Jessica's friend, police Lt. O'Malley, and his rookie niece solve the case of a businessman's wife's apparent suicide.Jessica's friend, police Lt. O'Malley, and his rookie niece solve the case of a businessman's wife's apparent suicide.Jessica's friend, police Lt. O'Malley, and his rookie niece solve the case of a businessman's wife's apparent suicide.
Valerie Red-Horse
- Female Reporter
- (as Valerie Redding)
Featured reviews
Jessica receives a letter from an old friend, Lieutenant James O'Malley, and tells the story of his most recent case, and why he almost ended up losing his job.
It's a very nicely written episode, it's certainly different, most of the time, the show operates as a traditional whodunnit, that isn't the case here, as we see exactly what happens, it's more a howtoproveit than a whodunnit. It could be very good, apart from one thing ......
...Why on Earth did they have to make Pat Hingle's character, Lietenant O'Malley Irish? A fine actor who appeared in one or two other episodes, and was excellent, but his diabolical Irish accent detracts from the episode, it is so very difficult to take his character seriously. The Irish music throughout made me cringe.
Stacy Edwards who plays O'Malley's Niece Rawley, on the other hand is excellent I thought, a wonderfully talented actress, so pretty. Best of all, is how her character stands up to the barrage of misogyny she faces, in spite of being told to remain silent.
I enjoyed it, but that accent was unforgivable, and I would say again, if Lansbury wanted a break, they should have just made the series shorter.
One of those episodes that on a good day, such as today I'll give it a 6, on a bad day, this would be a 4.
It's a very nicely written episode, it's certainly different, most of the time, the show operates as a traditional whodunnit, that isn't the case here, as we see exactly what happens, it's more a howtoproveit than a whodunnit. It could be very good, apart from one thing ......
...Why on Earth did they have to make Pat Hingle's character, Lietenant O'Malley Irish? A fine actor who appeared in one or two other episodes, and was excellent, but his diabolical Irish accent detracts from the episode, it is so very difficult to take his character seriously. The Irish music throughout made me cringe.
Stacy Edwards who plays O'Malley's Niece Rawley, on the other hand is excellent I thought, a wonderfully talented actress, so pretty. Best of all, is how her character stands up to the barrage of misogyny she faces, in spite of being told to remain silent.
I enjoyed it, but that accent was unforgivable, and I would say again, if Lansbury wanted a break, they should have just made the series shorter.
One of those episodes that on a good day, such as today I'll give it a 6, on a bad day, this would be a 4.
I am currently watching the episodes in order from Season One on. This season six episode almost made me ill, it is that bad. Pat Hingle comes off as seriously annoying. There have been overacting actors before in this series. Pat Hingle is not the worst but he does seem to be trying to do too much. The rest of the cast brings on, in the words of Ringo Starr, "Instant Amnesia." Do yourself a favor, skip this episode. I have not done the research into why they started doing Murder, She Wrote episodes without starring Angela Lansbury as part of the plot but this one has been the bottom of the barrel. So far. Ojala no hay mas episodos asi. The English translation of that last sentence is: I hope there are not any more episodes like this one.
A big JB Fletcher fan.
A big JB Fletcher fan.
Currently blowing through the complete MSW. While Angela is always missed in the non-Jessica episodes, they're usually still enjoyable. Not O'Malleys Luck. The combination of Pat Hingle's cloying accent and skeezy manner had me rooting for the murderer. Just terrible.
I feel deeply sorry for the illness of the "big JB Fletcher fan".
I felt that Pat Hingle in "O'Malley's luck" was the best independent performance in all the episodes that did not involve Angela Lansbury. He was truly like one or two people I have met in real life.
💖
Jessica's friend, police Lt. O'Malley, and his rookie niece solve the case of a businessman's wife's apparent suicide. An average episode which benefits from good characterisation and humour. The way O'Malley and his niece pins the killer to the crime is good.
Did you know
- TriviaOne of numerous Season 6 episodes in which Jessica Fletcher appears only briefly as the narrator. This was done to give an overworked Angela Lansbury a break.
- Quotes
[first lines]
Jessica Fletcher: [opens letter] Oh.
[reading]
Jessica Fletcher: "May your neighbors respect you, trouble neglect you, the angels protect you, and heaven accept you. As if there were any doubt. Happy birthday, love O'Malley."
- SoundtracksMurder She Wrote Theme
Written by John Addison
Details
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content