wbieber
Joined Aug 2008
Welcome to the new profile
Our updates are still in development. While the previous version of the profile is no longer accessible, we're actively working on improvements, and some of the missing features will be returning soon! Stay tuned for their return. In the meantime, the Ratings Analysis is still available on our iOS and Android apps, found on the profile page. To view your Rating Distribution(s) by Year and Genre, please refer to our new Help guide.
Badges2
To learn how to earn badges, go to the badges help page.
Reviews2
wbieber's rating
I never read Nevin's novel. The TV series spoke for itself. As I recall it was three 2 hour episodes, but could be wrong.
It is a classic story about the exploring and opening of the American west. The cast of historical characters include Fremont, Bridger, Benton (Thomas Hart and daughter Jessie). Gen. Kearney. Staging and costuming were excellent. Love to see it on Blue Ray.
While it may have had a soap opera quality, it still was entertaining and historically close. I had a VHS recording of the show, but sadly accidentally erased it. I had a college history professor ask me if I had a copy as he wanted to use it in class.
I understand that Chamberlain and/or others were upset with the result/reviews and that was part of the reason the series never surfaced again in any form. Well, boohoo. Tchaikowsky disliked his Nutcracker ballet, but there weren't a lot of lawyers around in his time to sink it to the bottom of the lake - like CBS etc.etc.
It is a classic story about the exploring and opening of the American west. The cast of historical characters include Fremont, Bridger, Benton (Thomas Hart and daughter Jessie). Gen. Kearney. Staging and costuming were excellent. Love to see it on Blue Ray.
While it may have had a soap opera quality, it still was entertaining and historically close. I had a VHS recording of the show, but sadly accidentally erased it. I had a college history professor ask me if I had a copy as he wanted to use it in class.
I understand that Chamberlain and/or others were upset with the result/reviews and that was part of the reason the series never surfaced again in any form. Well, boohoo. Tchaikowsky disliked his Nutcracker ballet, but there weren't a lot of lawyers around in his time to sink it to the bottom of the lake - like CBS etc.etc.
A hokey but passable story about small town youth(s) who come to tinsel town to make their mark but then get tossed around by the nightclub business. Love interest, good guys, bad guys, happy ending, it's all there. Some good acting. Don't blame the actors for the script. Sher is timeless as a stage/screen presence and she can read any line she wants. Music score, excellent. Dance routines are OK but are badly fractured by the rapid clip changes. The film editor gets a C minus or maybe they couldn't hold their dance routines for more than 1.5 seconds.
I'm a song and dance kind of guy. Big screen, big sound all the way. But, we've seen it before. The ancestor to this genre, for me, was the best of them all - Caberet. With a nod to 'Chorus Line' and 'Chicago', nothing else has since come close on the screen. That doesn't mean this wasn't a good effort. But "Good efforts" are in the same category as "nice guys" who are supposed to finish last.
Don't wait for the small screen on this one. but go to the bargain matinée. As you leave give a quiet thought to Bob Fosse and Rob Marshall. There may be an Academy award nomination somewhere here, but I'm probably not smart enough to see it.
I'm a song and dance kind of guy. Big screen, big sound all the way. But, we've seen it before. The ancestor to this genre, for me, was the best of them all - Caberet. With a nod to 'Chorus Line' and 'Chicago', nothing else has since come close on the screen. That doesn't mean this wasn't a good effort. But "Good efforts" are in the same category as "nice guys" who are supposed to finish last.
Don't wait for the small screen on this one. but go to the bargain matinée. As you leave give a quiet thought to Bob Fosse and Rob Marshall. There may be an Academy award nomination somewhere here, but I'm probably not smart enough to see it.