RMP.11:11 - SoTA-Echoing
| Source | Retained contribution | Use boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Stacey et al., Methods as a form of engineering knowledge | Method knowledge, variation and loss in engineering contexts. | Use the conceptual history to frame a question. Specific causal attribution and authority for a current choice have their own grounds. |
| Collier, Understanding Process Tracing, with 2019 addendum | The 2011 treatment supplies within-case sequencing and diagnostic observations. The addendum develops relations among rivals and examines the limits of rigid necessity/sufficiency test classes. | Use this historical foundation with later work on inference and C.28 when a causal use is at issue. |
| Fairfield and Charman, Explicit Bayesian Analysis for Process Tracing and A Dialogue with the Data | Compare specified alternatives conditional on prior evidence, account for source dependence and reconsider existing evidence as hypotheses change. | These operations support qualitative comparison. Numerical probabilities require their own justified assumptions. Judge causal support and a present architecture choice separately. |
| Fully specified Bayes factors for hypothesis testing and sensitivity analysis in process tracing, v2, 2026 preprint | Model-based evidence weights and sensitivity analysis can show how coding, selection and weighting affect a conclusion. | The binomial observation model and comparisons to one rival require substantive justification. Clustered dependence among sources limits the guarantees. Use the numerical procedure where these conditions fit. |
| Mahoney, The Logic of Process Tracing Tests | Logic of weak, necessary-condition and strongly discriminating tests. | Use the test logic to assess particular observations, then compare the support for the links across the chain. |
Current FPF C.28 | The causal-use question, rung, support components, common threat screen, verdict, permissible reliance, limits and conditions for reconsideration. | Use the verdict within its specified scope. A downstream decision also requires its own criteria and authority. |
Reconsider the historical or causal account when a relied-on source changes the diagnostic comparison, an observed case exposes a consequential gap between historical and causal claims, or an intended use needs evidence the present account does not supply.