Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 22:15:20 UTC

RMP.1:11 - SoTA-Echoing

How can a practitioner recognize a research question that admits consequential criticism while preserving ordinary professional uses of the same techniques?

The OECD’s Frascati Manual 2015, chapter 2, offers a cross-sector comparator for research and development statistics. RMP.1 adapts novelty and creativity to the unresolved knowledge and epistemic task of the whole inquiry. Section 4.6 describes its use of the other criteria. Frascati §2.16 recognizes the potential knowledge contribution of reproduction and discrepancies. To determine what a repeated procedure contributes here, examine its question and evidence.

The National Academies’ replicability account explains how a justified design and new data can change support for a claim. In §5.7 the replication can therefore earn research membership without a newly invented procedure. The same systematic measurement can give an ordinary quality-control verdict. RMP.1 distinguishes the cases through the whole inquiry’s knowledge task, qualified question, trace and bounded contribution. These four conditions combine and adapt the sources for the practitioner’s question.

UNESCO’s Recommendation on Open Science recognizes contributions by citizens and communities outside a particular research institution. This supports judging membership independently of affiliation. Ethics, safety, rights, confidentiality, security, access and community authority continue to govern conduct and disclosure.

An institutional or activity-based classification can help with staffing, funding or administration. Employer, venue and use of a laboratory can identify candidate work. They cannot distinguish routine testing from an investigation of a disputed mechanism. For that distinction examine the question, the task of the whole inquiry, the trace and the intended knowledge contribution.

Use field evidence for the truth of a claim, competent sources for its instruments and the governing authority for permission. Reconsider the affected membership criterion when a stronger cross-sector source changes it, evidence shows it misclassifies a design family or group, or a source rule changes what can be established about the relevant knowledge. Revisit prior uses that relied on the changed grounds.