Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:25:20 UTC

MDPE.6 - Choose Whether and How to Use a Music-or-Dance Result under New Conditions

Status: Stable

Type: DPF pattern body

Primary working result: An assessment of whether a music or dance result suits changed conditions, an account of an earlier use or choice, a recommendation, or a decision. For a decision, choose among feasible treatments such as using the result as obtained, revising it, keeping distinct versions or stopping. Identify a missing contribution or a worthwhile comparison when it affects that judgement. Permission, implementation, transmission and historical lineage each need evidence appropriate to the claim.

MDPE.6:0 - Use This When

Use this method when a music, dance, teaching, engineering or capability-development result must be considered under different conditions. You may need to assess its suitability, make or recommend a choice, or establish how an earlier team treated it. The source result can already be sufficient for the question.

The relevant change may concern any of the following.

  • dancer, musician, body, prosthesis, instrument, controller, partner, or ensemble;
  • room, floor, stage, recording medium, software, AI service, or publication format;
  • participant population, teaching setting, social event, recognition arrangement, or production constraint; or
  • intended performance, learning, interaction, or cultural-development use.

A shared name can hide a consequential change. An arrangement may preserve the notes while the new instruments mask an answering line. The visible steps of a routine can survive while partner communication changes. Compare the relation the receiving use needs. A direct method may already show what persisted or what must change. A different execution can serve the same use without establishing a new style.

Start from the question about the changed use.

Given this source result and the receiving conditions, is it suitable as obtained? Should we revise it, keep a separate version, stop, or seek an observation worth its cost? For a previous occasion, what does the available evidence establish about the choice or performance?

Use applicable results from arranging, transcription, choreography, inclusive teaching, instrument design, systems engineering, rehearsal or capability assessment. Obtain or produce a missing score, arrangement, assessment or other contribution through the relevant practice when the question requires it. C.17 can help establish a consequential characteristic of an identified subject. Use this method for a remaining question about suitability, an earlier use or a decision under changed conditions.

For a receiving-use choice, the following steps may be enough.

  1. Identify the source result, intended use, changed condition and who may decide or is being asked to advise.
  2. Identify feasible treatments, including use as obtained, revision, retention of separate versions or stopping.
  3. Compare how the treatments serve the musical or movement relations required in the receiving use.
  4. Use adequate existing evidence. Consider another observation if its attainable contribution justifies its cost.
  5. Return the judgement, recommendation or authorized choice, its grounds and any consequential limit.

Use A.22.CGUS only when the branches and returns of a maintained unfolding need their own description.

A choice inside an ongoing improvisation belongs to the performance method. Use MDPE.17 for transmission to another holder, MDPE.10 for performer capability and MDPE.19 for cultural continuation. A historical question about lineage requires evidence of that transmission or continuity. A question about an earlier choice of arrangement can be answered here.

MDPE.6:0.1 - Working Distinctions

NameMeaning here
source resultThe identified material, Method, MethodDescription, arrangement, teaching result, performing configuration, or other direct Music-or-Dance result being considered. Keep its actual kind.
Receiving conditionsThe performers and their means, partners, medium, location, support, constraints and purpose of the proposed or past use.
Use as obtainedUse the identified result with its relevant features unchanged. For enactment, use the permissions and arrangements already in force and identify anything else required.
revise before useSelect a described, feasible change that would address a specific incompatibility with the receiving use.
BranchKeep source and receiving versions separately when their differences matter to use, capability or later choices. State their actual derivation. A historical lineage claim requires evidence about transmission and continuity.
Receiving-use decisionThe decision maker’s C.11 choice for the changed use, including a decision to seek more evidence. Identify a recommendation as such, and establish an earlier choice from evidence of what the decision maker selected.

MDPE.6:1 - Problem

Music and Dance results cross conditions constantly. A phrase moves between instruments. Movement is translated between bodies. A social-dance figure enters another floor culture. A choir performance becomes training material for a model. A performer uses a new prosthesis. A teaching task enters a mixed-abilities group. A live practice is compressed into a recording or short video.

Several different things can happen under one familiar name:

  • a function is preserved through different means;
  • visible material is preserved while timing, interaction, or meaning changes;
  • a receiving variant adds possibilities unavailable in the source configuration;
  • one load-bearing relation is lost, although a superficial likeness remains; or
  • both source and receiving variants remain useful and should not overwrite each other.

Compare the relation that made the source useful with the relation required in the receiving setting. A design can document derivation. Historical lineage requires evidence over time. A recording can establish the features of that performance that it captures. A broader capability claim needs evidence under conditions representative of the claimed use. A technical recommendation can be complete before anyone authorizes or carries out a change.

