Melbourne

My rating is for this episode and episode 8.

Okay, despite all the good bits that I will like to say about the miniseries "The Pacific", I just couldn't stand two episode in this show, which are E03 & E08. Why the heck did either the screenplay writer or the director as well as the producers find it interesting to put so many sex scenes in a movie that was suppose to present a bloody HELL in the war? And why should the personal "romance" of John Basilone take almost an entire episode?? Why did the producers think the audiences who are paying their respect to that part of history and to those who sacrificed tremendously should care about some marines' love story? Honestly, I don't get it! I think it is ridiculous that almost 90 out of 540 minutes in this series contributed to that kind of stuff. E01 and E10 are not very good as well. They could have dug much deeper rather than showing, yes again, some "romance"!

But there are very good stuff in this series, things that are subtle yet touching. After watching Band of Brothers, I was touched deeply by the fraternity in a war. I had my admiration for some of the main characters in BOB. After watching this series, all I want to say is that there is no glory in this war or any war, and the only difference between wars is which one is more ugly and more devastating.

At the diner scene with Greek family, Leckie states that he read a lot and knows about "the sacking of Smryna by the Turks". Later on, Greek lady confirms and continues "Turks invaded there in 1922 an burnt it down".

First of all, Izmir (it was no longer called as Smryna after conquered by Turks) was a Turkish soil for over 600 years before it was "invaded" by the Greek army in 1919. Since Turks take back what was theirs, it can't be considered an "invasion". For this reason, there is no logical reason for Turks to sack and set their own city on fire. On the contrary Greeks had many reasons to burn the city of Izmir: Stalling the rapid march of Turkish army to the coast, buying time for evacuation and taking a last revenge against the triumphant Turks before leaving.

Even the given the facts appoint the Greek army, the issue whether the responsibility of burning of Izmir belongs to Greeks or Turks is still disputed. One sided narrative of a such disputed matter in the series as a historical fact is very inaccurate.

Secondly, an average Greek family doesn't allow a complete stranger man into their home, especially where a young and single daughter lives within.

Episode 3 of The Pacific, titled "Melbourne," shifts focus from the battlefield to the emotional and psychological toll of war on the soldiers. After the intensity of Guadalcanal, the Marines arrive in Melbourne for a brief respite. The episode centers around Robert Leckie (James Badge Dale) as he struggles to reconcile the horrors of war with the normalcy of civilian life. He begins a romantic relationship with a local woman, Stella (Claire van der Boom), which provides a temporary escape but also highlights his internal turmoil. The episode explores the disconnection the soldiers feel as they try to reintegrate into society, knowing they'll soon return to the front lines.

The performances in this episode stand out, particularly Dale's portrayal of Leckie. He captures the quiet intensity and confusion of a soldier trying to find his place in a world that now feels foreign to him. The chemistry between Leckie and Stella is heartfelt but bittersweet, as their relationship is tinged with the knowledge that it cannot last. Claire van der Boom brings a delicate vulnerability to her role, providing a nuanced portrayal of a woman caught between love and the reality of war. The episode's quieter moments, such as their time together at her family's home, are deeply emotional and contrast sharply with the violence of the previous episodes.

Jeremy Podeswa's direction is restrained, focusing more on character interactions than action. The pacing of the episode slows down considerably compared to the frenetic energy of "Basilone," allowing the audience to explore the soldiers' emotional state. This shift is both a strength and a weakness, as it offers valuable character development but may feel like a lull in the broader narrative arc of the war. Still, Podeswa effectively captures the disorientation and longing for normalcy that the soldiers experience. The use of natural lighting and softer tones in the cinematography emphasizes the temporary peace Melbourne offers, making the impending return to war all the more poignant.

The episode's thematic depth is commendable, tackling issues such as PTSD, alienation, and the fleeting nature of happiness in wartime. The stark contrast between the soldiers' camaraderie and their isolation in civilian settings underscores the internal conflict they face. The romantic subplot, while not central to the overall war narrative, serves as a metaphor for the impermanence of life during wartime, with Leckie's relationship symbolizing the fragility of any sense of normalcy.

However, "Melbourne" may be criticized for its slower pace and limited action, which might not satisfy viewers looking for more battlefield drama. The episode is a necessary emotional breather in the series but could have benefited from deeper exploration of other characters' experiences in Melbourne, as it heavily focuses on Leckie. That said, it sets up the emotional stakes for future episodes, giving the audience a deeper connection to the characters as they prepare to face the next phase of the Pacific campaign.

In conclusion, "Melbourne" is a quiet but impactful episode that shifts the narrative focus to the emotional scars of war. The strong performances, particularly from James Badge Dale and Claire van der Boom, add depth to the characters, while the direction and cinematography create a serene yet melancholic atmosphere. Though the pacing may feel slow, the episode effectively explores the personal struggles of the soldiers, making it a crucial part of the broader story in The Pacific.

Extremely fun episode that creates great bonds between the characters. Out of any of the episodes this one is just a joy to watch. The character's experience in Melbourne as so enjoyable, especially after being shown Guadalcanal. It expresses how they interact with each other, the personalities of each character and adds great development to each of them. The only reason I didn't give it a 10/10 is because I feel like this sort of episode should've happened earlier. Band of Brothers made you love the characters from the beginning letting you pick and choose who you wanted to follow. The Pacific decides to send you straight into the action and develop only a few characters and their stories. Melbourne can outclass a lot of the Band of Brothers episodes but because this fun type of episode happened 3 episodes in it isn't as impactful as Currahee was in BOB.

So much happened in this episode that I just didn't believe or care about. Drunken idiot American soldiers convince native girls to relate to them. How easy were Australian girls in the 40s? I quit watching this episode halfway through while fast forwarding through most of the first half and I don't feel I'm going to miss anything important about the characters or story. What a useless waste time this episode was. I usually would never rate anything a 1 out of 10 but this episode I feel was just not needed in any way. I would have been highly disappointed if I waited a week to watch the next episode and it be this garbage.