MDPE.14:8 - Rationale and Source Use
MDPE.14:8.1 - What current FPF already supplies
Use C.30.ILC to identify a conflict that remains across levels or declared scopes. When new architecture candidates are
needed, C.32.MLAO relates them to the structures they preserve, lose or change, burdens they create and the time and
conditions for revisiting them. C.32.MWA distinguishes views organized by different relations. Use A.19.CPM for a formal
comparison of admitted profiles under a stated comparator, C.11 for a bounded choice and C.28 for a causal contribution.
For music and dance, identify which bodily and artistic limits bind, what the partners or ensemble need, how the judging or platform arrangement works, and what evidence can establish the relevant use or feasibility. Those details can explain a conflict or discriminate between retaining, changing or splitting the practice.
MDPE.14:8.2 - Domain sources and the decisions they change
| Source or maintained result | Action-changing use here | Limit and reason to revisit |
|---|---|---|
| World Swing Dance Council, “Social Etiquette for Swing Dancers” | Direct practitioner guidance supports adapting slot width, choreography, and footwork to available floor space and shifting dancers, attending to the partner, and putting partner well-being above display. This makes floorcraft, partner information, safety, and split use load-bearing in the social-Dance branch. | Updated content is attributed to 2019 and concerns swing. It does not establish Urban Kiz prevalence, one universal floorcraft Method, or the constructed trial observations. Reopen when current direct social-Dance guidance or a result from Work using such a Method changes the candidate set or vetoes. |
| Lucie Lerebourg and Brice Guignard, “From theory to practice: modeling performance in breaking”, 2024 | Adds opponent-relative strategy, music not known in advance, audience and judging, fatigue and injury, and several performance criteria to the competition branch. It blocks reduction to one technical score. | This is a proposed performance model aligned with WDSF rules, not proof of adequate judging or cultural effects. Reopen when direct competition evidence changes the criteria or relation set. |
| Sato, “Reliability of judging in Olympic breaking at the 2024 Paris games”, 2025 | Distinguish single-judge from nine-judge-average agreement by criterion in the men’s Paris event; :4.3 preserves the numerical scope. | Verbal thresholds are inconsistent. Agreement is not validity; category or training changes were not experimentally compared, and other populations remain outside this result. |
| Coralie Lessard and Ariane Demain Gan, “Vers un ‘Breaking fédéral et olympique’…”, 2024 | A 2019–2023 field inquiry reports partial non-adherence to Olympic breaking and preservation concerns. This adds practitioner, institutionalization, format, and cultural-continuity relations to the judging decision. | The French field case does not represent every breaking population or establish that one arrangement caused a cultural change. Reopen when a direct population or event result changes the response. |
| Taylor, “Algorithms, affordances and the ambiguity of credit on TikTok”, 2025 | Separates recommendation feed, sound, and caption affordances and shows how informal Dance-credit practices can succeed or fail. This makes attribution and platform relations separate from discovery. | One digital ethnography and challenge case do not establish the origin of every Dance, the causal effect of recommendation, or learning transfer. Reopen when a platform or creator result changes attribution choices. |
| Blanchet et al., “Enhancing the Educational Potential of Online Movement Videos”, 2025 | Supplies a preview–part practice–fading–integration construction; Study 1’s skeleton bundle improves immediate similarity, while its sheet bundle does not. | Study 1 obscures emojis; Study 2’s component effects are not significant. Bundle results and preferences establish neither isolated emoji benefit nor durable or partner-Dance transfer. |
| Timing examples in the Dance profile and the local Balboa cases | Distinguishes continuous contributions, articulation, timing centres and representation choices. For pulse-and-accent work, MDPE.11:4.5.2 develops a common coordination Method through different Music and Dance realizations. | The shared construction informs corresponding practice; it does not make the physical techniques, feedback or acquired skills identical. Each receiving use retains its own requirements and transfer evidence. |
| Shimon project, mechatronic expressivity study, and social-gesture study | The sources identify version-specific actuation, gesture, timing, attention, noise and musical-plausibility questions for robotic performance. | Compare configurations and tasks before using findings together. The human researchers in these studies selected the design and experiments. An observed performance by the robot is a different contribution. |
Reconsider a source when its content or scope affects a relation, candidate, binding condition, observation or use. A paper, official rule or platform metric can establish the particular fact its evidence covers. For a claim about a specific performance, use evidence that covers it.