A project can choose a treatment for its own use on the evidence available. Population recognition, historical ancestry, transmission, retention and long-term cultural effects remain separate questions, and may be known or open on their own evidence.

MDPE.6:2 - Forces

TensionWhat must remain visible
recognizability ↔ functionFamiliar notes, steps, labels, or shapes help coordination; preserving only them can destroy timing, contact, articulation, or use.
source continuity ↔ receiving fitSource constraints carry knowledge; the new body, instrument, medium, or participant group can make literal reuse impossible.
repair ↔ branchingMaintaining one revised version can save work. Separate versions can preserve useful ways of moving or making music that depend on a particular body or medium.
Evidence and costA rehearsal or comparison can distinguish feasible choices. Use existing evidence when it settles the matter and compare the contribution of further observation with the resources and delay it would require.
technical feasibility ↔ permission and valueA result can be playable or physically possible while still lacking consent, authority, safety, or value for the receiving use.
Local choice and cultural outcomeA project can decide which variant to use. To establish transmission, recognition, style identity or continuation, examine the relevant people, practices and period.

MDPE.6:3 - Solution

Identify the source result, changed use and consequential relations. Examine what the available work establishes about suitability, earlier use or earlier decisions. For a new recommendation or choice, compare feasible treatments such as use as obtained, revision, separate versions or stopping. Apply C.11 when viable options require a choice. Consider continuity, receiving fit, feasible repairs, derivation, losses and the value of maintaining alternatives.

MDPE.6:3.1 - Identify the receiving use and who is asking or deciding

State the question in a form appropriate to its use. For example, a decision can be framed as follows.

[chooser] must decide how [source result] may be used for [receiving use] after [conditions] changed.

Identify what is being considered. A score, performance, movement description, method, dancer–prosthesis configuration, class design and event arrangement are different subjects. Name each when the question or choice covers several.

For a decision, identify who has authority to make it in the project. An arranger may recommend a concert version, a choreographer may decide what material to maintain, and a teaching team may choose the class exercise. Use existing authority, consent, permission or commitment within its scope. Obtain a missing one when the proposed action requires it. For a historical account, establish what applied at the time.

MDPE.6:3.2 - Establish the direct result and the changed conditions

Identify the existing result or proposed version and the conditions relevant to the question. For a proposed use, assess how those conditions could affect suitability. For an earlier use, report what the evidence shows about the conditions and their effects. The following are examples.

  • performer and body configuration: morphology, effectors, sensing, control, fatigue, injury, prosthesis, robot, or AI contribution;
  • musical or movement carrier: instrument, tuning, range, notation, floor, contact, spatial relation, partner, ensemble, or medium;
  • performance use: social interaction, stage, competition, installation, recording, class, rehearsal, or publication;
  • participation and support: consent, safety, access, teaching capability, venue, equipment, time, cost, or maintenance; and
  • cultural relation: expected recognizers, lineage claim, source attribution, scene boundary, or retained alternatives.

Retain conditions and dependencies that could change the answer. An unknown difference may leave the fit uncertain. Report what you can establish about each required relation.

MDPE.6:3.3 - Form the available options

Where a choice is needed, examine the following alternatives as they apply.

OptionKeep it only when
Use as obtainedThe identified source result meets the binding receiving requirements and no relevant incompatibility requires a change.
Revise before useA described feasible change can address the incompatibility while preserving any alternative that needs to remain available.
BranchBoth versions have a use, or keeping them separate preserves a distinction that matters in the changed conditions. State their derivation and limits.
Stop or defer this useNo available treatment meets the binding conditions, or the use lacks a required permission, decision authority, capability or safe operating condition.

Use options feasible under the stated conditions. If a new arrangement or action still needs designing, identify the missing contribution and use the relevant creation method, MDPE.9 or C.18. Reframe an unresolved next action through the applicable FPF method when needed. Following an authorized decision, the responsible practitioner can implement a chosen change through the relevant domain work. For an inquiry about an earlier occasion, use the evidence to distinguish the change selected from the change carried out.

MDPE.6:3.4 - Apply a Music-or-Dance comparison rule

Identify the criteria that matter to the receiving use. If comparing treatments, apply them as follows.

  1. Eliminate an option that fails a binding condition, such as consent, safe performance, a necessary performer capability, an audible cue or a stage constraint.
  2. Compare the remaining options on the uses they support, the work required, known losses and uncertainty, how well their origins are established, and any useful version they would displace.
  3. Show ties or conflicting advantages when the available criteria do not settle an ordering.
  4. Consider another observation when it could change feasibility or the choice, and its expected contribution warrants the time and cost.

