Alyson Hannigan credited as playing...
Lily Aldrin
- Ted Mosby: [Ted, Marshall and Lily alert Robin that Scooby, Robin's new boyfriend, is missing from the apartment] Robin! Hey, remember Scooby? Well, he got out.
- Robin Scherbatsky: Got out? What do you mean?
- Ted Mosby: He just walked right out of the apartment. Someone must've left the door open.
- Marshall Eriksen: It wasn't me!
- Lily Aldrin: Me neither.
- [gasps]
- Lily Aldrin: He must have figured out how to open it himself!
- Ted Mosby: He's so smart, we should get him on Letterman doing tricks!
- Marshall Eriksen: I know Paul Schaefer's sandwich guy. This can happen.
- Lily Aldrin: Scooby, we're in our thirties, we don't smoke sandwiches anymore.
- Ted Mosby: Sandwich brownies?
- Lily Aldrin: Okay!
- Nora: First, I wanted to let you know that your friend Barney is being a perfect gentleman.
- Robin Scherbatsky: Well, it's still early.
- Nora: I'm being serious. I had no idea that deep down, he's such a romantic.
- Lily Aldrin: I had no idea he had a deep down.
- Dr. Kirby: [to Barney] Okay. None of this suggests a systemic issue. Your heart's fine. With a healthy diet, you can live a long and happy life. If nobody stabs you.
- Lily Aldrin: Day's not over.