I Want a Dog for Christmas, Charlie Brown

While "I Want a Dog for Christmas" has it's flaws and may not totally live up to the old "A Charlie Brown Christmas", it nonetheless manages to hold a special place in my heart and has remained a staple for my family's Christmas viewing for three years running.

I can remember being in the philosophical Rerun's position, both for wanting a dog -- for years and years until I was able to get one when I was in my teens, and also for and also for being treated as the "baby" in the family. Seeing other members of Snoopy's family was a treat.

I felt the script could have been a little tighter, but I think it is far from being dreadful.

I've been a fan of Peanuts for as long as I can remember. Every year our family has a tradition of watching the holiday specials together. Sure, we all know what happens, but Peanuts still has the ability to get you in the mood for the season.

At least until this special came along.

Rerun always had a segment on the TV show, riding on his mom's bicycle and giving his philosphies on things. For a two minute segment, it was cute. But this new special is all Rerun, all the time. There was a reason Rerun was confined to a two minute space. Any longer and he's grating.

The special (or at least the first half hour) consists of Rerun basically complaining about being the baby of the family. Nobody includes him in anything. Mom won't let him have a dog. He's not big enough to do what he wants to do, etc.

And then he gets suspended for sexual harassment! I kid you not. He tells some girl he wants to take her to Paris and he gets suspended for sexual harassment! At that point, I switched the channel. This isn't Peanuts. It's a cheap piece of trash trying to cash in on the Peanuts empire. Charles Schulz would be spinning in his grave.

This gets zero stars from me.

It's hard to believe that this film is from 2003! It has the look and overall feel of the originals from the 60s and 70s - a really good Christmas cartoon movie. If you do like the originals then you should like this 2003 because it's just as good.

In this one, Lucy and Linus' little brother Rerun wants a dog for Christmas but his parents will not allow him to have one because it's a lot of work caring for a dog. Rerun starts bugging Charlie Brown to play with Snoopy and eventually Snoopy's brother Spike comes to stay with Rerun and his family for awhile.

Really cute, fun movie for the entire family.

10/10

Out of the four "Peanuts" Christmas specials, this is probably the best since the first. Like the other two, it's mainly a collection of strips taken straight from the comic and animated. This time, though, they've actually taken strips they can form a cohesive story out of. The focus this time is Rerun, younger brother of Linus and Lucy, and his desire to get a dog for Christmas. Rerun is a sweet character (sometimes almost too sweet), but he's genuine in his affection.

Some viewers complain about the segment where Rerun makes a joke about taking a girl to Paris and winds up getting accused of harassment. (The word "sexual" is never used.) Other reviewers actually said this would cause Charles Schulz to spin in his grave -- since Schulz himself wrote the strips that this segment is based on, I highly doubt that.

Nothing will ever approach the greatness of the original "Charlie Brown Christmas," but out of the ones that have come out since then, this is the cream of the crop.

'I Want a Dog for Christmas, Charlie Brown' is simply put, a very sweet film. Its honestly just one of the sweetest Peanuts specials released.

Starring the Van Pelt kids (Lucy, Linus, and Rerun) and Snoopy this special is really all about Rerun and his pursuit of getting a dog for Christmas. This ends up involving Snoopy so you get to see the usual luster Snoopy brings to all scenes!

From Rerun's dialogue to Snoopy and his siblings who all make some cameos, this special produces some peak adorableness of the Peanuts gang. Although the music is just average, the animation feels authentic and entertaining.

Its a good Peanuts special and worth watching as a change up to the original 1965 Christmas special.