The relevant relations are case-specific. Music can require range, articulation, timbre, phrasing, pulse, balance, ensemble cueing, or recording behavior. Dance can require effort, weight transfer, spine, focus, timing, contact, partner readability, floor use, consent, or spatial safety.

Use an existing characteristic or contribution result where it applies. C.17 can help establish a needed characteristic claim, and C.11.CRC can compare what a particular option contributes in this configuration. When a choice or its implementation is at issue, identify who may decide and who may carry it out.

MDPE.6:3.5 - Decide whether to probe again

When a consequential question remains, consider whether a feasible observation could narrow it enough to affect the answer. It might be a rehearsal, partner trial, instrument comparison, recognition task or safety check. Compare the likely value with the cost, delay and work displaced. Use an adequate prior check directly. Report a limit when it affects the answer.

A useful observation may distinguish viable options, resolve a tie, support rejecting the set or show that a different question requires attention. If it would only refine implementation of an already justified treatment, finish the present choice and leave that detail to the implementation work when commissioned.

MDPE.6:3.6 - Return the assessment, recommendation or receiving-use decision

Give the result in plain language. For a decision or recommendation, the following optional form can help preserve its grounds and limits. An account of earlier work can instead state what was chosen, what happened and what remains unknown, as the question requires.

receiving use and responsible chooser or adviser, where relevant:
source result and changed conditions:
available options:
must-conditions and comparison basis:
recommendation or decision: use as obtained | revise | branch | stop or defer | obtain evidence | investigate another question
what the evidence shows about continuity, change, loss or uncertainty that matters to the recommendation or decision:
any authority, permission, capability or evidence still needed:
any material condition for revisiting this decision:

For a C.11 decision, state which treatment the decision maker selected and what limits apply. Label an advisory conclusion or reconstruction of an earlier decision accordingly.

When implementation of a revision or branch is commissioned, the responsible practitioner carries it out through the relevant music, dance, teaching, production, event, tool or engineering practice. Use available evidence of each property the use requires. Obtain further evidence where needed. A.15.7 can guide a response during ongoing work, and C.11 can help with a further choice among formed options. For the schedule, use the relevant planning method and any authorization already in force. A recommendation, selection and its actual execution can be reported separately.

MDPE.6:4 - Worked Cases

The next two cases are constructed applications of published methods. The cited authors supply the approaches. The named scores, phrases, rehearsals, case evidence and decisions belong to the examples.

MDPE.6:4.1 - Music: revise an automated arrangement before concert use

McCloskey and colleagues’ program takes a MusicXML score of monophonic parts and playable ranges for the same number of target instruments or voices. It searches key transpositions, assignments of parts and octave changes. When a solution exists within these constraints, the arrangement preserves the rhythm, the durations of notes and rests, and the bar lines. Assess balance, timbre, articulation, the actual performers’ capability and concert suitability on grounds that cover those features. Release permissions are a separate matter.

In the constructed case, Arrangement-Q17-A is playable by a school ensemble. A rehearsal supports its rhythmic entries and ranges. The ensemble’s balance in that rehearsal masked the required answering phrase. This establishes what happened in that performance of Q17-A. Articulation remains uncertain.

The arranger compares:

  • use the arrangement as obtained;
  • change the dynamics and one voice allocation before use; or
  • keep an unrepaired branch.

The answering phrase must be audible at the concert. The rehearsal gives the arranger a reason to address balance before that performance. Keeping the score as a separate branch preserves the version. That leaves open how the phrase would sound with a different balance in performance. Changing the dynamics and one voice allocation offers a low-burden repair within the instruments’ ranges. More evidence about articulation could guide the edit. To judge whether the answering phrase is audible in the revised arrangement, use a performance under conditions relevant to the concert.

The arranger chooses revise before use for this concert. The decision identifies the version, the balance problem, the proposed edit and the conditions that could change the choice. To report the actual revision, later rehearsal or permission to release it, use evidence of that work or authorization. An adviser with a narrower remit could instead recommend the same treatment.

The arrangement method is described by Matthew McCloskey, Gabrielle Curcio, Amulya Badineni, Kevin McGrath and Dimitris Papamichail in Automated Arrangements of Multi-Part Music for Sets of Monophonic Instruments (2023) (consulted 25 August 2026).

MDPE.6:4.2 - Dance: keep a translated phrase as a distinct branch

In Stopgap’s Translation practice, one dancer offers movement and another explores how to convey it with a different physicality. They examine effort, the spine, focus, direction, rhythm and detail to find a corresponding action. The work can produce distinct versions and a choreographic choice. For a claim about a partner’s response, permission or historical development, use evidence that bears on it.

