MDPE.24:3 - First Useful Result
When someone will rely on a finding, give the following details that apply to their question.
- Question and use. Which claim is at issue? If the result affects a decision, identify the engineering, funding, maintenance, measurement or responsibility it bears on.
- Prior whole, when relevant. Identify the established prior whole, its period and its identity rule. For a transition question, state any missing or disputed identity grounds.
- Candidate. Identify the proposed subject and the admitted kind whose criterion it must meet.
- Change or claim under examination. Identify what was observed or proposed and any features the evidence leaves undetermined.
- Comparison, when a prior whole is established. Explain how its relations and identity rule account for the change, why the claim needs another whole, or which deciding fact remains unknown.
- Construction and evidence. To identify a whole, establish its constituents, their constructive relations and assembly, its identity rule, a composition-dependent characteristic and compatibility with a governed larger assembly. Apply the separate criterion for its kind. Include evidence about memory, selection, continuity or effects where the claim needs it.
- Finding. State which whole carries the claim for the period. For formation, transition or continuity, identify the dated events and relations that support the finding. Specify any failed condition or what the evidence leaves open.
- Project consequence, if any. State what the finding means for the project, including grounds for retaining its boundary or a proposed, authorized or completed change, as applicable.
- Further evidence, if needed. Say what the comparison still requires and whether that evidence can be obtained.
- Reopen condition: [new construction, loss of persistence, changed identity rule, or contrary evidence].