MDPE.10:6 - Sources and Epistemic Boundaries
When capability development is the task, connect the learning or technical intervention with representative performance and transfer. In an assessment, state what the evidence establishes about the named performance or capability, with its time and conditions.
| Source or maintained result | Contribution used here | Boundary |
|---|---|---|
FPF E.23.CDI and A.2.2 | General holder–Work–limitation–intervention–transfer Method and holder-dependent capability identity. | They do not supply Music-or-Dance material, body, rhythm, instrument, partner, ensemble, context, or performance filling. |
| Timing examples in the Dance profile and the local Balboa cases | Layered timing, contact, weight, partner feedback, and variation for Dance capability design. | Method-design input only; no named-holder capability or mandatory lesson order. |
| Heald, Lengyel, and Wolpert, COIN sensorimotor model | Separation of motor-memory creation or updating from context-dependent expression; graded mixtures under inferred context. | Tested in human sensorimotor adaptation; other performance and learning uses remain hypotheses requiring discriminating probes. |
| Heald, Lengyel, and Wolpert, Contextual inference in learning and memory | Context dependence across conditioning, episodic memory, economic decision-making, and motor learning motivates cross-domain tests. | It does not establish one COIN computation for every memory, reasoning task, or learner. |
| Ogasa et al., decision uncertainty as a context for motor memory | Internal decision conditions can contribute to context-dependent expression. | One motor-adaptation factor does not reveal a learner’s unrestricted context categories. |
| Kumar et al., contextual cues and transition statistics | Cue availability, recency, transition history, blocked and interleaved schedules, and competing motor-memory expression. | Six visuomotor experiments do not establish one optimal schedule for every learner, Music or Dance task, or non-motor domain. |
| Reybrouck and Schiavio, Music performance as knowledge acquisition; Hohagen and Immerz, focus of attention review; Moura et al., solo assessment criteria | Coupled bodily, auditory, visual, instrumental, attentional, technical, interpretive, expressive, rhythmic, and instrument-specific pressures. | These sources do not supply one universal cue, rubric, or capability-development Method. |
| Fitch and Barnstaple, Dance as mindful movement; Silang, Zhou, and Gao, Dance pedagogy review | Automatized subskills, deliberate attention, demonstration, correction, exploration, reflection, dialog, feedback, and choice as candidate components. | The sources do not establish one definition of Dance, lesson order, or universally superior pedagogy. |
| Georgia Tech Shimon project, 2017 account, actuator study, and gesture study | Robot-holder capability, generation/control/actuation separation, bounded performance evidence, and separate human development decisions. | Results remain configuration-, material-, measure-, and condition-bounded. |
| Georgia Tech Barnes prosthesis account, finger-control account, and Drumming Arm study | Person, device, combined-configuration, engineering, co-adaptation, and performance distinctions. | One performer and device lineage does not supply a universal prosthesis or teaching Method. |
| Yamamura et al., JIZAI ARMS | Equipped-body configuration, co-design, embodied observations, and open questions. | Physical possibility and prototype interaction do not establish Dance capability or transfer. |
Reconsider the relevant development choice when another field method can supply the needed result at lower cost, a changed performer or configuration requires a different kind of evidence, or new observations challenge an explanation of transfer. The finding for earlier conditions can remain valid.