I Love You, America

I rate this a '10' because... It touches my heart! That's actually a rare thing for me. As the show ranges about--largely hewing to format, but also throwing in stuff that breaks format--I find myself feeling a warm lovingness; it's a nice thing for a TV show to do, and it happens so seldom.

I understand that Sarah always threatens to spin out of control and drop a ball and lose the audience, but... I feel like I understand where she's coming from: She insists on pushing her cognitive function forward; that's her thing, right? That's the whole point of Sarah; why she hovers on the fringes of mass connection... which is the grail of TV, after all. In order to let her into the tabernacle of your heart, you have to decide that this insistence on her part is somehow endearing. If you can do that (and it's not all that hard), she's right up there with any of the finest wranglers of video product in TV history.

Very much looking forward to future shows! Hopeful that this newest creative fling on Sarah's part gets a toehold and hangs in there!

Make it beautiful, Sarah!

First of all, I think Sarah's standup is great. Always have. This show however is disappointing and weird.

There's an agenda to a lot of it. It feels like the material is meant to teach me lessons and correct my behavior. The last thing I would want or expect from Sarah is to tell me how to be politically correct. Ugh.

Also when she interacts with her guests she's got this exaggerated way of responding to them that feels like sarcasm at first and then you realize she's not kidding. Ugh. Weird.

Having said that, there is definitely some good material in these shows that makes me laugh.

Terrific pilot episode everyone else seems to be expecting something run-of-the-mill and spoon fed where Sarah Silverman has always been one of the most unorthodox comedians with some of the most unorthodox TV show formulas if you could call them formulas . I found the Intro musical to be slow and annoying for the first 20 seconds but then funnier as the skit plays out and you begin to realize what she's actually trying to speak to. I thought the interview was great and I thought her visiting the family was great and also I even like the fake show host because it's pretty clear that there's a degree of truth to the things she says about late-night hosts.

I really enjoyed the first season of the show. She brought together 2 opposing parties, and had them discuss. Then came season 2 where she starts advertising her opinions, and belittling others. Still holding a little to bringing parties together, but her bullying dominated the show and makes it unwatchable. I know some like sitting around and making fun of other people, but I dont find that entertaining.

i would really love to say i wasted a half hour of my life watching this...."show". but instead i only wasted about maybe.... 23 minutes. it was the first episode, i went in with open eyes and mind. the only thing i learned is..... nothing. yeah i know it was not meant to be informative. but what i did observe is either your a sjw or your the butt of a joke.i cant even remember why Sarah is famous or why she is relevant, her brother starred in some good movies way back when. other than that...... i love America.... its not funny, maybe its not supposed to be. it was not engaging, maybe its not supposed to be. was it good? absolutely not. is there wiggle room for improvement? yes. could it blossom into a "good" show? maybe, but not likely. i will give it one more shot....