danieljbarton

OK, so I absolutely love the books, I've read all TMI, TID and shadowhunter academy stories.

Surprisingly I was introduced to the books via the movie which I loved, for different reasons to the books. Obviously I didn't like all aspects of the movie so I thought a TV show would be better suited. Firstly, I prefer the film actors as these were how I based (and adapted) my view of the characters but I find the budget effects and acting quality an issue in the show IF you try to compare this to the books.

I guess my main point is that no, the film wasn't perfect but was closer to the books, yes the books were perfect and yes the TV show is completely different. Just enjoy it for what it is, a bit of fun :/

Having seen this film a few times now I have to remind myself to wait a little longer between viewings to try and preserve the beauty of the simplicity and complexity of this film. Yes, that is a contradicting statement but well found, the complexity of the characters own journeys could be seen as difficult to project in a relatively short film however the acting is very good, portraying the jubilations justly and the struggles just enough so that they aren't over dramatised. This coupled with the simple acting and feel of the overall experience. The simple telling of the messed up aspects of peoples lives hand in hand with it's greatest joys (love, family, loyalty etc.).

The casting is extremely good, giving life to each character of a well written script by Josh Boone, high praises for Kinnear, Wolff and Liberato. This film is well written, acted and directed even if feeling a little short (possibly adding to the satisfying effect, leaving the viewer wanting more).

Highly recommend along with 'Kevin' and 'The First Time'