The biggest drawback of putting The Three Stooges in a sitcom, as I can see, is the use of a laugh track. I always found their comedy the funniest when we, in the audience, were the only ones laughing-to hear laughing at their antics on the film itself is detrimental to the humor, in my opinion. So would a Stooges sitcom have worked, or was it just a poor idea in the first place?
The second biggest drawback in this pilot is the direction. Comedy films require more than just gags and funny jokes, they require timing and proper direction and pacing. This film has great gags and jokes, some of the best the team ever did-but it suffers because the direction is bad. At times (especially during the painting-and-papering scenes, which should ZING but don't), it almost seems like the camera is focused on the wrong Stooge. It even sometimes appears hard to follow, though this could also be due to the poor quality print I watched, to be totally fair.
Though the laugh track distances us from the "pure" humor of The Three Stooges, a Stooge series might still have been fun in its own right, and indeed, this pilot *is* sometimes fun, especially in the first act. There seem to be more gags and jokes per minute in this film than in their standard Columbia Pictures shorts, and this is both a good thing and a bad thing. Good, because even with poor quality direction the Stooges on a bad day are better than no Stooges at all. Bad, because it throws off the all-important pacing.
You'll note that despite this seemingly negative review, I did give this film six stars out of ten, which may seem incongruous. This is because The Three Stooges are among my favorite comedians of all time, and even at their worst they're still better than most "comics" today, though this particular film strikes me as a miscalculation and a missed opportunity. This pilot is probably best left for serious Stooge buffs alone, certainly not for people discovering them for the first time.
