Jump to text
On this page
Copy and source
Published source confirmed at last check

Source changed 2026-11-18 21:11:39 UTC · snapshot created 2026-11-18 21:12:35 UTC · last check 2026-11-18 21:55:20 UTC

RMP.11:4.4 - Weigh Historical Evidence between the Actual Accounts

Distinguish the reliability of a source from the diagnostic weight of its contents. A reliable fact expected equally under all serious accounts can establish the sequence while leaving their relative support unchanged. A potentially discriminating statement may carry little weight if its date, authorship or relation to the events is uncertain. Use these judgements when grading claims in :4.1.

  1. Compare the actual accounts. For the same finding, ask how expected it would be under each serious account given the evidence already used. Explain the difference. If two causes can operate together, compare their proposed contributions or consider a combined account.
  2. Examine how the finding became available. Distinguish the event from a later assertion. Ask what the source could observe, what would be recorded and how records were selected and preserved. Absence can weigh against a proposed event when that event should have left a record in the material actually examined.
  3. Identify new information and its origin. A brochure, an interview repeating it and an article citing the interview can transmit one assertion. Assess what each adds given the earlier evidence. A new source date or an independent Work observation can add information even within the same archive.
  4. Return a conditional comparison. State which findings favour which accounts and under what assumptions. Report unresolved rivals when the relevant observations are equally expected or source uncertainty defeats discrimination. Examine whether the preference survives plausible changes in coding, selection, dependence or weight of a finding. If it does not, describe that sensitivity. If the question needs a numerical comparison and the observation model and assumptions warrant it, use a quantitative analysis.
  5. Reconsider earlier findings when the account changes. A new actor, date or proposed mechanism can change what earlier evidence implies. Compare the revised account with the relevant prior corpus and the new item, accounting for dependence.
  6. Identify the use the evidence supports. A comparison can yield a scoped historical hypothesis or identify a worthwhile further inquiry. For causal reliance, supply the relevant findings and limits to C.28. If a revised premise mattered to an existing repertoire or decision, trace that reliance in C.39.RP, A.3.1.QM or C.32.MWA.PP. A current Method can retain a qualification that rests on independent evidence.