MDPE.20:8 - Rationale and Source Use
| Source | Contribution | Scope of the finding |
|---|---|---|
FPF B.5, B.5.2, A.3.3, C.28, A.15.7, C.11, A.10, C.16, C.27, C.29 and C.36 | Develop rivals, examine dynamics or causal claims, choose a current action, and trace evidence, measurement, time, representation and cultural relations. | Use domain grounds for the actual practice, trajectories, observations and intervention. |
| Buskell, What are cultural attractors? | Distinguishes uses of attractor for transformation tendency, a cluster, increased frequency and equilibrium. | Identify which use fits the available observations and what explanatory mechanism is proposed. |
| Alex Mesoudi, Cultural selection and biased transformation: two dynamics of cultural evolution | Selective transmission and biased transformation can fit similar population observations. | Identify evidence bearing differently on the two processes before attributing the distribution to one of them. |
| Deffner et al., Bridging theory and data: A computational workflow for cultural evolution | A research method connecting generative assumptions, estimands, checks on simulated data and empirical comparison. | Use it when the unresolved mechanism calls for that design. A qualified local forecast can be sufficient on existing grounds. |
| Jacoby et al., Cross-cultural comparison of rhythm priors in 15 countries, and Ravignani et al., Musical evolution in the lab exhibits rhythmic universals | Supply iterated-reproduction evidence for structured, population-sensitive rhythmic reconstruction. | Laboratory reconstruction is not the whole historical or social selection process. |
| Spiech et al., 4/4 and more | In three experiments with Western listeners, groove ratings peaked at moderate complexity in 4/4. Simpler rhythms elicited the highest ratings in the other tested meters. | Familiarity was inferred from cultural background. Enculturation and a possible innate preference for binary organization remained explanations. Reports of wanting to move and of pleasure concern those listeners and excerpts. Partnering and later development need suitable evidence. |
| Toussaint, The Geometry of Musical Rhythm, 2nd ed. (2020), especially chapters 8, 17–18, 36, and 39–42 | Supplies rhythm representations, metrics, transformations, similarity, complexity, genealogical hypotheses, and transmission cases. | The constructions do not constitute a universal rhythm ontology or causal theory of cultural attractors. |
| Heald, Lengyel and Wolpert, Contextual inference underlies the learning of sensorimotor repertoires | A model of how context affects the creation, expression and updating of human sensorimotor memories. | Treat extension to other music and dance tasks, cognition, robots, software or population change as a hypothesis with relevant alternatives. |
| Marjieh et al., Characterizing the Interaction of Cultural Evolution Mechanisms in Experimental Social Networks | In controlled singing networks, differences across topologies diminished when selection or reproduction bias was removed. The result supports considering the mechanisms together. | Use the stated population and melody-choice and singing tasks. To assign the same mechanism to another practice, examine evidence from the receiving conditions. A forecast can retain it as a plausible explanation while that attribution is open. |
Choose sources and models for the evidence and assumptions relevant to this practice and horizon. A novel or popular model may suggest a rival. Prefer it over a grounded local explanation when its account or evidence improves the forecast for this case.