In this constructed case Ada, a wheelchair dancer, originates Phrase-P3. The eight-pulse curved travelling phrase uses a change of focus to invite a partner’s answering turn. Bo, a standing dancer, develops Phrase-P3-T with Ada. Direction, pulse and the exchange of focus remain usable. Bo’s changes of weight, elevation and contact geometry differ. Ada’s rolling movement is the source for Bo’s standing translation. Treating Ada’s action as an imitation would reverse their roles in making this phrase.

The direct choreography Work has also produced a compact shared version, Phrase-P3-C, with less travel and a common turning cue. Rehearsals with the named partner show that both C and the pair of conditioned P3/P3-T versions support the intended eight-pulse exchange. The participants consent to both treatments, report comfortable contact, and have enough space in this studio. The unresolved decision is which versions to maintain for the next teaching and performance block; translation itself need not be repeated.

The choreographer compares two usable treatments:

  • maintain C as the one taught and rehearsed version, retaining the earlier material as source documentation; this saves explanation and rehearsal time but removes the contrast between Ada’s rolling travel and Bo’s changing elevation from the block;
  • maintain P3 and P3-T as conditioned branches, with their different contact and cue instructions; this preserves that contrast but requires two descriptions, a separate partner briefing for each and fifteen additional rehearsal minutes when the cast changes.

The choreographer chooses P3 and P3-T for this block. Showing how the same invitation changes through Ada’s and Bo’s actions is part of the teaching and artistic aim. The partner is available, and the rehearsal schedule allows the extra fifteen minutes when the cast changes. The descriptions identify the originating phrase, the translation, the exchange they share, and the contact and cue conditions for each. This documents derivation within the case. A wider claim of historical lineage would require further evidence.

If the programme becomes one short demonstration of the common exchange, C can suffice under the conditions already tested. The same applies if the additional partner rehearsal would displace a required ensemble run and the shorter version still serves the aim. Another trial of the established shared exchange would not alter the current trade-off. If a partner later reports difficulty with a particular contact transition, reconsider its fit and whether the planned rehearsal would address it.

The choice to maintain both phrases applies to this block. Before changing descriptions or arranging a later rehearsal, use the authority, permissions and assignments that cover the work and obtain any that are missing.

The movement-translation approach comes from Stopgap, Inclusive Choreography — Translation (text consulted 4 October 2026). Ada, Bo, the phrases, alternatives and receiving-use choice are part of the constructed case.

MDPE.6:4.3 - Stop when the direct Method already returns the whole answer

A prosthesis can be designed for Jason Barnes. His playing and his own assessment in a trial can establish particular facts about control, rebound, strokes and synchronization under the tested conditions. DanceAbility offers work on inclusive improvisation for mixed-ability groups. JIZAI ARMS co-design can produce and test an exploratory equipped-body prototype. Use a suitable existing result for the question it already covers.

Use MDPE.6 when a further question concerns how a musical or movement result worked in changed conditions, whether it suits a proposed use, or which treatment to choose. A direct design or trial may already settle the source condition, the receiving question or both.

MDPE.6:5 - Recognition and Assurance

Use the questions that bear on the requested suitability assessment, recommendation, decision or historical account. For a past use, establish what the evidence supports for that period.

  • Which source result was available, or what did the proposal specify? Where it matters, identify the work and method that produced it.
  • What receiving condition and intended use changed?
  • Who made the decision, recommends a treatment or has authority to adopt one?
  • Which options are or were available for the choice, if one is at issue?
  • Which Music-or-Dance relation is a veto, and which differences are trade-offs?
  • What is preserved, changed, added, lost, or still unknown for each serious option?
  • If further inquiry is an option, what could it establish and would that result justify its cost? If it is unavailable, how does that limit the answer?
  • What was recommended, chosen, rejected or left open?
  • Which permissions and commitments apply or applied to the use in question? Which claims about capability, implementation, transmission, lineage or cultural effect need separate grounds?
  • If the decision is still in use, what change in its grounds would warrant reconsideration?

Assess the answer against the source result and evidence it uses. A filmed performance can show the exchange in that event. A prototype, course description or official endorsement can establish other particular facts. For a claim about use under new conditions, prevalence, effectiveness, style identity or continuation, examine evidence that covers the claimed result. If an expert estimate serves the task, state its grounds and uncertainty.

