In the Flesh

Wouldve liked to see a better episode of this. They wae cool at first and then we get a cliche of Starfleet species 8472. I do like the actor Ray Watson tho so this made it better. Byt I wish it was different.

This is what Star Trek *used* to be about. Peace, understanding, communication. That's what made Star Trek the phenomenon it is. Not the fancy special effects, not the warring, fighting, etc. It's exploration, and celebrating the differences. Not reacting in fear. Extending the hand of friendship BEFORE fighting.

Today's "Star Trek" just doesn't do this, it's more about the fancy special effects, the conflict, the fighting. Somewhere today's "Star Trek" has these lessons, but they are so far in the background, there's no point.

Seven of Nine represents today's mentality, shoot first, forget communication and understanding, just kill 'em all. I'm glad the writers had her admit she was wrong.

This is an interesting episode in that it never has its principles come to blows. It is more about posturing and trying to prevent a horrible consequence. Janeway and the Voyager crew move in on a San Francisco recreation of Species 8472. They are interested in the plans of this group, the one they attacked several episodes previously. Ray Walston appears as the leader of this species. The whole thing just is to pat and easy and hence my criticism.

Can't we continue this romance ark between Chakotay and the Species 8472 lady ? Seriously. For all we know, Chakotay should get arrested after arriving in the Alpha Quadrant at the end of the entire show. A prison cell was waiting for him all along. Species 8472 can jump through dimensions - inside prison cells. Plus, Chakotay is the kind of guy who could have a lasting romance with a slightly-fascist lady. Forget The Next Generation's "Imzadi" Romance between Troi and Riker. I want Chakotay oo Species 8472. In this episode, the two meet when that lady practices infiltrating the Federation. Chakotay is Maquis, not Federation. There is no telling how much Chakotay could be taught about infiltrating hostile species at home. --- Speaking of which. What would a Romulan Espionage Camp look like ? At the centre of Romulan space where Starfleet can't see them ..? Join my Star Trek Fan Project on Google Play Books. Codename: Greenspace.

After so many action-packed arcs, it's nice to see diplomacy, communication, and efforts to prevent violence from escalating, with careful planning aimed at reaching an agreement and always pursuing peace. Above all, Janeway proves herself to be a truly principled Federation Starfleet captain. A great episode.

And don't get me wrong, I enjoy action stories - but sometimes I also like seeing what Gene Roddenberry aimed for: an optimistic story about the future that leaves you with a smile at the end of the episode.

This, together with "Extreme Risk" are underated episodes in my opinion, it deserve more love.