RMP.1:0 - Use This When
Use this method when you need to establish what an available source or ordinary professional practice can answer and whether an unresolved question warrants research. Start with the intended use, the question as far as you can state it and the material you have. If the needed distinction is still unclear, develop it in §4.0. Use a suitable existing answer or recover one through §4.3. For routine professional work, §4.4 identifies the result needed and how to obtain or supply it. Prepare a ResearchQuestionBrief when the inquiry meets all four research-membership conditions.
A request for “more data,” a favored answer in search of support, a surprising observation, a disputed transfer from test to field or a literature search with a possible answer can all prompt this question. To determine membership, examine the inquiry itself. Affiliation, job title, grant, venue, publication plan, tool choice or data collection gives no verdict on the four conditions.
Give an answer from available knowledge, a particular gap or a research question that states what remains to learn and what evidence would suffice. Use RMP.2 for an open design question when a compatible ResearchQuestionBrief and current frame are available.
For a design choice use RMP.2. For an instrument, access or risk decision, engineering or policy action, or repair to a reusable professional Method, use the practice and authority responsible for that result.
RMP.1:0.1 - Working Terms
| Name in this pattern | What it denotes |
|---|---|
| receiving question and use | The practical or knowledge question, who needs the answer and how they will use it. If it informs a decision, identify whose values and authority apply to that decision. |
| qualified current frame | An account of what the sources support for the receiving question, the conditions under which they apply, and which important alternatives or gaps remain. It may be supplied or prepared through §4.3. |
| unresolved knowledge question | A question about a specified claim or contribution to a body of knowledge. An answer or criticism could support retaining, revising, narrowing, rejecting or adding it for the intended use. Establish the gap against relevant knowledge available for that use. |
| criticism demand | The error, rival explanation, source misuse, dependence, bias, missing context or unsupported transfer a defensible answer must be able to reveal. More than one design may meet that requirement. |
| answer condition | What the evidence must establish to answer the bounded question for its intended use, with the uncertainty that use permits. |
| useful stop | The point at which the evidence gives an adequate answer, or the present work can finish with a reasoned refusal, uncertainty or an identified missing input. In the latter cases state what remains open and what could reopen the inquiry. |
| ResearchQuestionBrief | The bounded question, current frame, intended change in knowledge, criticism requirement, constraints, answer condition and conditions for stopping or reopening work when all four membership criteria hold. A brief can supply RMP.2. |
| exact supplied-result return | An existing result from sources, comparison, evidence assessment or retrieval that answers the question within a specified scope and limits. |
| exact non-research return | The precise question, available material, ordinary professional result needed and where it can be supplied or obtained. Include any condition that would reopen the research question. Examples include qualification, monitoring, troubleshooting, audit and evaluation. |
| research-boundary hold | The missing or stale source or result, the decision about research it prevents, its source or supplier when known, and the condition for reconsidering the question. |
Identify what each contribution changes and what evidence supports it. An inquiry may change the knowledge account. An operating, physical, social or administrative change needs the corresponding action, and an authorized decision when applicable. One may use the research result in making that decision.