IS.3:5 - Archetypal Grounding
IS.3:5.1 - Compare complete first-week alternatives
In this constructed Harbor Design case the following quantities are stipulated for the comparison. Six analysts are available. After the local diagnosis, suppose four have adequate current capability for the selected case family and two need a supported attempt with feedback. The intended first-week contribution is eight eligible package checks, with the two additional analysts beginning to acquire the missing comparison operation. In the current continuation, the four capable analysts can provide those eight checks at 0.20 hours each, using 1.6 hours already available for checking. The two analysts’ acquisition requires additional work.
All three serious alternatives require the same access repair, taking 1.5 technical hours, and a 0.5-hour managerial contribution that makes the review interval and receiving decision effective. These two hours are counted once in each alternative.
| First-week alternative | Scarce qualified provider time | Other direct time, including ordinary checking | Complete effort for the selected work |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full six-person workshop, followed by brief individual follow-up | 2 hours preparation + 2 hours teaching + 6 × 0.25 hours follow-up = 5.5 hours | 6 × 2 hours attendance + 6 × 0.25 hours follow-up participation + 2 common hours + 1.6 hours checking = 17.1 hours | 22.6 hours |
| Targeted workplace rehearsal for the two analysts | 1 hour preparation + 2 × 0.75 hours coached rehearsal = 2.5 hours | 2 × 0.75 hours participation + 2 common hours + 1.6 hours checking = 5.1 hours | 7.6 hours |
| Qualified expert supplies the checking contribution for eight cases | 8 × 0.20 hours = 1.6 hours | 2 common hours; the expert replaces the analysts’ checking contribution | 3.6 hours |
The totals include eight checks and the implementation work in each constructed alternative. Other unchanged package work lies outside the comparison. Relative to 1.6 hours of ordinary checking, the additional effort is 21, 6 and 2 hours respectively. The workshop uses the instructor’s time and each participant’s time. In the expert option, the expert performs the checks in place of the analysts.
Suppose only three qualified support hours are available after existing commitments. The workshop is unavailable in that window. Targeted rehearsal needs 2.5 hours. Two agreed 45-minute intervals and the available preparation hour give it a workable schedule.
The expert service can supply eight immediate checks with less first-week effort than either learning arrangement in the table. If those checks are the entire requirement, the expert service is eligible alongside the current analysts wherever each can meet the receiving conditions. If the authorized promise also includes developing the two analysts’ judgement, the extra learner work and support remain necessary.
The parties select targeted rehearsal for the acquisition attempt and retain the existing qualified review condition until later performance supports another allocation. They obtain the rehearsal and assessment from HCD and the subject provider. Use A.3.1.MI to examine what happens when the strategy is introduced.
IS.3:5.2 - Build the local instruction rather than paste a strategy name
The target requires identifying whether a source revision changes the support for a claim. The initial implementation instruction says:
Use the new review method before release.
A walkthrough shows that the analyst cannot find the source pair and that the technical lead receives only an unqualified approval flag. The local instruction is changed:
When a package cites a revised source, open the cited edition and the proposed current edition. Locate the passage supporting the claim. State whether the change affects that support, with the relevant passage. Send an unresolved or changed-support case to the technical lead before release recommendation. If either edition is unavailable, return the missing source instead of marking the claim checked.
The source owner supplies the two-edition route. The technical lead agrees the receiving response and timing. The learning provider uses representative pairs to teach the missing comparison where needed. The instruction is a local explanation of the selected operation.
Suppose instead that the source is a continuously updated database with no recoverable historical edition. The instruction’s input condition fails. The helper returns the record-preservation and claim-support question to the source/subject owner. Inventing a timestamp from memory would not preserve the target operation.
IS.3:5.3 - Strong AI changes the obtaining way
Suppose a qualified AI service can perform the source comparison under the actual access and protection conditions, and its current evidence supports the required case family. One alternative lets it supply the comparison while the technical lead retains the receiving decision. Another uses it to prepare contrasts for the analysts’ practice.
In the first arrangement the service can reduce demand for human comparison work and deliver the requested result. In the second, the analysts make the comparison and receive feedback as part of the proposed learning arrangement. Assess their capability from their own work under the conditions of the claim. Attributing a change in capability to the feedback requires evidence of that effect. Use the arrangement that meets the promised result.
If the service loses access to a protected source, the alternative becomes unavailable for that case.