Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-21 06:40:20 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-21 06:41:11 UTC · last check 2026-11-21 06:45:15 UTC

MDPE.23:6 - Sources and Epistemic Boundaries

For a recognition claim, examine the holder’s response to the relevant difference under the conditions the claim covers. Use sufficient existing evidence. Weigh the contribution and burden of further observation where uncertainty matters. If development is requested, use a suitable established method or compare feasible alternatives by their likely gain, cost, protected conditions and intended use. A teaching choice can be supported before a broader capability claim is established.

Source or maintained resultContribution used hereBoundary
Heald, Lengyel, and Wolpert, Contextual inference underlies the learning of sensorimotor repertoires and Contextual inference in learning and memoryThe sensorimotor model relates context to the creation, expression and updating of memories. The wider review examines contextual learning and possibilities for testing cue effects.Reappearance under an earlier condition can be observed in a task without identifying its mechanism. Extending the same computation to other kinds of memory or to machines requires separate evidence.
Makarome, South Indian Konnakkol in Western Musicianship Teaching, especially printed p. 38Compare the relation of syllables to positions in a beat with a syllabic group retained when its entry moves. Section 4.3 uses those conventions in a constructed timed example.The article gives a musician’s teaching experience and feedback. To establish what this learner recognized or performed, use evidence of that task under the relevant conditions.
Context-dependent recall and transfer (unpublished source note)Offers multidance switching and blending cases, possible explanations and comparisons for human or machine recognizers.Use its proposals as hypotheses and its sources as leads. Evidence from a particular task is needed to establish the mechanism there.
Balboa, Brushes, Pulse, and P-Center (unpublished source note)Develops examples of a continuous rhythmic carrier, articulation, different timing centres, partner feedback and interleaved recognition tasks.Choose an exercise order for the learner and the use. Transfer to another performer needs evidence from that use.
Wood et al., The Global Jukebox and the comparison methods in MDPE.12:6Recordings, coding guides and coder training make selected musical features comparable. Reliability differs by characteristic.Agreement among coders supports a finding about consistency for that feature. Inferring how another population recognizes or interprets it needs evidence concerning that population.
Whitehead et al., Capturing spontaneous interactivityCompare measured coordination and observations of the movement with the improvising partners’ reports of their own interaction. Differences can show what the observation task captures.To assess an audience’s recognition of a style, examine audience responses under the relevant conditions.
Dawou Tarraxo, TOCA Method: student book and teacher guideThe student and teacher materials connect touch, observation, control and awareness in individual and partnered practice.The publication identifies the exercises and intended progression. Evidence from actual learners is needed to establish their recognition or transfer.

Prefer a contextual-inference explanation when the observations favour it over relevant alternatives. Otherwise state the possibilities the evidence leaves open, or make a comparison whose attainable value warrants its cost. A practical action supported under all plausible explanations can be chosen when needed.