Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 22:51:26 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 22:54:45 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 23:10:20 UTC

RMP.11:11 - SoTA-Echoing

SourceRetained contributionUse boundary
Stacey et al., Methods as a form of engineering knowledgeMethod knowledge, variation and loss in engineering contexts.Use the conceptual history to frame a question. Specific causal attribution and authority for a current choice have their own grounds.
Collier, Understanding Process Tracing, with 2019 addendumThe 2011 treatment supplies within-case sequencing and diagnostic observations. The addendum develops relations among rivals and examines the limits of rigid necessity/sufficiency test classes.Use this historical foundation with later work on inference and C.28 when a causal use is at issue.
Fairfield and Charman, Explicit Bayesian Analysis for Process Tracing and A Dialogue with the DataCompare specified alternatives conditional on prior evidence, account for source dependence and reconsider existing evidence as hypotheses change.These operations support qualitative comparison. Numerical probabilities require their own justified assumptions. Judge causal support and a present architecture choice separately.
Fully specified Bayes factors for hypothesis testing and sensitivity analysis in process tracing, v2, 2026 preprintModel-based evidence weights and sensitivity analysis can show how coding, selection and weighting affect a conclusion.The binomial observation model and comparisons to one rival require substantive justification. Clustered dependence among sources limits the guarantees. Use the numerical procedure where these conditions fit.
Mahoney, The Logic of Process Tracing TestsLogic of weak, necessary-condition and strongly discriminating tests.Use the test logic to assess particular observations, then compare the support for the links across the chain.
Current FPF C.28The causal-use question, rung, support components, common threat screen, verdict, permissible reliance, limits and conditions for reconsideration.Use the verdict within its specified scope. A downstream decision also requires its own criteria and authority.

Reconsider the historical or causal account when a relied-on source changes the diagnostic comparison, an observed case exposes a consequential gap between historical and causal claims, or an intended use needs evidence the present account does not supply.