Beyond the Hill

As the debut feature of Emin Alper's dense, dominant, and politically charged cinema, Beyond the Hill is a carefully crafted film that is well-directed for a first effort, even if it bears a few production shortcomings. Sharing thematic parallels with the director's later works (excluding A Tale of Three Sisters), the film portrays how the order of a farmer and his family is disturbed by an unseen "other." The enemy, in truth, does not reside within their home, but is a paranoid specter they imagine waiting "beyond the hill."

The second act feels a little rushed; had the film been given more time to breathe and the finale handled with greater restraint, its cohesion might have been even stronger. The uneasy atmosphere of the steppe and the occasional use of horror elements add a distinctive flavor to the film.

With Beyond the Hill, Alper makes a confident debut that lays the groundwork for both his recurring themes and his cinematic language, a clear sign of the tone his later films would carry.

The film is technically a masterpiece. The long periods of silence succeeding natural sounds incorporate the viewer into the scenery and the atmosphere.

The key to the comprehension of the movie is the closeted parallel of this archaic in manners Turkish family with the modern state. What prevails is suspiciousness against imaginative external enemies as well as hidden guilt between the members of the inner family. The outcome is quite tragicomic and indicative of the obsessions and artificial dead ends which point at the "foreign" as the source of all our woes.

I also underlined the scene where the little girl with all its innocence states that we are also nomads, so "these" nomads won't do us any harm. The mature man replies that "they are bad nomads" and so differ from the morally immaculate family.

I was lucky enough to catch this at this years International Berlin Festival. The director was realistic about the eventual outcome of the movie I suppose, but still the fact he made this movie is something that should be celebrated. It's a really remarkable movie, with standout performances by the cast. And while it does revolve around violence, none is actually really shown.

Which makes the whole thing even more intriguing and more arresting at the same time. Human interactions are the main course, with our instincts, drives and fears being dissected very slowly and for all to see. You can see things coming, but it seems to be impossible to stop them. It's in our nature. While this is a pessimistic view of things (or at least my interpretation of it), this is an amazing movie, that I cannot recommend highly enough!

The film tells usabout the creation of enemies and by the way this is excatly how politicians make enemies. And then people start believing that there is an enemy and they canalize all their hatred to there. Modern societies need that. Just turn on your TV and look at the news all the politicians have someone to hate. and they make people hate them too.

It is an interesting movie that shows very well how Turkish people feel to live in this land. I think this is because of the education system, politicians and media in Turkey. They want us to have fears for "those people beyond the hill". They want us to hate "those people beyond the hill". They want us to kill "those people beyond the hill". Of course this is a generalization but it fits for a lot of people who lives in Turkey.

I don't agree with people who thinks that this movie is slow or boring. (If you want, you can always watch an action movie or something.) It helps you to think what is next, but you never know everything at the moment.