Peter Blomquist credited as playing...
Micah Bell
- Micah Bell: I don't want to kill you, John.
- John Marston: Arthur saved my life, more than once.
- Micah Bell: Arthur's been dead a long time. This is a new century.
- John Marston: Dutch, we all did our best for you. It ain't our fault things turned out the way they did. Dutch, killing me won't solve nothing!
- Micah Bell: Put down your gun, Marston!
- John Marston: Say something, Dutch! Say something!
- Dutch van der Linde: I ain't got too much to say no more.
- [With that, he shoots Micah in the chest]
- Micah Bell: [both surprised and amused] You shot me! Ha ha ha ha ha. You shot me pretty good...
- John Marston: [John empties all of his ammo into Micah's head/torso. He walks around for a bit, then shrugs and collapses, dead] Thank you. I... I...
- [as Dutch walks passed, he glares at John and gives him a look as if to say, "I didn't do it for YOU" and keeps on walking]
- John Marston: [Dutch has just interrupted a standoff between John, Sadie and Micah, pointing his gun at John, which has allowed Micah to hold his gun against Sadie's] What are you doing here, Dutch?
- Dutch van der Linde: Same as you, I suppose.
- Micah Bell: Dutch and I are teaming up once more. We got money... we got dreams. Join us, John. Join us.
- John Marston: Let her go.
- Micah Bell: Now I can't do that, John.
- John Marston: [to Dutch] Dutch... Dutch, come on now.
- Dutch van der Linde: You shot at me, son.
- John Marston: You started it.
- Dutch van der Linde: You betrayed me!
- John Marston: I could say the same as you.
- Dutch van der Linde: I was trying to do my best. You... you just cared for yourself.
- John Marston: I think differently.
- Dutch van der Linde: Micah recons there's a rat.
- Arthur Morgan: Oh, does he? On what evidence?
- Micah Bell: We's only back a minute, Pinkertons show up.
- Arthur Morgan: We been on the run since you two fools went crazy in Blackwater. We barely escaped with our lives in Saint Denis. Now we got a rat?
- Dutch van der Linde: Well, Molly clearly talked, but who else?
- Arthur Morgan: Maybe we pushed things too hard.
- [Micah feigns snoring to be an asshole]
- Arthur Morgan: Maybe time for folks like us has passed. We don't need a rat. We got sloppier than the town drunk, and they know who we are, and where we are, and what we're doing.