Unaccustomed As We Are

Early on while watching Laurel & Hardy's "Unaccustomed As We Are" I figured out that the plot was going to be similar to their later "Block-Heads", with Ollie bringing Stan home, only to have his wife get angry at his expectations of her (the later movie expanded the plot). This 1929 short has the guys doing their usual stuff, and in some scenes I could predict what was about to happen. Predictable though some of it may be, the whole thing is a fun romp. It's not their best, but I recommend it.

Noticeably absent is James Finlayson, whose annoyed grunt inspired Homer Simpson's catchphrase.

From the first seconds of this film's opening credits you know something's a little "off." Leo the Lion roars his roar in silence, backed not by the beloved Koo-Koo theme but by unfamiliar, generic theme music which cuts off sharply when the dialog begins, and from then on it's talk, talk, talk. While Laurel & Hardy buffs will tune in to Unaccustomed As We Are well aware that it was the team's first talking film, willing to cut the boys some slack, casual viewers looking for a chuckle or two should be warned that this is a movie with all the faults of the earliest talkies, i.e. slow pacing and somewhat uneasy performances. All things considered, the guys adapted pretty well to the new technology, but at times this film looks like a nervous dress rehearsal.

The marital squabbling between Ollie and Mae Busch, later developed into a fine art, feels a little forced here, and occasionally suggests an improv exercise in an acting class. And while it's always a pleasure to see Thelma Todd and Edgar Kennedy in support, it's apparent that they're just as uncomfortable the new technology as our two stars. Generally speaking Stan comes off better than Ollie because so much of his material is visual, allowing for his hilariously over-scaled reactions. It could be mentioned too that Stan had more extensive stage experience than most of his colleagues, and was therefore more comfortable delivering dialog.

Still and all, Unaccustomed As We Are is a decent maiden effort in the new medium, and there are some interesting attempts to experiment with sound, as when Ollie puts on a jazz record during one of Mae's tirades and causes her to unintentionally rant in time to the music. It's kind of odd, but amusing. Other bits involving off-stage explosions, fights, and crash-bang sound effects must have made more of an impression when the film premiered, when their impact was still so new. But the major problem here is uncertainty about what sort of material will work in talkies and what won't. For instance, there are moments when the guys strike deliberately theatrical poses and deliver their lines in the style of ham actors, as when Ollie threatens to leave for South America "to do Big Things!" Cute, but this sort of shtick played a lot better in the silent days, and they would soon leave it behind. Dedicated Laurel & Hardy buffs will surely want to see their first talkie, but even the fans need to make allowances for (understandable) awkwardness and remember that soon after this debut, after a little more practice, the guys were producing talkies as strong as their late silent output.

A couple of technical notes: a silent version of Unaccustomed As We Are was also released in 1929 for theaters not yet wired for sound, and for many years it was the only version available, but it's deadly to watch and should be avoided. The major element of interest here, after all, is to observe how the gang at the Roach Studio handled the new technology, and without that you've got nothing. The soundtrack was not re-discovered until the 1970s, and, in the version of this film currently available on DVD, Reel Two is in pretty rough shape. During the latter scenes you can detect a strange, metallic echo under the dialog, which at times sounds almost like the chirping of birds. That's the closest you'll get to hearing the Koo-Koo Song in this one!

P.S. I'm pleased to add that there's a newly restored version of this film now available, and the sound quality in the second reel is much improved.

Laurel and Hardy are enjoying a game of pool, when Mr Hardy tells Laurel all about his wife's cooking and decides to invite him round to get some food. However the expectation of food is too much for Mrs Hardy and she refuses leaving the duo to cook for themselves. After a bad start a neighbour offers a little help which only leads to more trouble.

The title refers to the phrase used by after dinner speakers `unaccustomed as I am to public speaking etc' and is used as, in terms of their shorts, the duo were unaccustomed to it as this was their first `talky'. As such the sound quality is pretty poor and at some points the dialogue doesn't flow very well because it sounds like it is being said very deliberately so as to be clearly heard. This slows the action down which is a bad thing because the comedy isn't as to the fore as usual.

There are still some funny scenes but it didn't totally work for me. Hardy didn't do as well as he usually does, although Laurel was as good as I'm used to him being. The support cast are amusing and do better with the dialogue than Hardy (not sure why) but it is more Laurel's film than before.

Overall this is a good short in that it has several good scenes that are funny, but, because they are just starting out with sound on film here, they are not as good as they quickly become.

It would take a couple of talkie films before Stan and Ollie adapted to the new medium of sound but they soon did. Released in 1929, "Unaccustomed As We Are" is about Ollie inviting Stan to an evening meal with he and Mrs. Hardy - and that soon finishes in anarchy! Mae Busch is once again cast as Mrs. Hardy and does very well. Edgar Kennedy is cast again as a Police officer who lives across the hall from Ollie and his wife. Thelma Todd plays the wife of Officer Kennedy and she shows how feisty she can be! The comedy is a bit awkward at times but that isn't the fault of Laurel and Hardy, it was only a temporary problem. There are some funny scenes, such as when the boys play a gramophone record to drown out Mrs. Hardy's constant nagging!

The comedic team of Stanley Laurel and Oliver Hardy serves as a prime example of the success a handful of comedians from the silent era had when they were first heard on the cinematic screen. More common were those comedians such as Charlie Chaplin who hesitated in bringing their voices into their movies. But Laurel and Hardy didn't think twice when Hollywood studios made the conversion to sound. The pair appeared in their first all-talkie, May 1929's "Unaccustomed As We Are." Suddenly, the viewers could hear Laurel whimpering in his trademark sobbing when he was confronted by the husband (Edgar Kennedy) seeing him with his undressed wife. Hardy could be heard explaining to his wife (Mae Busch) why he's leaving her.

"Unaccustomed As We Are" was one of the first films to be shot on the new sound stage producer and studio owner Hal Roach built in the spring of 1929. The movie's title is drawn from the then popular phrase "Unaccustomed as we are to public speaking," which, despite the pair's previous stage experience, was still a somewhat jarring experience for all the actors on the set miked up for the first time. Laurel especially was wary about being amplified by the sound system because he was known to have a slight lisp and felt the technology would exaggerate his speech defect. It turned out no one picked up the lisp.

Directors Lewis Foster and Hal Roach used the new audio devices to great effect in "Unaccustomed As We Are.." When Edgar Kennedy is bragging about his female escapades to Laurel and Hardy, his wife is hiding in a traveling trunk so she wouldn't be discovered having the two men in her apartment. She later emerges enraged at his philandering and throws everything she can get her hands on at him. As the comedic pair retreat to their apartment across the hall, the noise heard off-camera emphasizes the violence taking place, an audio technique which will be used in many future comedies. Similarly, when Laurel falls down several flights of stairs, viewers don't actually see him tumbling, but they hear his body hitting the hard stairs. Such sound effects were impossible to replicate in silent films.

Throughout their movie careers, Laurel and Hardy were known for their catchphrases. "Unaccustomed As We Are" was the first time Hardy says "Why don't you do something to help me." The movie had to be shot during the evenings since Hal Roach had money to outfit only one studio set for audio. The 'Our Gang' film "Small Talk" was using the same set during mornings and afternoons because the childhood actors were restricted to only day shoots.