Nothing Left on Earth Excepting Fishes

Of all the episodes thus far this one has the most heart. This show has struggled with the balance between farcical humor, down to earth witty humor, and heart. The Office managed to thread all three needles simultaneously. This show has yet to achieve the balance, but this particular episode has a lot of heart. The unusually long closing sequence of the episode, which is dialogue-free, is the most emotionally complex and sincere moment of the series thus far, and is genuinely moving.

This episode is the epitome what we used to see in ST:TNG - a well fleshed out story that not only links us to last season, but is also a great stand-alone story. It has some of ST's 'Everyman' tropes in it, but the story still manages to not be preachy. That is a trap so many older franchises have fallen victim to lately (yes, I mean the current ST series and even a certain British sci-fi show we used to love). Seth has allowed Ed to (finally) move on with his personal life and, at the same time, display a willingness to show maturity and respect for his ex-wife in this episode. Ed is growing emotionally which is a hallmark of what Roddenberry did so well. His characters grew and, over time, changed so that they became more than a 2D character. They almost took on lives of their own, a fact we see at nearly all conventions nowadays. We also see this in Gordon in the episode (despite initially being motivated by baser desires). He realizes his value isn't dictated by a title but just being the best person he can be - a valued and vital member of the crew. Overall, Seth, Gene would be so proud of you!

The Orville is NOT a comedy series...it's a legit spacefaring adventure series with comedic elements. The last song of this show? Are you kidding me? No. Seth MacFarlane is a genius..."Hey, guys, I got this great idea for a comedy series, c'mon, it'll be fun" Corporate: "Ok, sure...you're good at comedy." Corporate: "HEY, what is this?? This seems more like an actual spaceship adventure action thingy series!" Seth: "Gotcha"

This episode is dramatic and heart warming. This show is by far better than ANYTHING on the air now and definitely better than than STD (Star Trek Discovery).

This episode manages to grip you emotionally. Honestly, I simply cannot wait for what's to come!!

A truly dramatic and heart warming episode. It has a twist that you won't see coming, and it will leave you with a smile...and possibly a tear. By far, my favorite episode so far.