With the Marines at Tarawa

The Battle of Tarawa in the late autumn of 1943, the first contested amphibious landing in the Pacific during World War Two, was a bloody affair costing nearly 1,000 United States Marine Corps' lives. The film footage captured by fifteen Marine cameramen was released as an 18-minute documentary, March 1944 "With the Marines at Tarawa," the Academy Awards Best Documentary Short Subject winner.

There was a massive debate whether to release the film showing dead Marines and mutilated Japanese defenders to the general public. Only President Franklin D. Roosevelt could decide on having the general public see the complete color documentary. After watching the film, the president consulted with Time-Life photographer Robert Sherrod, a trusted friend, to give him an honest assessment on the value of public dissemination. "I tell the President the truth," Sherrod related later. "Our soldiers on the front want people back home to know that they don't knock the hell out of them every day of every battle. They want people to understand that war is a horrible, nasty business, and to say otherwise is to do a disservice to those who died." Released into nationwide theaters in early March 1944, "With the Marines at Tarawa" was a rousing success, raising a huge amount of war bonds. On the downside was the Marine Corps witnessed a drop in its recruitment, so terrifying were the images on the screen. Actor Louis Haywood, who had played the dual role in 1939's "The Man in the Iron Mask," and husband to actress Ida Lupino, enlisted in the Marine Corps. He was assigned head of the photographic unit overseeing the Corps' camera crew, where two of them were killed on the shores of Tarawa. Shooting over 5,000 feet of footage, the surviving cameramen handed the film canisters over to Haywood. The actor oversaw the editing, reliving daily the horrors he had witnessed on the island. People close to him said he was never the same after this experience. Awarded the Bronze Star, Haywood's marriage with Lupino ended in divorce soon after he was honorably discharged.

"War is Hell," writes reviewer Joe Bendel. "That is pretty much the essence of 'Tarawa's' message. Rather than focusing on individual servicemen, 'Tarawa' stresses the unity of the Corps and the costly price they paid for the sake of ultimate victory." The Pentagon studied much of the footage the cameramen took on a battle which took the lives of 6,400 American, Japanese and Koreans, battling on the small 291-acre heavily fortified island. As the first contested landing in the face of an entrenched enemy, the Marines had sent underwater demolition and reconnaissance teams well ahead of the main landing force for the first time in WW2. Their destruction and intelligence work was so valuable the U. S. Navy quickly formed what we now know today as the Navy Seals.

This short documentary broke ground in the film world, being aired to a public largely unaware of the atrocities of war. President Roosevelt himself had to approve the wide release of this film to public theaters because of the gory imagery onscreen. This documentary covers all major events of the Battle of Tarawa and the US teams that supported the Marines as the major invasion force. As some of the only surviving footage from this battle in full color, this documentary will forever maintain its importance. Some pictures seen here are unforgettable. They show the price paid by many during this bloodiest war.

It's a documentary, mostly in color, made about the landing of US Marines on Tarawa, basically the first time an amphibious operation was launched against organized resistance in the war.

And it's well done for what it is, a short film designed to boost morale at home. A lot of splendid and brave combat photographers accompanied the Marines in their slog across the small, low-lying sandy atoll. Some of the footage is startling -- half a dozen enemy soldiers running the gauntlet some 50 yards away while Marine riflemen try to bring them down, with both the Japanese and Americans in the same frame.

They wouldn't make it this way today. The Japanese are "Japs." And their resistance is "fanatic." Instead of the monumental foul up of landing craft stuck on the reef -- a mistake due to inaccurate charts -- and the infantry having to wade across hundred of yards in the lagoon, sometimes drowning but always under enemy fire, we hear simply that "the Marines had to wade ashore." The enemy had been preparing for weeks for the invasion and were well dug in. The naval bombardment wasn't long enough and there were difficulties in communicating from shore to ship. A low atoll is a difficult target. And, like Porter Alexander's bombardment of Cemetery Ridge at Gettysburg, many shells overshot the little island or bounced off it to explode in the sea on its far side. None of this is brought up.

If it were being made today, surely the heroics of the actor, Eddie Albert, would be mentioned. He commanded a salvage boat carrying gasoline that rescued many wounded and stranded infantrymen while under heavy small arms fire.

The errors and bad luck that plagued the operation aren't described for what I would presume to be a simple reason. Why give away the lessons you've learned to the enemy? It was a hellish battle, which only a handful of Japanese soldiers and Korean laborers survived. And this film provides a good overall sketch of the assault with a surprising amount of up-front combat footage.

Director Louis Hayward delivers an important Oscar-winning documentary short about the Battle of Tarawa in the South Pacific. America suffered almost 1700 dead which shocked the country. The movie has colored war footage filmed by combat reporters right in the thick of the fight. It proved to be too graphic to exhibit until President Roosevelt approved it himself. It brings war documentary to a new level of realism. As propaganda, this is a very risky move by Roosevelt. The bloody fight could have sapped the resolve of the American people. Instead, the people rose to the occasion and come to understand the difficult fight yet to come.

With the Marines at Tarawa (1944)

*** (out of 4)

Richard Brooks and Louis Hayward co-directed this WWII short that shows us the battle at Tarawa where less than a thousand American soldiers were killed battling the Japanese. If you watch these old WWII films you'll be struck by how brutally honest they are. These films were made to show people back in the States what was going on in the war and a lot of times these shorts were made to build up support for our troops. There were some films that were deemed too controversial to release including some by the great John Huston. This one here certainly isn't a masterpiece but at the same time it's pretty remarkable that you get to see so much of the battle footage and of course the harsh realities of the aftermath. The film was shot in color, which also helped bring the realism to life. This here certainly won't appeal to everyone but history buffs should be entertained by the footage.