Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:20:20 UTC

MDPE.20:8 - Rationale and Source Use

SourceContributionScope of the finding
FPF B.5, B.5.2, A.3.3, C.28, A.15.7, C.11, A.10, C.16, C.27, C.29 and C.36Develop rivals, examine dynamics or causal claims, choose a current action, and trace evidence, measurement, time, representation and cultural relations.Use domain grounds for the actual practice, trajectories, observations and intervention.
Buskell, What are cultural attractors?Distinguishes uses of attractor for transformation tendency, a cluster, increased frequency and equilibrium.Identify which use fits the available observations and what explanatory mechanism is proposed.
Alex Mesoudi, Cultural selection and biased transformation: two dynamics of cultural evolutionSelective transmission and biased transformation can fit similar population observations.Identify evidence bearing differently on the two processes before attributing the distribution to one of them.
Deffner et al., Bridging theory and data: A computational workflow for cultural evolutionA research method connecting generative assumptions, estimands, checks on simulated data and empirical comparison.Use it when the unresolved mechanism calls for that design. A qualified local forecast can be sufficient on existing grounds.
Jacoby et al., Cross-cultural comparison of rhythm priors in 15 countries, and Ravignani et al., Musical evolution in the lab exhibits rhythmic universalsSupply iterated-reproduction evidence for structured, population-sensitive rhythmic reconstruction.Laboratory reconstruction is not the whole historical or social selection process.
Spiech et al., 4/4 and moreIn three experiments with Western listeners, groove ratings peaked at moderate complexity in 4/4. Simpler rhythms elicited the highest ratings in the other tested meters.Familiarity was inferred from cultural background. Enculturation and a possible innate preference for binary organization remained explanations. Reports of wanting to move and of pleasure concern those listeners and excerpts. Partnering and later development need suitable evidence.
Toussaint, The Geometry of Musical Rhythm, 2nd ed. (2020), especially chapters 8, 17–18, 36, and 39–42Supplies rhythm representations, metrics, transformations, similarity, complexity, genealogical hypotheses, and transmission cases.The constructions do not constitute a universal rhythm ontology or causal theory of cultural attractors.
Heald, Lengyel and Wolpert, Contextual inference underlies the learning of sensorimotor repertoiresA model of how context affects the creation, expression and updating of human sensorimotor memories.Treat extension to other music and dance tasks, cognition, robots, software or population change as a hypothesis with relevant alternatives.
Marjieh et al., Characterizing the Interaction of Cultural Evolution Mechanisms in Experimental Social NetworksIn controlled singing networks, differences across topologies diminished when selection or reproduction bias was removed. The result supports considering the mechanisms together.Use the stated population and melody-choice and singing tasks. To assign the same mechanism to another practice, examine evidence from the receiving conditions. A forecast can retain it as a plausible explanation while that attribution is open.

Choose sources and models for the evidence and assumptions relevant to this practice and horizon. A novel or popular model may suggest a rival. Prefer it over a grounded local explanation when its account or evidence improves the forecast for this case.