The Murder Secret

'The Murder Secret' aka 'Don't Be Afraid of Aunt Martha' is a strange low budget Giallo slasher flick from the late 1980's. This movie has a cool off-kilter atmosphere and an eerie unsettling tone to it, along with some cool gory death scenes. But its not without its flaws such as the awful dubbing, questionable acting/dialogue, bad pacing and predictable plot twists that really bogs things down to sub-par levels.

The plot = Richard Hamilton (Gabriele Tinti) takes his family for a long drive to his Aunt Martha's (Sacha Darwin) house after she has just been released from the asylum after 30 years. Only when they get there, she isn't there just the caretaker Thomas (Maurice Poli) and his message that she will arrive the next day, but can they survive the night with a killer roaming the area.

The direction by Mario Bianchi is competent enough considering the obvious small budget and the cottage location is used effectively enough, but as I already mentioned the pacing is very boring with almost nothing happening for the first hour, I wouldn't mind if the director used this time to flesh out the family or to build some tension. But we don't get any of that unfortunately instead we get a rather mundane set up of pointless interactions with nothing happening. Even with this wafer-thin plot there was potential to add more depth to this movie, but nope instead you're just waiting around until the last act which is where all the excitement happens. Now the death scenes towards the end are rewarding as you do get some shocking violent scenes, but it requires a lot of patience to get there and even then the climax ends on a rather sour and confusing note.

The acting was god-awful the only performance of note worthy was the main lead Gabriele Tinti who was okay but felt way too passive and uninspired to really root for. Overall 'The Murder Secret' is a confusing mess of a Giallo that takes way too long to get off the ground.

The plot of "The Murder Secret" begins with Richard Hamilton(played by Gabriele Tinti)receiving a letter from his long lost and psychotic Aunt Martha inviting him and his family to visit her at her remote countryside villa.Together he and his wife Nora,their older children Georgia and Charles and their younger son Maurice decide to stay at Aunt Martha's villa.Upon their arrival Aunt Martha is nowhere to be found and the Hamilton's are instead received by the outwardly friendly yet decidedly creepy Thomas who claims that he is Aunt Martha's caretaker and that she will join them shortly.Soon series of bloody murders is set in motion..."Don't Be Afraid of Aunt Martha" by Mario Bianchi is an alright slasher/giallo with three extremely bloody murder scenes including chainsaw decapitation of a young boy.The acting is okay and the plot is entertaining.If you liked similarly gore and nudity laden Andrea Bianchi's "Massacre" give this one a chance.7 crazy aunts out of 10.

The Murder Secret (1989)

* 1/2 (out of 4)

Richard Hamilton (Gabriele Tinti) takes his wife (Adriana Russo) and their two kids to visit his Aunt Martha. Even though Richard hasn't seen her in years when they arrive to her house she's no where to be found. The family is told to just wait around but soon murders begin to happen.

THE MURDER SECRET, aka THE BROKEN MIRROR and many other titles, is one of the handful of films that were released as "Lucio Fulci Presents" and, as you can probably tell, he had very little to nothing to do with the actual film, although clips would eventually show up in his A CAT IN THE BRAIN (as well as clips from other movies). If you're looking for a great Italian horror film then you certainly won't find it here, although there are a few interesting moments.

People often talk about how the Italian horror market was in its dying days during the late 80s but people also seem to forget that the genre was pretty much dying everything. This film here has a few interesting ideas that I'm sure could have been better exploited back in the early part of the decade when film's were allowed a bigger budget. There are a couple twists in the story, which is actually pretty good but the biggest problem is the fact that there's way too much talking and not enough action. Not to mention, the film really drags, contains no atmosphere and certainly no scares.

Outside the nice plot twists, the film also offers up a couple memorable death scenes. The decapitations are all done without too much of a budget so they aren't very convincing but at least there's some blood here. There's also an obvious wink to the shower scene in PSYCHO, which is certainly the highlight of the picture.

After spending 30 years in a mental hospital, aunt Martha is free to leave and writes a letter to her relatives, inviting them to spend a weekend on her isolated country house. But when they get there, they meet only the caretaker, who informs them that their aunt has not arrived yet....After 50 slow minutes of virtually NOTHING HAPPENING, there are a few gory murders, and then it's time for the twisted secrets and nonsensical plot revelations. As it often happens in these Italian horror films, there is a very atmospheric score, which actually does most of the director's work for him. And I must mention that the actress who plays the daughter (Jessica Moore) is really hot. There are two scenes of her checking herself out in the mirror, and let me tell you, this girl has every right to be proud of what she sees. (*1/2)

This terrifically trashy, but frequently fun low budget B-Horror is riotously replete with maniacal aunts and all manner of spooky, crudely exploitative Italianate B-horror lunacy! Produced by esteemed horror icon Lucio Fulci, starring charismatic actor Gabriele Tinti, and directed with 'relative' competency by Euro-cult hero Mario 'Satan's Baby Doll' Bianchi. While Mario Bianchi's initially tepid creepshow 'The Murder Secret' takes a wee while to come to the B-Movie boil, but when it finally reaches body temperature it righteously rewards the more patient horror fan with a scurrilous selection of screw-headed set pieces!

The benign inclusion of a tantalizing shower scene luridly exposing the gratifyingly buxom assets of super-starlet Jessica Moore effectively increases the film's more aggressively voyeuristic content! 'The Murder Secret' is no less bemusing a proposition than many of the Fulci/Lenzi helmed horror films from the same era, and might be more essential to those obsessive B-Movie mavens compelled to watch every gonzo, blood-spattered Italian horror made in the 80s! Happily, there is just enough warped, schlocky shenanigans in 'The Murder Secret' to merit a single viewing, and the distractingly zesty electronic score by maestro Gianni Esposito certainly didn't go unnoticed! Perhaps it might be time for a comprehensive Bianchi Blu-ray horror box set? In addition, ardent Lucio Fulci fans might care to note that this was one of the six films that had its bloodier elements edited into his audaciously skewed splatter masterpiece 'A Cat in The Brain'.