IS.2:4.2 - Distinguish explanations that matter to the finding or response
State explanations as working claims about the episode. “The lookup route cannot retrieve this edition” is more useful than “technology barrier”. State what evidence would distinguish the claim and which response, if any, would depend on it.
| Possible explanation | Observation that could distinguish the explanation | Different response |
|---|---|---|
| The needed source or tool cannot be used. | Can the qualified performer proceed when effective access is supplied? | Repair access or select another qualified obtaining way. |
| An operation or judgement is missing. | What contribution does an expert make that is absent from the ordinary attempt? | Use an adequate judgement or obtain it from a qualified provider. If the performer must acquire the operation, select a development or provision Method appropriate to that holder. When learning is the selected way, arrange the contributions that its Method requires, such as practice with feedback for a person or training data for a technical system. |
| The target does not fit the receiving case. | Which relied-on condition differs, and does the known alternative address it? | Reconsider the target or qualify a variant through the subject practice and A.3.1.MV. |
| Correct work conflicts with current commitments. | What occupies the necessary interval, and who can change the allocation? | Establish the conflict. If it must be resolved, obtain a feasible arrangement under the applicable authority. |
| Correct participation brings adverse consequences. | What actually follows the action, compared with the stated rule? | Establish the adverse consequence. If intervention is required, use or obtain a change that can alter it. |
| A completed action returns no wanted value. | What did the receiver need, and what remained unresolved after completion? | Identify the mismatch. Repair the contribution or reconsider the desired action if the undertaking calls for change. |
The table is illustrative. Form another explanation when the case requires it. Several can survive: an unclear instruction and unavailable time can both matter. An available determinant inventory can prompt questions about the relevant operation and its grounds.
Silence or non-use can have several explanations. When the question concerns a person’s experience, reason or decision, use their applicable account or seek it where appropriate. A refusal can reflect a burden, an objection or the person’s choice. Obtain needed clinical or other specialist judgement from a qualified professional, or state the limit if it is unavailable.