Pip

Matt & Trey stated that this is their least favorite episode and they regret making it. Personally I think it's slightly underrated, no it's not a masterpiece but it does have it's moments. I'm quite familiar with the story it's based on and I have actually read the book. Which may be the reason why I appreciate this episode more than regular viewers.

No it's not an accurate representation of the book.. Robot monkeys and 17 year old American guys with cars in 19th century England, I mean c'mon lol. It's not supposed to be accurate, it's a parody and a fine one at that. Far from the best South Park has to offer but not as bad as they say.

I see a lot of hate for this one and to be honest, I don't know why. Sure, Pip is a completely stupid and random character to make an episode on, but at the same time, it had enough laughs to where I enjoyed it somewhat. It has an extremely boring start but it eventually picks up in the climax and has some pretty corny or just not funny moments. The characters in this one(with the exception of Pip) are very random and definitely were meant to be based off characters from "Great Expectations". While there is 300+ episodes in this show, "Pip" is certainly not the worst but also fails to maintain the South Park quality we like to see.

The first 10 minutes were definitely a head scratcher, the main characters are entirely absent, but the episode really grew on me. Malcolm McDowell is hilarious, and the "alternate" ending to the Charles Dickens masterpiece is hilarious.

I got the feeling that Trey and Matt were having a lot of fun with the episode, so I did as well. It's definitely not for everyone though.

This must be easily one of the worst episodes. The plot goes nowhere and nothing happens. Luke a lukewarm bowl of water with some lumps in it and those lumps don't taste like anything either.

It felt like this episode lasted for 45 minutes - and not in a good way.

This episode does not deserve some of the hate that it is receiving. I personally find this episode to be extremely underrated and funny. I think a lot of people dislike this episode because it breaks away from the main 4 boys, but I loved seeing Pip star in his own episode, which he definitely deserved. This episode still made me laugh when I rewatched it a couple days ago. I will admit, the story gets a little weird at the end, but that's what's expected. It's a South Park episode after all. This episode was one of Pip's last major roles in the series, which was sad, but I'm glad he at least got a solo episode. In conclusion, I would highly recommend this episode to anyone who has yet to watch it.