infoed-01836
Joined Sep 2015
Welcome to the new profile
Our updates are still in development. While the previous version of the profile is no longer accessible, we're actively working on improvements, and some of the missing features will be returning soon! Stay tuned for their return. In the meantime, the Ratings Analysis is still available on our iOS and Android apps, found on the profile page. To view your Rating Distribution(s) by Year and Genre, please refer to our new Help guide.
Badges3
To learn how to earn badges, go to the badges help page.
Reviews26
infoed-01836's rating
The show is firing on all cylinders now. The actors have it down pat, the chemistry is better than ever. The story of the dirty apartment is a classic and Schwimmer does a great job with it as does Monica in the tag over the closing credits.
But one thing that bugs me is the Monica/Phoebe subplot about catering the funeral. Yes, the woman owed them money but is that really standard to walk into the middle of a funeral reception and ask for payment? Wouldn't it have made more sense if they, I don't know, just invoiced her or had her pay up front? Maybe this is standard amongst caterers for funerals but it came across as a bit strange.
But one thing that bugs me is the Monica/Phoebe subplot about catering the funeral. Yes, the woman owed them money but is that really standard to walk into the middle of a funeral reception and ask for payment? Wouldn't it have made more sense if they, I don't know, just invoiced her or had her pay up front? Maybe this is standard amongst caterers for funerals but it came across as a bit strange.
The original short story by M. R. James is so spooky and atmospheric but I found this adaptation to be lacking. To be sure, there are some excellent moments of dread and scares such as the silhouette of a figure on the beach and the nightmare the main character has about running for his life. Those sequences are well-paced and rise yo the occasion of the story. But there are long, long moments of nothing happening. And the climax of the story feels rushed and doesn't communicate the real terror of the story. Granted, in 1968, a TV production most likely did not have a huge budget but it wasn't just the effects. It was the way the sequence was filmed and the reaction of the man to just say, "Oh no. Oh no." over and over.
Not a favorite.
Not a favorite.
And do we are nearly at the end of the show. In 1091, 62 episodes was a respectable, but short, run. In the 2020s, 62 episodes is a normal full series.
This episode shows how Colleen McMurphy, now nearly two decades after she left Vietnam, is suffering post traumatic stress and needs to get help. It's a dark episode and ends with McMurphy asking, "When will it end?" We get flashback scenes set back on the base somewhere around the first half of season three as Hyers is still alive (though, as McMurphy states, he died shortly thereafter) as Colleen relives a horrific memory.
Dana Delaney does excellent work in this episode as Colleen finally faces down her trauma after avoiding it for so long. In the next, and final, episode, we meet up with McMurphy three years later at a reunion.
This episode shows how Colleen McMurphy, now nearly two decades after she left Vietnam, is suffering post traumatic stress and needs to get help. It's a dark episode and ends with McMurphy asking, "When will it end?" We get flashback scenes set back on the base somewhere around the first half of season three as Hyers is still alive (though, as McMurphy states, he died shortly thereafter) as Colleen relives a horrific memory.
Dana Delaney does excellent work in this episode as Colleen finally faces down her trauma after avoiding it for so long. In the next, and final, episode, we meet up with McMurphy three years later at a reunion.
Recently taken polls
1 total poll taken