The New Perry Mason

The original "Perry Mason" TV show was one of the classics of its time. Running for nine years from 1957-1966, the series had everything going for it: good writing, great music, exceptional acting, and all the rest of it. Raymond Burr played Perry Mason so well that it became difficult to see anyone else playing him; likewise, the rest of the cast, including Barbara Hale as Della Street and William Hopper as Paul Drake, fit their roles so well that any attempts at using other actors would hardly be acceptable to viewers.

But, TV producers being the way they are, there was of course an attempt to reboot the show in the 1970s, because they just couldn't stand the idea of not piggybacking off of an iconic show after running out of other ideas. Enter "The New Perry Mason", a short-lived series that made it only a half season before being cancelled. While this series certainly isn't terrible, there's no reason to rate it particularly high in view of the fact that this same idea had already been done before in a much better way - that of course being in the original series itself. Nothing that made the original so good is present in this reboot - at best, everything is mediocre. It's understandable why this show flopped, even if it wasn't the worst - it couldn't live up to the original, and there was really no point trying to make it do that considering they couldn't even use the same actors as before.

To start off, there's the theme song. "Park Avenue Beat" from the original is replaced with a semi-memorable fanfare that hardly captures the tone of what the series is really about. While not bad, this theme song hardly lives up to the original theme by Fred Steiner and already makes it incredibly difficult for one to give the series a chance after years of the old show. They certainly weren't giving it their best effort - something which can be said for the entirety of the show.

As for acting, there's very little to write home about here as well. Monte Markham is cast in the role of Perry Mason, but of course he's no Raymond Burr. While Markham does carry himself well onscreen, that's about all that can be said for his performance - otherwise, he clearly lacks the presence that Burr brought to the role which makes it a tough sell. Sharon Acker is unexceptional as Della Street and looks like some 70s fashion model - and there's hardly any screen chemistry between her and Markham like Burr and Barbara Hale had. The same can be said about Albert Stratton's performance as Paul Drake: bland, nothing special, and certainly not living up to William Hopper. All in all, the trio in this series doesn't at all fit together well like the original trio did, and if the producers wanted to keep the show, that would have to be the first thing to fix.

Harry Guardino, likewise, doesn't really bring anything new to the role of Hamilton Burger. To be honest, his physical appearance reminds me more of someone who should be playing some pipe-smoking sherlock more than someone who should be playing a District Attorney. The biggest injustice, however, is Dane Clark as Lieutenant Tragg, who has no smug manner about him like Ray Collins, nor any trace of humor (for example, the writers literally gave him a great opportunity to be just like the original Lieutenant Tragg when they wrote in the part about his "sensitive instrument" - but when Clark says it, he's completely humorless).

When it comes to the writing, there's nothing too bad to be said, although the writers certainly could have written in some things that would give the cast a better chemistry. The stories are as creative as ever, which is perhaps the best thing to be said about the show, but without the proper cast to carry them out, they don't really have the same feel as the original.

To conclude, "The New Perry Mason" reeks of mediocrity - from music to acting, there is nothing that makes this show special. It's not bad, but it's not very good, and to be honest, I see no reason to watch it as a casual observer considering a far better show was already made (that being the original Perry Mason). The only people I can truly recommend this to are diehard Perry Mason fans who want to watch everything Perry Mason - and even then, I doubt they'd be impressed with it after becoming so used to the old show.

The New Perry Mason had the misfortune to come along in one of the writer's strike years, 1973. Shows for all three networks were delayed, and many scripts were rushed and weak as a result. Bill Bixby's show "The Magician" was another casualty, though it managed the full season and The New Perry Mason was canned after a half season.

For fans still well familiar with the original series, this cast simply doesn't' stand up, and I write that as someone who has always liked Monte Markham. The one interesting role was Match Game regular (and Jack Klugman's eternally estranged wife) Brett Summers in the role of Gertie, the receptionist.

But Markham didn't bring the presence to the role that Raymond Burr pulled off, and none of the other actors brought the same life to their characters, either. Still, part of that may have been the writing. Scenes were too brief and rushed, and the courtroom scenes were slap-dash and brief.

This is the first Perry Mason series I've seen (since I wasn't even born when the original Raymond Burr starrer appeared) and saw it in its entirety (at least what the local station showed). Monte Markham may be a great stage actor, but he never found success on TV and this is why. He and the rest of the cast act like robots, mouthing lines with nary a trace of believability. Mason is supposed to be a criminal lawyer not a corporate one (I guess Markham forgot that). The best evidence of a live character there would be Harry Guardino's Ham(ilton) Burger. He's the only actor who looks the least uncomfortable with the role. The mysteries posed are good, almost Murder-She-Wrote-like quality. But the pace is too fast (though not by today's standards), the courtroom scenes (where the highest point of the drama is expected) are much too brief. If only they made them movies-of-the-month like Columbo or McCloud, there may have been a chance for this show to find its audience.

Nowadays, there's been a lot of moaning about remakes and how Hollywood seems to have no new ideas. What The New Perry Mason proves is that the remake idea is nothing new, and that the remakes from the past are no less lackluster.

I agree that casting is the biggest problem here. Monte Markham is an actor who's a joy to watch and can play many different parts, but Raymond Burr's shoes are pretty big to fill (in more ways than one!). Add to that the fact that the original Mason series was a syndication staple at the time, and most people would rather see the better Mason. The show was in trouble from the start.

As for the rest of the cast, Sharon Acker, who, like Markham, was a ubiquitous presence on TV at that time, is more style than substance as efficient secretary Della Street. In other words, she seems to function more as eye candy than anything else. Albert Stratton is a colorless Paul Drake. Old pros Harry Guardino and Dane Clark try hard, as D. A. Hamilton Burger and Lt. Arthur Tragg respectively, but even these talented actors can't elevate the series. Clark, in particular, lacks the smart-ass charm that Ray Collins brought to the role in the original series.

They tried hard behind the scenes, as well, stacking the deck with vets from the original series (Ernie Frankel, Art Seid, Arthur Marks, Orville H. Hampton), but the stories aren't as compelling as anything the original series offered. The courtroom scenes, in particular, which were the strong parts of the original, seem weak.

I'm currently watching this series via YouTube. There aren't many more to go, so I've decided to ride it out, but I'm not expecting much from the remaining episodes. At least this is light years better than the remake of Raymond Burr's other iconic series, Ironside, which had a very short run in its own right. The new Ironside totally stuck on ice, but that's a subject for another review.

They did make frequent TV movies of Perry Mason in the 80s and early 90s (until Raymond Burr died) and they were very successful even thought they were not part of a program "wheel" as were "McCloud", "Columbo", "McMillan and Wife", and such. They were successful because they starred the original Mason, Raymond Burr, and the original secretary Della, Barbara Hale, who had a tremendous screen chemistry between them. They had nothing to do with the Markham attempt at revival. It is hard to imagine what CBS was thinking to try to bring back such a big hit with an all-new cast just seven years after the original ended and while its star was still appearing in a second hit show, "Ironside". I also don't know what they were thinking in trying to have Monte Markham as Mason, either; the casting could hardly have been worse. Markham can play lot of things; Mason was NOT one of them.