Return to Halloweentown

This is the worst movie in the series. The new version of Marnie is too mature and ready for college when she really shouldn't be. Lucas Grabeel is still awesome but not enough. The plot is overly complex and contains no real threatening villain, just people who want power. It is sad that pretty much every character that isn't Marnie gets development in some form. I wish it was as fun as the first two but it just kinda fell flat as a forgettable movie. Disappointing is the best word for it.

Just no, the decision to replace marnie and give Aggie a very limited role was just a bad movie. This doesn't have the feel of Halloweentown, I reject this as a sequel.

Hate it when they change the main character to a new person. I wonder why they even did it.

My biggest disappointment is that they replaced Kimberly J. Brown with Sara Paxton. Apparently, she was available and able to continue, yet they replace her with a blonde actress? If they're going to make changes, they need to make sure the changes make sense and have reason

Not having Kimberly Brown was really disappointing. I like the other girl in other things she'd done but Kimberly was Marnie for 3 films and really made the character