The Covered Wagon

Good accuracy on most of the equipment and clothing. The leading characters' make-up was almost clown-like and over-acting was running rampant, but that was the norm of the time and cannot really be criticized. What cannot be excused is the pathetically weak and insipid story line.

Jim Bridger's only surviving child, Virginia K. Bridger Wachsman Hahn, reacted violently after viewing Tully Marshall's portrayal of her father in the then newly-released `The Covered Wagon' in 1923. She instituted a $1,000,000 libel action against the Famous Players-Lasky Corporation, charging that they wrongfully depicted her father as a drunkard and a man of questionable morals, defaming his character and casting a stain upon her birth.

Judge Albert L. Reeves, of the federal court at Kansas City, sustained a demurrer filed by the defendants on the grounds no one could recover damages for defamation of the character of an ancestor, setting the precendent for Hollywood's dismal record of accuracy in its portrayal of historic personages.

THE COVERED WAGON is an ordinary programmer western dressed up with epic scenes of wagon trains and sudden ambushes. The spectacle is incredible, but it's barely enough to keep interest. The cast is at the very least enlivened by the presence of several wonderful character actors, like Tully Marshall and Ernest Torrance. I really love Torrance-- I wish he was the main character instead. They really make the movie. Otherwise, it's just very generic and it's hard to see what made it such a massive hit back in 1923. Maybe there was an ardent desire for footage of wagon trains moving back and forth?

Monumental in scope and mamouth in nature, March 1923's "The Covered Wagon" has been acknowledged as the first epic movie Western. One TV personality, Joe Franklin, even called this "the first American epic not directed by Griffith." What makes "The Covered Wagon" such a pioneering work is not because it was the highest production budget for a Western film yet, over $750,000, and was the number one box office draw for 1923. The movie established iconic scenes future Westerns films would copy. The motion picture was the first to show realistic views of the pioneering frontier, which included a convey of authentic covered wagons from California's first settlers that had been lovingly preserved. In addition, the trials the wagoners went through during their journey, such as river crossings, Indian attacks, severe weather, even quicksand, are all seen in one complete package. Lastly, a buffalo hunt, although minuscule in comparison to more impressive modern day episodes in today's films, is undertaken. The number of buffalos back in 1923 was a fraction of today's amount, so the producers gathered what small number of the animals living back then for the hunting sequence.

During the river-crossing scene where horses were hauling the wagons across a deep ford, actress Lois Wilson was so traumatized witnessing two horses drowning she returned to her tent and didn't work the rest of day.

"The Covered Wagon" was the final of many Lois Wilson and J. Warren Kerrigan movies where they paired up as a romantic couple. The irony of the matrimony roles they played through that span, neither one actually married in real life. Wilson, appearing in over 150 movies, made the transition to sound, but retired in 1941 over the type of roles she was offered. She wrapped up her acting career in three network soap operas, including 'The Guiding Light' and 'The Secret Storm.' Actor Kerrigan's career was sinking like a rock when he receive the romantic lead in "The Covered Wagon." A rising star in the mid-1910's, he made an insensitive comment when the United States entered the Great War in 1917, stating actors, musicians, great writers and other artists shouldn't be sacrificed on the battle front. "I think that first they should take the great mass of men who aren't good for anything else, or are only good for the lower grades of work," he callously said. That statement and the fact he was living with his mother as well as a partner, actor James Vincent, in the same house, sunk his standing in Hollywood. His friendship with director James Cruz got him the lead role in "The Covered Wagon." The movie was President Warren G. Harding's favorite film as well as the creator of Godzilla, Japanese producer Tomoyuki Tanaka. "The Covered Wagon" was also nominated for American Film Institute's '100 Most Thrilling Film Ever Made' category.

The first great western epic, The Covered Wagon established many of the cliches that appear in many subsequent westerns, both "A" and "B" features alike.

Here for the first time, we have the wagon train of eastern settlers trekking west in search of a new land and a new start. We have the circling of the wagons in preparation for the Indian attack, the attack itself and the ride to the rescue of the besieged wagons.

Cruze captures the feel of what a real wagon train journey must have been like. The long lines of slow moving covered wagons, the dusty trails, life and death situations on the prairie, as well as the celebrations around the campfire.

The sub-plot of boy-girl-villain is "B" western calibre, however, the players carry it of admirably. J. Warren Kerrigan as the hero is adequate but not memorable. The lovely Lois Wilson as the heroine and a young Alan Hale as the villain are much better. It is curious that the Cruze portrayed legendary mountain man Jim Bridger (Tully Marshall) as an absent-minded, liquor swilling comedy relief.

The ending is strictly Hollywood. Boy gets girl of course and the villain is defeated, but I thought that the final shoot-out left a little to be desired.

Despite its apparent faults, The Covered Wagon remains today as powerful a film as it must have been in 1923.

THE COVERED WAGON was based on the novel of the same name by the now forgotten writer Emerson Hough and recounts the 1848 trek of a wagon train from Kansas City to Oregon. It remains a landmark film in many ways. Originally planned as just another Western programmer, it was expanded by director James Cruze into the TITANIC of its day. Like TITANIC, it cost a fortune to make and made a fortune at the box office.

Cruze, the son of Mormon parents, grew up in Utah and could still remember the Old West as it really was. He saw this film as the opportunity for him to advance beyond the programmers and Fatty Arbuckle features that he had been doing at Paramount up until then. He demanded total authenticity which included not only the original locations, but also a cast of 3000 (including real Native Americans) and over a hundred genuine Conestoga wagons. Despite the enormous expense and the prolonged shooting schedule, the film was one of the biggest successes of the Silent Era and Cruze was on his way to becoming one of the top directors of the 1920's (another of his epic films OLD IRONSIDES is also available on home video).

The acting is restrained by the standards of the time which helps the film to play well with modern audiences. J. Warren Kerrigan and Lois Wilson are OK as the lovers but the film belongs to character actors Alan Hale Sr.(the father of GILLIGAN'S ISLAND's Skipper), Tully Marshall, and Ernest Torrence. Watching the film is like having history come to life before your eyes. The print used for the DVD is of high quality with a colorful score by Gaylord Carter, one of the last great practitioners of silent film organ playing. Many thanks to Paramount for making this landmark epic along with several other silents available for home viewing and at a reasonable price too...For more reviews visit The Capsule Critic.