RHY.5:5.4 - One attack can conceal two different instructions
Consider two instructions over two equal beats. A starts a tone on the first beat and sustains it until the end of the second. B starts at the same time, stops at the end of the first beat and leaves the second beat silent. With this beat reference, the attack-only syllable ta specifies the same onset in both cases. It leaves sustain versus silence open.
In Cha’s convention, ta–ah carries a tone through the next beat and ta (ta) marks a rest there. Give the convention when using the parentheses. In other Takadimi uses, parentheses can mark muted, unarticulated positions without specifying a rest. Cha also proposes voiced rest cues ending in sh. The voice supplies a rehearsal cue while the instrumental phrase remains silent.
Another option uses a two-beat guide and a duration instruction. For A, start and continue to the end. For B, start, stop after one beat and remain silent. A familiar gesture and duration notation can supply this information without introducing new syllables.
Either augmented representation answers the sustain-or-stop question. The bare ta leaves it open. Evidence of a performance with the teaching cue supports that assisted use. A claim about unprompted performance requires evidence from the conditions in which the learner must perform without the cue.