"Kitten," the sixth episode of the eleventh season of The X-Files, written by Chris Carter and directed by Carol Banker, presents a character-driven narrative that delves into the complexities of Walter Skinner's past while intertwining elements of horror and conspiracy. This episode, while ambitious in its exploration of Skinner's character, has received mixed reviews for its execution and coherence.
The episode begins with a flashback to Skinner's (Mitch Pileggi) time as a Marine during the Vietnam War, where he and his platoon mate John "Kitten" James (Haley Joel Osment) are involved in a top-secret operation. During a firefight, they accidentally release a mysterious gas that induces hallucinations, leading to tragic consequences. In the present day, Skinner receives a severed human ear in the mail, prompting him to go AWOL as he seeks to confront his past and help Kitten's son, Davey (also played by Osment), who blames Skinner for his father's fate. Mulder (David Duchovny) and Scully (Gillian Anderson) are called in to track down Skinner, leading them to a small town where they uncover layers of deception and manipulation tied to government experiments.
Carol Banker's direction effectively captures the eerie atmosphere of both the Vietnam flashbacks and the contemporary investigation. The cinematography enhances the tension, particularly during scenes set in dark woods and claustrophobic environments. The pacing is generally well-executed, although some critics argue that the plot feels disjointed at times, particularly in how it shifts between past and present.
Mitch Pileggi delivers a compelling performance as Skinner, showcasing vulnerability and strength as he grapples with guilt from his past actions. Haley Joel Osment's portrayal of Davey adds depth to the narrative, embodying both anger and desperation as he confronts his father's legacy. However, some viewers felt that Mulder and Scully were underutilized in this episode; their roles primarily serve to support Skinner's storyline rather than drive the plot forward.
Thematically, "Kitten" explores issues of guilt, memory, and the repercussions of government secrecy. The episode raises questions about accountability for past actions and how those actions resonate through generations. The inclusion of elements like MKUltra and chemical warfare taps into real-world fears surrounding government experimentation and conspiracy theories, making the narrative feel relevant yet unsettling.
"Kitten" is an ambitious attempt to provide depth to Walter Skinner's character while exploring significant themes related to memory and guilt. While it successfully evokes nostalgia for earlier seasons with its blend of horror and conspiracy, it suffers from pacing issues and occasional plot contrivances. Ultimately, this episode serves as a reminder of the complexities within The X-Files, highlighting how personal histories intertwine with broader societal issues. Despite its flaws, "Kitten" contributes meaningfully to the ongoing narrative of The X-Files, reinforcing why audiences remain invested in these characters' journeys.
