Zoe is selected as a companion for the Krotons and the Doctor insists on joining her.Zoe is selected as a companion for the Krotons and the Doctor insists on joining her.Zoe is selected as a companion for the Krotons and the Doctor insists on joining her.
Featured reviews
Zoe unwittingly shows off her Intelligence,and is subsequently chosen as the next companion to The Krotons.
It's quite a dark story, I hadn't realised it, but the overall tone is quite bleak, and the story itself has particularly sinister tones. The Gonds seem to cope well with loss and death, a race that are clearly so used to it, hard to imagine they would have any fight at all in them.
I quite like the sets, the doors and various pieces of equipment look pretty good, I particularly love the two chairs Jamie and Zoe are offered, I'd have them in my home! On the downside The Krotons themselves are pretty ridiculous looking, they're so big and cumbersome, great accents though. I am a big fan of the music.
There are some nice touches of humour, The Doctor's rant at Zoe, and his subsequent messing up of the test.
Up until now, it's been pretty good. 7/10
It's quite a dark story, I hadn't realised it, but the overall tone is quite bleak, and the story itself has particularly sinister tones. The Gonds seem to cope well with loss and death, a race that are clearly so used to it, hard to imagine they would have any fight at all in them.
I quite like the sets, the doors and various pieces of equipment look pretty good, I particularly love the two chairs Jamie and Zoe are offered, I'd have them in my home! On the downside The Krotons themselves are pretty ridiculous looking, they're so big and cumbersome, great accents though. I am a big fan of the music.
There are some nice touches of humour, The Doctor's rant at Zoe, and his subsequent messing up of the test.
Up until now, it's been pretty good. 7/10
Review of all 4 episodes:
The first episode is, in my opinion, a lot better than this story's reputation would lead you to expect. It comes across as an intelligently scripted, interesting political allegory. The story features the humanoid Gonds being exploited by a strange alien race known as the Krotons. This is the first script from future Doctor Who writing legend Robert Holmes and his talent is already starting to show in episode 1. However his talent is less visible in episodes 2-4. Another great talent and Doctor Who legend involved is Philip Madoc as Eelek. His great acting skills are not fully utilised but, of course, he portrays his part perfectly.
After the very solid start the following three episodes turn into just a slightly bland, not massively interesting 'filler' between more meaty stories in the season. It also suffers from technical limitations of the age and budget. The Krotons themselves look and sound very unimpressive.
The final verdict has to be this is decently scripted and acted but unremarkable. It is a disappointment, taken as a whole, after a promising 1st part.
My Ratings: Episode 1 - 8/10, Episode 2 to 4 - 6/10
Overall: 6.5/10
The first episode is, in my opinion, a lot better than this story's reputation would lead you to expect. It comes across as an intelligently scripted, interesting political allegory. The story features the humanoid Gonds being exploited by a strange alien race known as the Krotons. This is the first script from future Doctor Who writing legend Robert Holmes and his talent is already starting to show in episode 1. However his talent is less visible in episodes 2-4. Another great talent and Doctor Who legend involved is Philip Madoc as Eelek. His great acting skills are not fully utilised but, of course, he portrays his part perfectly.
After the very solid start the following three episodes turn into just a slightly bland, not massively interesting 'filler' between more meaty stories in the season. It also suffers from technical limitations of the age and budget. The Krotons themselves look and sound very unimpressive.
The final verdict has to be this is decently scripted and acted but unremarkable. It is a disappointment, taken as a whole, after a promising 1st part.
My Ratings: Episode 1 - 8/10, Episode 2 to 4 - 6/10
Overall: 6.5/10
Did you know
- TriviaThis episode was watched by 8.4 million viewers on its original transmission.
- GoofsShortly after the Doctor hands Jamie some pills to give to Vana, the camera lurches violently after colliding with the set.
- ConnectionsFeatured in The Lively Arts: Whose Dr. Who (1977)
Details
- Runtime
- 23m
- Color
- Sound mix
- Aspect ratio
- 1.33 : 1
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content