The New Dick Van Dyke Show

I really liked this show when it was on. I would have been a young girl (10-11) back then. I'm assuming the episode about the daughter seeing her parents having sex didn't air. If it did, how do posters know what actually took place in that particular episode? Quite frankly, in the early 70's, that would have been too hot to handle. And I'm not sure an episode like that even today would be appropriate for very young children to see. At 10-11 years of age, I would have been kind of horrified if I had watched that episode with my parents in the room. I was just beginning to learn about the birds & bees at that age. Very uncomfortable and very before it's time if Carl Reiner got ticked off because they wouldn't air it. And I think all of the actors involved should have understood the controversy such an episode would have brought to the public that they weren't ready for at that point in time. It was a good show and I think it got axed way too early. I just never knew the whole story about the "sex" themed episode and why the show was canceled due to the actors/producers being angry about it.

This show had lots of stars and sorta-stars, but never lived up to the period-excellence of DVD's previous show.

A clear case of the parts being greater than the whole.

I remember as a kid tuning in hoping to relive the excellence of the earlier Dick van Dyke show, only to get this.

Hope Lang was not MTM, which she repeatedly demonstrated with her wan performances and her insufferable camera glances. The supporting players were uninteresting and there was none of the dynamism the old DVD show managed to bring to both home and office. MTM advanced, DVD struggled.

I don't know whether the "making love" scene was true, but it does sum up the era - with inhibitions gone, any absurd thing became relevant. It may be that DVD as a comic performer needed the supporting cast he had, not the ones here that he ended up with.

Not a good show.

Admittedly, I am a perennial Dick Van Dyke fan. This show should / would have gotten more notoriety maybe with a different name, against different competition, and without the solid precursory success of the original Dick Van Dyke Show.

Nonetheless, these are great watches today just like the original Dick Van Dyke show, and I hope they are released as a DVD set for fans of this great entertainer. There's significant differentiation between the Hope Lange version of Dick's wife and the Mary Tyler Moore one 10 years prior, and Fannie Flagg of "Match Game" fame and Nancy Dussault later of "Too Close for Comfort" fame both give terrific supporting performances. Lot of awesome guest star appearances too, names and faces you'll recognize from 60s and 70s TV.

Highly recommend!

I enjoyed this show even more than the original Dick van Dyke show. I always found Mary Tyler Moore a little annoying - never liked her show, but loved Rhoda - and found most of the characters a little one-note (Sally couldn't find someone to marry, Buddy couldn't say anything nice about his wife, Mel couldn't say anything nice about anyone but Alan and that was fake, and Alan was bald). But I really enjoyed this, even though I only got to see a few episodes. The episode where Dick got stuck in a tree was a hoot! And I always loved Hope Lange. She never over-acted or over-reacted, but just seemed real.