MDPE.6:6 - Common Failures and Repairs

FailureRepair
“It has the same name, so use it unchanged.”Compare the decision-bearing Music or Dance relations under the receiving conditions.
“It looks different, so it is a new style.”Establish the relevant difference in use or derivation. A claim about style identity or population recognition needs evidence about the practice concerned.
“Adapt it somehow.”Identify what might need revision and the relation it should preserve or restore. If an option is missing, develop one through the relevant practice, MDPE.9 or C.18.
“The prototype works, so the repertoire transfers.”Separate the engineered System and capability evidence from the musical or movement result being considered.
“A successful trial proves transmission.”State what the receiving performer did and what assistance, if any, they used. For a transmission claim, establish the contribution of the source as well as the relevant receiving enactment, using MDPE.17 where needed.
“The decision authorizes the change.”Use authority, permission, consent or commitments already in force within their scope. Obtain what is missing when action requires it. If implementation is commissioned, plan the work separately.
“More evidence is needed,” without specifying the gap.Identify what a further observation could establish and what it would cost. If sufficient evidence exists, give the supported conclusion. Where it does not, state the consequences of the remaining uncertainty.

MDPE.6:7 - Consequences

BenefitCost or caution
Shared labels no longer decide receiving use.The team must identify the actual bearer, relation, and changed condition.
Useful source and receiving alternatives can both survive through branching.Branches add maintenance, description, teaching, and comparison cost.
Established domain practice can supply an adaptation, design or lesson directly.Use MDPE.6 where a question remains about applying the result under changed conditions.
A well-chosen observation can prevent a costly mistake.Obtaining it takes time and can displace work. Reuse an adequate existing result.
A local use can be assessed or chosen on its own grounds.Claims about historical lineage, population recognition or continuation need evidence about that history or practice.

MDPE.6:8 - Rationale and Source Use

The direct music, dance, teaching, control, instrument-design and systems-engineering methods can produce the particular result. Here the practitioner compares what the changed use preserves, makes possible or loses, and the effort of repairing a mismatch or maintaining alternatives. Use that comparison to judge suitability, recommend or choose a treatment, or establish what happened in an earlier use or choice from the available evidence.

Source or maintained resultUse hereBoundary
C.11 Decision TheoryDefine the decision, identify who can make it, compare available options and decide whether another observation is worthwhile.Identify the concrete music or dance treatments and their practical comparison criteria from this case.
C.17 and C.11.CRCEstablish a relevant characteristic or compare contributions of available treatments in the receiving configuration.Judge suitability against the receiving requirements. Identify who can decide or authorize implementation when a choice or action is requested.
McCloskey et al., automatic arrangement for monophonic instrumentsFinds a feasible pitch and part assignment within the specified ranges when one exists, preserving rhythmic values and bar lines.Sound balance, the players’ capability and actual concert use require evidence from the relevant ensemble and setting.
Inclusive ChoreographyTranslate movement across physicalities by attending to effort, spine, focus, direction, rhythm and detail.Observations or accounts of the translating work can establish how the new phrase derives from the source movement. Claims about a partner’s response, authorization or cultural continuation need their corresponding grounds.
Drumming Arm study and JIZAI ARMS co-designUse the drumming study for its tested performer–prosthesis coordination and the co-design study for its equipped-body prototypes.To assess a different musical or movement use, compare its requirements with the tested configuration and performance.

Reconsider a live choice if changes in the source, receiving conditions, intended use, viable alternatives, binding requirements, evidence or authority would alter its grounds. A change today can affect future use while leaving an established past decision intact.

MDPE.6:9 - Relations

RelationUse in this pattern
C.11, C.11.CRCGovern the local choice and finite contribution comparison.
C.17, A.10Ground the characteristic and evidence claims used by the choice.
A.22.CGUSDescribes a maintained branching unfolding when one is needed.
MDPE.9Use MDPE.9 to generate candidate material when needed. Here compare feasible treatments of an identified result for the receiving use.
MDPE.10 and MDPE.3Assess performer capability and identify or design the configuration that supplies a particular performance.
MDPE.12Use a relevant observation or comparison of an earlier performance or a changed condition. Obtain a new observation when its added contribution justifies the cost.
A.15.7, C.11, and the applicable direct Music-or-Dance MethodGovern a next action during current Work, an already formed bounded choice, and the later selected change respectively.
MDPE.17, MDPE.18 and MDPE.19Address transmission, usable cultural memory and evidence of lineage, and continuation or loss, respectively.
C.36, C.36.PKeep population-level cultural claims separate from one receiving-use choice.
C.24 and applicable planning MethodsUse a suitable existing plan when implementing a choice, or plan the work when it is commissioned.

MDPE.6:End

Referenced in the corpus

20 literal mentions in other sections. Read their context to establish the relation.