Résistance

When the resistance began. very honest, realistic. youths, women, and communists WERE the heroes--the men were pows, dead, or in england or north africa.

as good a depiction of anything in the war as i've seen for a long time. real venues, uniforms, weapons, vehicles, concerns, motives.

because its a construction, laps into 'train,' 'monuments men,' 'la rafle...'

It seems that most of the events depicted and characters shown were real (although, for odd reasons, some characters were included not with their real names), but the combination of dramatism, personal relationships and flashbacks in not carried out in a smooth manner. The pace which is rather intricate from the beginning, tends to fade out, with the appearance of some events and characters not providing any additional value to the course of events. Some solutions remain unclear, with some explanation in the credits, and the reasons for sabotages are given "in a hurry", with much longer focus on the trials.

The characters/cast are uneven as well, some of them seem static. While the "older generation" provided catchy performances in spite of duration, then, among the youth, only Tom Hudson caught my attention.

Thus, this Series is definitely not bad, but I can´t say it is a must-see to those interested in France in 1940s, including the locals. Me as an outsider had evidently more pleasant things to focus on, as I tend to watch Nordic and UK series.

I watched my dvd of this in 2 sessions and am very glad I did.

I had forgotten how good and how moving it was.

I don't get the hipsters on here not liking this,nobody says France won World War 2 but while there are resistance myths the resistance was not a myth.

I borrowed that from historian Julian Jackson.

In 1940 it looked like France was finished and Germany was going to win the war but some people swam against the tide of opinion.

Thousands of french people were killed by the Germans and their fascist allies between 1940-1944.

This drama was well done because it makes a virtue of its limitations of budget,it uses still standing Paris streets,there are few action scenes.

I can't find much to fault with this series,it is a bit sentimental at times but I can accept that.

I.

Given the excellent reviews this series has received, I must be missing something.

Yes, the production values were good, but the script was terrible.

For the first few episodes I kept wondering whether the writers were deliberately making the resistance workers seem incompetent, but eventually I realized that it was the writers themselves that must have lost contact with reality.

Some of the ignorance was simply a lack of research (e.g. even a casual look on Wikipedia would show that rather than exploding, Molotov cocktails work by spreading burning gasoline when the glass container shatters, but the characters simply rolled the bottle under a truck without even attempting to break it. Similarly, hand grenades have a lever that, when released, automatically opens and starts a timed fuse, but the characters were told to count to three *before* releasing the lever).

By far though, the worst writing was the way the characters would continually tell each other what they and others had done and were going to be doing. It seemed like they were trying really hard to ensure that no matter which one of them got caught, that person would know all the secrets of the whole organization. Can you imagine in real life someone telling you something like "Joe Smith is going to meet Herman Perkins, the secret head of the resistance, tomorrow at noon at Granny's Café so they can discuss the border tunnel they're digging in Smallville"? That conversation wouldn't have been out of place in this program. No underground organization could work like that, at least not for long. If someone doesn't need to know something, they shouldn't.

Good solid drama.

For some reason we don't get a lot of French TV in the UK; so it was great to get this mini series. I'm not too au fait with the French resistance movement during the Second World War (I only knew of the French Maquis because of Star trek DS9!), but have learnt a lot from this show, for example: I was amazed at the ages of the most of the characters in the underground movement; would the youth of today be up for it?

It's not spectacular or particularly dramatic, but instead paints a picture of what I imagine life would have been like then. It pulls on your heart strings towards the end; but the rest is quite straight forward, matter of fact and life-like. That is except for the lead role: she seems natural in front of the camera and is very pretty and all that but plays it a bit smiley and vapid for the character that she is portraying. The rest of the cast is universally solid.

I would recommend it to anyone who wants to learn more about France in the Second World War, it's the sort of thing I imagine that would be useful for educators.