The Original Martian Invasion

Episode aired Apr 21, 2017

IMDb RATING

4.9/10

236

YOUR RATING

Comedy Talk Show

Bill introduces the theory of panspermia (which is the hypothesis that life exist throughout the Universe), NASA scientists discuss the Mars 2020 mission, and Wil Wheaton and the panel ponde... Read allBill introduces the theory of panspermia (which is the hypothesis that life exist throughout the Universe), NASA scientists discuss the Mars 2020 mission, and Wil Wheaton and the panel ponder life on other planets.Bill introduces the theory of panspermia (which is the hypothesis that life exist throughout the Universe), NASA scientists discuss the Mars 2020 mission, and Wil Wheaton and the panel ponder life on other planets.

See production info at IMDbPro

IMDb RATING

4.9/10

236

YOUR RATING

See production info at IMDbPro

Photos

User reviews1

4.9236

Featured reviews

6drbits

Oversimplification leads to poor conclusions.

1) The table discussion at the end is not very useful. In particular, Wil Wheaton is not a scientist, he is an actor and science fiction fan.

2) The description of how life might have traveled to Earth ignores the "Aerobic divide." Initial life on Earth would have to be able to thrive without free oxygen. When photosynthesis developed, oxygen would have killed most of the existing organisms. Life continued to evolve from there.

That means panspermia would have required delivery of a mixture of photosynthetic cells and cells that would not be killed by oxygen. This is an advanced collection of single cellular organisms, not the organism mentioned in the episode.

3) The original experiment did not explain much (it was a fake creation of primordial soup). Primordial soup would have allowed reactions to generate a variety of chemicals, but nothing life-like would appear until some sort of envelope (cell membrane) developed to separate the proto-cell from the soup.