VENICE FILM FESTIVAL
Venice Review: Darren Aronofsky’s Mother! Is a Spectacular Attack of a Movie
byGUY LODGE
SEPTEMBER 5, 2017 12:21 PM
There are angrily haunted walls, live organs in the toilet bowl, and floor cracks that turn into squidgy open wounds in Mother!, with a blazing inferno consuming the screen in the very first shot. But those might just be bloody, shuddery distractions: with apologies to Sartre, in Darren Aronofsky’s exhilarating, shape-shifting horror-not-horror movie, the real hell is other people. As lusty boos bounced off the walls of the Venice press screening theater while the credits rolled, I briefly felt much the same way. I wanted calm to absorb the pained, deranged provocation I’d just seen, not others’ loud, livid snap judgments; there’d been more than enough sound and fury in the preceding two hours.
I get the discord: Mother! is not a well-behaved movie. It does not obey the loosest expectations, even for an art-genre whatchamacallit by which we eagerly anticipate being freaked out. In terms of cinematic structure and discipline, it makes Black Swan look like an episode of Murder, She Wrote. Aronofsky compresses and splinters time with as much abandon as he stretches logic; the film’s story world turns as infinitely vast or as claustrophobically tiny as he needs it to be from one scene to the next. Aronofsky has cast his audience adrift like this before: 11 years ago, in the likewise contentiously Venice-premiered The Fountain, in which polite narrative and metaphysical rule sheets also gave way to persuasive, expressive surges of feeling.