across projects

Two permitted project excerpts describe the same observation. One concludes, “The indicator increased under these measurement conditions.” The other concludes, “Increased resistance caused the indicator change.” The learner is asked to mark what the second statement adds and what evidence would be needed for that added claim under the supplied subject account. The correct distinction concerns observation and causal attribution; either claim can be written briefly or confidently.

The learner then inspects two reports from another project. Both use different wording but derive from the same original observation. Calling them two independent observations would miss a different consequential relation: the provenance is shared. Use the receiving criterion to decide whether the shared observation suffices. If the claim requires independent observations, trace the sources.

A changed pair reverses which excerpt is longer and makes the cautious-sounding version overstate the evidence. Another pair contains genuinely separate observations under the stated independence conditions. The learner must identify what the evidence supports for each claim. Feedback can confirm a sound distinction or address one the learner missed. The learner then uses the grounds of their own case to preserve or narrow a claim, or return it for the support it needs.

HCD.25 develops how to select and connect such permitted project cases; HCD.24 uses discernible differences in peer judgement. The contrast here prepares recognition. Neither identifying an overclaim nor reading the other project’s report establishes competence to conduct its full investigation.

These examples propose teaching tasks and illustrate possible responses. Claims about what a learner did or learned need observations of that learner.