rmsoran-1
Joined Sep 2009
Welcome to the new profile
Our updates are still in development. While the previous version of the profile is no longer accessible, we're actively working on improvements, and some of the missing features will be returning soon! Stay tuned for their return. In the meantime, the Ratings Analysis is still available on our iOS and Android apps, found on the profile page. To view your Rating Distribution(s) by Year and Genre, please refer to our new Help guide.
Badges2
To learn how to earn badges, go to the badges help page.
Ratings175
rmsoran-1's rating
Reviews5
rmsoran-1's rating
This movie is much more intelligent than most users and critics. The movie is much more intelligent than most users and critics. This film is much more intelligent than most users and critics. The screenplay is fantastic in nature, but nevertheless as scientifically accurate as the pioneers of futurology, of artificial living and thinking organisms, of neurosocial informatics, of rapid learning epigenetics could have imagined it. And del Toro demonstrates that he's a genius, one of the three most creative cineasts in Hollywood's history. This movie is much more intelligent than most users and critics :-) Really, really, really: This movie is much more intelligent than most users and critics :-)
Average artistic, directing and storytelling, not bad, but certainly also not good, given the Auswitz and the Holocaust context. The basic story had all ingredients for a very good resulting plot and accurate artistic translation.
Unfortunately is the director's approach filled with post-Shoa clichés that gives induce artificial, quality diminishing elements into the dramaturgy and authenticity of the resulting work.
Can be recommended to high school students from families that experienced the Holocaust and like to talk about. For those attracted by real historic accounts, be they even sentimental, it won't rise up to expectations. For all others: read better a good book
Unfortunately is the director's approach filled with post-Shoa clichés that gives induce artificial, quality diminishing elements into the dramaturgy and authenticity of the resulting work.
Can be recommended to high school students from families that experienced the Holocaust and like to talk about. For those attracted by real historic accounts, be they even sentimental, it won't rise up to expectations. For all others: read better a good book
Ohne Zweifel ist "Orange's Clockwork" ein Meilenstein des historischen Dokumentarfilms in Israel und Palästina. Exzellent recherchiert beleuchtet der Film bisher von beiden politischen Seiten bewusst ausgeblendete Fakten und Geschehnisse. Sowohl Israel als auch Palästina haben sich ihre eigene Geschichte zusammengeflickt, jeweils ein Patchwork aus Propaganda, Nationalismus und ausgesuchten Resten der vergangenen Wirklichkeit.Damit räumt der Film sehr überzeugend, da sehr fundiert, auf. Eigentlich stürzt der Film einige fundamentale Legenden der zionistischen Bewegung, Ideologie und Propaganda um. Etwas, was am überzeugendsten von Israelis gemacht werden kann.